Long Island's best seafood restaurants

Full story: Newsday 33
Up there with a winning Lottery ticket and a reliable pizzeria, Long Island craves seafood. Read more
First Prev
of 2
Next Last
Chill63

Huntington Station, NY

#21 Mar 5, 2009
The best seafood on Long Island is at Oaklands in Hampton Bays. The best crab cakes ever. Pick any fish dish and get it blackened. Yum.
PL Resident

Palisades, NY

#22 Mar 5, 2009
Very bdisssapointing list and reviews. These reviews could have been written 20 years ago and probably were. Riverbay and Louie's are hit or miss, at best, and Legal Sea Food, on Long Island, is a mall phenomeneon and nearly always a miss. While these places remain popular, the consistancy, creativity and quality are extremely questionable. Paddy Mcgees is a treat and The Jolly Fisherman, while old fashioned, always servs a quality meal. There are much better places I could mention, but I wouldn't want to because if these (for the most part) smaller, better qulaity places start to see a lot of new traffic, I would have trouble getting my favorite table there.
PL Resident

Palisades, NY

#23 Mar 5, 2009
Sam, you're right on with this commentary on Riverbay. They are jerks at Riverbay, I used to be a regular there, but I wouldn't give them my $$$ anymore. Who needs to go out and spend good money on average food and be abused?
Sam wrote:
Nice list of restaurants, too bad you can't change the management and attitude of Riverbay. Be prepared to wait and wait and wait some more. Forget about honoring reservations, the chosen few friends and regulars will jump ahead of you. Plenty of other places with equally as good food and less of an attitude.
Unfortunately Omniscient

Forest Hills, NY

#25 Mar 5, 2009
Arthur Treacher's Fish and Chips. It's still the meal you can't make at home!

I always liked the chicken sandwich too.
Andrea

Medford, NY

#26 Mar 6, 2009
I love Seafooooooddddd
Tink

Massapequa Park, NY

#27 Mar 6, 2009
LI Press said Anyans. I went there. I don't think so. Better seafood at a diner.
BlueFish

Stamford, CT

#28 Mar 6, 2009
Bigelow's gives me agita;

Southside in Lidenhurst hands down for freshness, quality and bang for the buck!
Donna

Roslyn, NY

#29 Mar 6, 2009
They missed the "boat" by not included The Nautilus Cafe in Freeport. The food is amazing. Get on the mailing list and you can get some great coupons. Althought some of the places listed are good, I have to agree with the previous poster who questioned if the locations pay to be included.
justsayin

Jim Thorpe, PA

#30 Mar 9, 2009
I agree many of these places are overrated
and can be pricey...I think if Peter gets his meal Comped they get a good review!
This is a bad review, It is unfair to the many great seafood restaurants on LI...
This would need to be a more in depth look!
The story should have run for several weeks.
What a lazy story!!
hosehead

United States

#31 Mar 11, 2009
Either LI has one crappy collection of seafood restaurants or this writer is an idiot. Legal Seafood??? Are you kidding me?
Maryanne

Lake Grove, NY

#32 Jul 7, 2009
Crabby Dan's in Glen Head is a great local spot with outdoor seating. The entrees start at $12.95 and go up to $32.95 for surf and turf. They also have a great lobster special going on right now, its only $29.95 for a 2 1/2 lobster! its only monday- thursday.
Nemo

Fuzhou, China

#33 Jul 9, 2009
solefans.com is better!
Nemo

Fuzhou, China

#34 Jul 9, 2009

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 2
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Southampton Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Berry Plastics hit with layoffs (Jan '09) 14 hr piss off employee 31
News State education chief recommends state takeover... Mar 25 jtn 1
News Police officer arrested after fatal bicycle col... Mar 24 Ralph 2
News Northampton jurors hear police interview in Bil... Mar 24 buzzkill 2
News Woman files suit against Planet Fitness followi... Mar 24 heather 1
News Sheriff Carmen Massimiano Jr. Campaign funds us... (Mar '10) Mar 22 infamy is forever 79
Dan Kirouac and Steve Kirouac join forces for l... Mar 21 Massachusetts Mus... 1
Southampton Dating
Find my Match
More from around the web

Southampton People Search

Addresses and phone numbers for FREE

Personal Finance

Mortgages [ See current mortgage rates ]