Suspect indicted in murder of former ...

Suspect indicted in murder of former Palm Beach Gardens softbal...

There are 24 comments on the story from Jul 31, 2007, titled Suspect indicted in murder of former Palm Beach Gardens softbal.... In it, reports that:

A grand jury on Tuesday indicted a Palm Beach Gardens man in the strangling death of an 18-year-old softball player who, documents show, exchanged phone calls with him the morning he was accused of raping two ...

Join the discussion below, or

First Prev
of 2
Next Last


#2 Jul 31, 2007
So what if one of the women in the earlier rape case had a questionable reputation? Shenfeld had effective attorneys, and someone willing to bad-mouth one of these young ladies. If they had acted on just one of these girl's accounts, this tragedy might have been prevented.

United States

#3 Aug 1, 2007
I am so sick of all the negative comments Shenfeld's attorney is trying to say regarding Amanda and the other two VICTIMS of his client! All three of these girls were VICTIMS and as Dolly said, IT DOESN'T MATTER WHAT THEIR REPUTATION IS OR WAS!!!! Amanda Buckley is now dead and my daughter is left with a broken heart because her friend is gone forever. I could care less about Shenfeld, his boyhood blood clotting problems that he "didn't want anyone to know about"...blah blah blah... he is a MURDERER....PERIOD!

Delray Beach, FL

#4 Aug 1, 2007
they are right. hes a killer and thats all there is to say about him. law enforcement once again missed out on the chance to prevent the inevitable.

West Palm Beach, FL

#5 Aug 1, 2007
What happened is a shame but Ms. Buckley herself had a drug problem and was on probation. Doesn't make what happened to her right, but, with the State Attorneys track record this case will probably be plead out or filed as a lesser charge.....the criminal justice system has become just that, justice for the criminal only !

Spartanburg, SC

#6 Aug 1, 2007
Maybe he is a candidate for a dictorectomy. Anyone have a dull knife?

Lynwood, CA

#7 Aug 1, 2007
Please polish old sparky for this low life. In the immortal words of James Hetfield, and Metallica, let this piece of human garbage "RIDE THE LIGHTNING!"
execute him

Miami, FL

#8 Aug 1, 2007
white trash, execute him.
Jules Winfield

Palm City, FL

#9 Aug 1, 2007
This is just a Sad, Sad story. Poor girl, and poor family. There is just too much of this crap around here. It has to stop.

Unfortunetly Mary, the blame does not belong to law enforcement, it belongs more to the District Attorney, because they decide which crimes they want to prosecute, and which ones they don't. They didn't feel they could win it, so they didn't persue it. It sucks, I know.

Fort Lauderdale, FL

#10 Aug 1, 2007
execute him wrote:
white trash, execute him.
Abraham Goldstein

Pompano Beach, FL

#11 Aug 1, 2007
Jason Shenfeld's parents were holocaust survivors
Hip Hugger

Pompano Beach, FL

#12 Aug 1, 2007
Mr. Goldstein, was that remark necessary, do you feel better by heaping denegration on his parents after what they survived. Shame on you.
Nazi 4 Life

Hialeah, FL

#13 Aug 1, 2007
When is a Jew decendent the one that commit the crime there is not many blos here. Well, maybe if Hitler would off had finish his job this could off have been prevented...Here we are, I bet that if it was a prostitute, they would of have prosecute him. But a girl, that likes to sleep around is bad.. Give him the death penalty and mom and dad too they protect him once before and this time with a dead person in their home, they first went to get a lawyer before handling himn to authorities... Go Figures..

Lake Worth, FL

#14 Aug 1, 2007
I like the part in the previous article that stated Shenfeld's parents contacted an attorney before contacting police. These jack bags are no better than the piece of garbage they call their son.

West Palm Beach, FL

#16 Aug 1, 2007
I wonder what the parents REALLY knew about ole' Jason and his shenanigans with girls who " slept over ". Kinda odd to " lawyer up " before calling the police once you've found a body in a closet.....or.........did the disabled relative figure in her demise somehow... or Dad. Maybe a double or triple team on the poor girl. After all, wasn't big mama out of the house when the body was found. Again, odd that he would ride over to the lawyers house with the father......strange !!!!!!!!!!

“Yes, it's Steve”

Since: Jun 07


#17 Aug 1, 2007
Typical justice system - he was scum before this happened. Who knows how long his sick and deviant life has been going on like this before this murder. They should put his father's as-s and the family attorney's a-ss in jail too.
His (now dead) girlfriend decided to live on the wild side and wasn't overly sucessful in her endeavour. Can't have too much sympathy for her stupidity in choosing her lifestyle and friends.

Hollywood, FL

#18 Aug 1, 2007
The Shenfelds are not jewish, let alone holocaust survivors.
Abraham Goldstein wrote:
Jason Shenfeld's parents were holocaust survivors

Deerfield Beach, FL

#19 Aug 1, 2007
This guy looks alot older than they say....And it is hard to believe she was "drugging" as she had an athletic college scholarship lined up.....Maybe some recreational, ill advised, I'm just a kid use???

United States

#20 Aug 1, 2007
Still want to know how many women each man is allowed to rape and murder before the legal industry decides to take him out of circulation. The entity called Shenfeld should have been caged long ago, but the offense attorneys who kept him free did it the usual way - smearing the victim. Why are 'officers of the court' allowed to do this and get away with it?

The cretin defending entity Shenfeld now is pulling the same crap - because the latest victim talked to entity Shenfeld she somehow deserved to have him rape and strangle him. And of course Garbageheart Shenfeld peddles the crap that she was drugging; just another smear the victim tactic to suggest that she deserved it. Too many on this thread are drinking that Kool Aid. Proof?

Like to know how much these hate-monger attorneys would appreciate having the same treatment - rape, beating and then smearing in court. What you do comes back to you, jack. Learn it because someday soon, you'll be living it.

'Attorneys' that free garbage to kill by smearing victims are worship Satan and belong in hell.

United States

#21 Aug 1, 2007
Writing when angry isn't good. I meant to say: the nonhuman entity purporting to be an attorney that is now defending Shenfeld is suggesting that because she spoke to him on the phone at an early hour, she knew him well and this somehow excuses his conduct in raping and strangling her.

And that particular attorney worships Satan, the Taliban and Osama bin Load and should return to his father who art not in heaven now,and avoid the Judgement Day rush.

United States

#22 Aug 3, 2007
The ONLY reason Shenfeld's attorney is talking about Amanda Buckley's "drug use" or the other girl's "reputations" is to take the focus off his client.. PERIOD. The fact that Shenfeld killed Amanda is all that matters in this case. There shouldn't even be a case! She was in his closet, with bruises all over her body, she had severe trauma to her head and she had been severely raped! Obviously, the only place she had been was at Shenfeld's house, in his bedroom. That does not take brain surgery to figure out who did it. The why part doesn't even matter.

This guy is much bigger than Amanda and why don't we talk about HIS criminal past! What about the other two girls he duct taped and raped? What about the guy who called 911 because Shenfeld was following him in traffic and got out of his car and tried to attack him? Lets focus on all that for a moment! I am so sick of the so called justice system here. It will take the part of the people to make them realize we are not just going to sit back and be quiet any longer while our children are being raped and murdered!

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 2
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

St. Leo Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Review: Sajan, Dinar MD - Dinar Sajan MD (Sep '11) May 23 James Robert 2
Wild chickens & roosters destroy yards & are no... (Jan '15) May 22 TWILL1941 3
News Lawsuit Alleges Illegal Debt Collection Practic... (May '07) May 16 msgal 318
Has anyone heard the case about the family the ... (Mar '06) May 7 Hiswife 90
News Woman finds husband shot dead (Feb '08) Apr 29 housecall 74
Areas to avoid in Clearwater (Jul '10) Apr 27 Injoy 73
jcmakesmusic Apr '16 mario 1
More from around the web

Personal Finance

St. Leo Mortgages