Police: Three arrested in beating of ...

Police: Three arrested in beating of gay man in St. Cloud

There are 69 comments on the TwinCities.com story from May 24, 2011, titled Police: Three arrested in beating of gay man in St. Cloud. In it, TwinCities.com reports that:

St. Cloud police arrested three men early Monday after police say they beat another man because he was gay.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at TwinCities.com.

First Prev
of 4
Next Last
Food Stamp President

Elk Grove, CA

#64 May 25, 2011
trolls wrote:
<quoted text>
OK, but what if a black man beats you up because he hates whites. And in the during this assault he calls you the n-word? He is beating you up out of hate, but calls you a derogatory word for blacks. How do you prove the hate here? Had enough of these hypotheticals yet?:)
the answer is to charge all crimes with the harshness of a hate crime, why would society want some crimes tolerated more on some victims then others. A bottle over the head of a white male hurts just as much as a gay white male. Both victims feel the pain.
George

Minneapolis, MN

#65 May 25, 2011
john0990 wrote:
<quoted text>
I can't really imagine someone hitting someone else for literally no reason,...
You never heard of people on drugs or alcoholics hitting people for no reason? You've got alot to learn boy. Hate crime laws are a bunch of liberal BS.
john0990

Minneapolis, MN

#66 May 25, 2011
George wrote:
<quoted text>
You never heard of people on drugs or alcoholics hitting people for no reason? You've got alot to learn boy. Hate crime laws are a bunch of liberal BS.
Well, boy, I would say that the reason that addicts hit people is probably because they're high off their asses. I don't know, just a guess?
john0990

Minneapolis, MN

#67 May 25, 2011
Food Stamp President wrote:
<quoted text>the answer is to charge all crimes with the harshness of a hate crime, why would society want some crimes tolerated more on some victims then others. A bottle over the head of a white male hurts just as much as a gay white male. Both victims feel the pain.
Sure, they feel the same physical pain. And if that's all that happens, neither should be a hate crime. When a gay guy gets beat up, the fact that he's gay doesn't automatically make it a hate crime. If that was the case, how would we prosecute a gay guy who beat up another gay guy? Besides, in a practical way, I think the whole notion of sentencing someone to prison is more about punishing an offender than it is about compensating a victim.
George

Minneapolis, MN

#68 May 25, 2011
john0990 wrote:
<quoted text>
Well, boy, I would say that the reason that addicts hit people is probably because they're high off their asses. I don't know, just a guess?
No. It's because they're MEAN. Is being MEAN a HATE crime Bubba?
john0990

Minneapolis, MN

#69 May 25, 2011
George wrote:
<quoted text>
No. It's because they're MEAN. Is being MEAN a HATE crime Bubba?
Hey, how'd you know my name?!
Lost Cause

Saint Paul, MN

#70 May 25, 2011
john0990 wrote:
<quoted text>
Sure, they feel the same physical pain. And if that's all that happens, neither should be a hate crime. When a gay guy gets beat up, the fact that he's gay doesn't automatically make it a hate crime. If that was the case, how would we prosecute a gay guy who beat up another gay guy? Besides, in a practical way, I think the whole notion of sentencing someone to prison is more about punishing an offender than it is about compensating a victim.
whether we like it or not, when a gay man gets beat up and the perpretator gets a longer sentence then if he beat up an average white male in similiar fashion is pure bigotry which ironically the laws tries to eliminate.

practically speaking

Only real fair thing to do is eliminate hate crimes or charge all crimes with the severity of a hate crime.

Liberals do not want fair treatment they want special treatment and division.
john0990

Minneapolis, MN

#71 May 25, 2011
Lost Cause wrote:
<quoted text>
whether we like it or not, when a gay man gets beat up and the perpretator gets a longer sentence then if he beat up an average white male in similiar fashion is pure bigotry which ironically the laws tries to eliminate.
practically speaking
Only real fair thing to do is eliminate hate crimes or charge all crimes with the severity of a hate crime.
Liberals do not want fair treatment they want special treatment and division.
OK. Well, I'll leave the discussion to you, then. Have a good day, folks.
Food Stamp President

Elk Grove, CA

#72 May 25, 2011
Excellent post , let's end it here. Good debate all.
Lost Cause wrote:
<quoted text>
whether we like it or not, when a gay man gets beat up and the perpretator gets a longer sentence then if he beat up an average white male in similiar fashion is pure bigotry which ironically the laws tries to eliminate.
practically speaking
Only real fair thing to do is eliminate hate crimes or charge all crimes with the severity of a hate crime.
Liberals do not want fair treatment they want special treatment and division.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 4
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

St. Cloud Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Jonathan Conder (Feb '10) Jan 8 Cyco 23
News Minnesota Lottery Holding $1 Million Raffle Dra... Dec 28 hassen benhassen 6
to roger n (Oct '15) Nov '16 Harry 3
News Ex-governor Carlson endorses Independence Party... (Sep '10) Nov '16 Geezer Files 45
News Waite Park Police: Suspect Arrested After Rammi... Oct '16 Enzo49 10
News Police Respond To St. Cloud Mall On Reports Of ... Sep '16 Spotted Girl 189
News Minnesota stabbing Sep '16 southern at heart 8

St. Cloud Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

St. Cloud Mortgages