|
rodney
Fort Defiance, AZ
|
BlaBlaBla wrote: <quoted text> A "code" developed by the U.S.Marines, not the code talkers. Code talkers were instructed what to say and how to say it because in many instances there was no corresponding word in Navajo. Navajo was selected because it was an un-written language, i.e no alphabet, just grunts and groans! You are all a bunch of d-u-m-m-i-e-s! And your point is? After all anyone can be instructed what to say and how to say it as well as what to do./.. why honor anybody according to your logic? Ok, so basically languages then are basically made up of grunts and groans. Did you know that according to linguists, again, people who have been basically told "what to say". have found that Navajo has more sounds than the average language like English and Spanish? So to use your "grunts and groans" the Navajo language has a few more "grunts and groans" than the Engilsh language.
|
|
PapaCito
|
Judged:
2
Much respect to the Code Talkers. What a great story, although wasn't Adam Beach in the movie?
|
|
Gemi
Fort Lee, VA
|
Kudos to the Code talkers who sacrificed a lot for us today. I'm sure in their day they just wanted to serve their country. And serve they did. Thank you, you are Heros in my eyes.
|
|
BlaBlaBla
Albuquerque, NM
|
real navajo wrote: <quoted text>sa ah Naaghaai ie dii doo ajil ii da doo hanidziz a doo dine bijolniih,inda jeehdzizti doo HOYOOCH IIDA.naana doo T'aa adzaagoo hojilne,indaa naana ei doo keyah doo baah aah jinizin da hey ashkii !! All English alphabet letters. You just proved my point.
|
|
BlaBlaBla
Albuquerque, NM
|
rodney wrote: <quoted text> And your point is? After all anyone can be instructed what to say and how to say it as well as what to do./.. why honor anybody according to your logic? Ok, so basically languages then are basically made up of grunts and groans. Did you know that according to linguists, again, people who have been basically told "what to say". have found that Navajo has more sounds than the average language like English and Spanish? So to use your "grunts and groans" the Navajo language has a few more "grunts and groans" than the Engilsh language. Maybe so but still no alphabet!
|
Joined: Nov 11, 2008
Comments: 166
|
BlaBlaBla wrote: <quoted text> All English alphabet letters. You just proved my point. HEY TKELE-CHO-G, that's because the Navajo language, like many Native American languages, was an oral language. For the slower people, YOU, in this thread that means it wasn't written down. Those English letters were put there by linguists working for our government. Your ignorance shows ever more with each post...keep it up!
|
|
sam
Albuquerque, NM
|
YOUR another graduate from the school of IDIOCY.. HUH? :P BlaBlaBla wrote: <quoted text> Maybe so but still no alphabet!
|
|
sam
Albuquerque, NM
|
and what service were YOU in? HMMM?? OR YOU just another WHITE WHINER? HUH? :P BlaBlaBla wrote: <quoted text> A "code" developed by the U.S.Marines, not the code talkers. Code talkers were instructed what to say and how to say it because in many instances there was no corresponding word in Navajo. Navajo was selected because it was an un-written language, i.e no alphabet, just grunts and groans! You are all a bunch of d-u-m-m-i-e-s!
|
|
|
|
California Girl
Santa Cruz, CA
|
BlaBlaBla wrote: <quoted text> Maybe so but still no alphabet! Yes, the Navajo language has its own alphabet: http://www.omniglot.com/writing/navajo.htm People are not writing in it on Topix because YOU wouldn't be able to read it. They are instead writing for phonetic pronunciation.
|
|
real navajo
Deming, NM
|
BlaBlaBla wrote: <quoted text> All English alphabet letters. You just proved my point. its called''NAVAJO LITERACY'',MAYBE YOU outta come to my hogan and we'll chat about ur problem.shinii yah?
|
|
Fed Up
Denver, CO
|
I for one am truly grateful for what the Navajo Code Talkers did for us. I also think it's been too long in coming to honor them for all they went through. My father fought in WWII also, but never got to meet any of these men,(that I know of) but he was also very proud of them. Anybody who has to show disrespect to these men is nothing but a traitor in my book. Maybe they are related to 'Hanoi Jane'?
|
|
real eyes
Tohatchi, NM
|
BlaBlaBla wrote: <quoted text> All English alphabet letters. You just proved my point. Which you still do not know the meaning of... you really should get off this post and do some research on somethign you really dont know about.
|
|
sam
Albuquerque, NM
|
Bla Bla Bla goes blA, bLA, BLA, BLA all the time...
LOL!
:P
|
|
navajo
Deming, NM
|
BlaBlaBla wrote: <quoted text> All English alphabet letters. You just proved my point. Dine' Be'iina' Hozhoogo Sila'.
|
|
|