What is the Definition of a rhetorical situation?

Posted in the South Hill Forum

guleilaytwithrye rspoon

Los Angeles, CA

#1 Nov 9, 2013
What is the Definition of a rhetorical situation?This (below) is a YA question and a classic rhetorical situation. It is presented as a question but it really just a speech intended to influence your opinion. So, when someone says "that was rhetorical", it means it was only an argument meant to convince you of a point. It does not call for a response because the speaker doesn't care about what you believe, only about convincing you.

__________
_
WHICH IS WORSE ?: Rand Paul's Libertarian Views or Rand Paul's Historical Ignorance?

Both are pretty bad, I suppose, but which is more harmful, which causes you more dismay?
Libertarian views are what caused Alan Greenspan to consider the secularization of Mortgages into very complex investment vehicles to be useful and valuable innovations in finance. Greenspan was a student of Ayn Rand, the founder of modern American Libertarian economics and philosophy.

Greenspan, like your professor in Econ 101, feels that any interference by government in the free market, always backfires by producing bad unintended consequences. This view was also held by Milton Friedman, Ronald Reagan and G.W. Bush.

So, the SEC officials were watching porn on the internet, and not Wall Street. Regulation is bad, so let's take out all the control rods and the economy will really get going -- that was the view.

We know now that the Libertarian view is bad economics and totally misguided, and just plain wrong.

What happens when you take out all the control rods is not a wonderful new day for the economy. Instead you get the implosion of the economy into a credit crisis that engulfs the whole world.

Even in small towns, people have heard about the Great Recession. What they don't know is that it is tied very closely to exactly the kind of libertarianism that Rand Paul espouses and wants to bring back.

So his libertarian views are a basis for some dismay.

But so is his historical ignorance. He seems almost more ignorant than Sarah Palin, and she was truly the Queen of Clueless.

To not know about Heart of Atlanta Motel -- which was the Supreme Court case that decided the issue of seating people at private lunch counters really reveals deep gaps in this man's education. He must have gone to High School. Did he take US History? How did he do he that course? Or was he raised maybe in Indonesia?

There are also plenty of cases that finally put to rest the issue of non-discrimination when selling a private house. Yes, you can sell your house. But if you put your house up for sale, no you cannot pick and choose the buyer based purely on their skin color. Rand Paul is still struggling with that. He's not retarded, but he's clearly some kind of a throwback. Hey, Rand, join USA, it's the country you live in! We are not coming to your planet.

He's also not sure that BP really ought to pay for the oil spill in the Gulf.

Rand Paul is ignorant and weird. That may not be a problem for a US Senator (see also Senator Inhoff), but surely it would dismay a rational voter if Rand Paul ran for higher office.

The Rand Paul story is a sad one for USA. It bespeaks our inability to learn the big picture factors that cause our national catastrophes, and it betokens the utter failure of our educational system at the High School and College levels.

Sarah Palin says "Now Rand Paul knows what it feels like to be me."

And for a reason, sweetheart, for a reason.
6 days ago
Report Abuse

Best Answer - Chose
gracolielaihpoin twier

Los Angeles, CA

#2 Nov 9, 2013
guleilaytwithryerspoon wrote:
What is the Definition of a rhetorical situation?This (below) is a YA question and a classic rhetorical situation. It is presented as a question but it really just a speech intended to influence your opinion. So, when someone says "that was rhetorical", it means it was only an argument meant to convince you of a point. It does not call for a response because the speaker doesn't care about what you believe, only about convincing you.

__________
_
WHICH IS WORSE ?: Rand Paul's Libertarian Views or Rand Paul's Historical Ignorance?

Both are pretty bad, I suppose, but which is more harmful, which causes you more dismay?
Libertarian views are what caused Alan Greenspan to consider the secularization of Mortgages into very complex investment vehicles to be useful and valuable innovations in finance. Greenspan was a student of Ayn Rand, the founder of modern American Libertarian economics and philosophy.

Greenspan, like your professor in Econ 101, feels that any interference by government in the free market, always backfires by producing bad unintended consequences. This view was also held by Milton Friedman, Ronald Reagan and G.W. Bush.

So, the SEC officials were watching porn on the internet, and not Wall Street. Regulation is bad, so let's take out all the control rods and the economy will really get going -- that was the view.

We know now that the Libertarian view is bad economics and totally misguided, and just plain wrong.

What happens when you take out all the control rods is not a wonderful new day for the economy. Instead you get the implosion of the economy into a credit crisis that engulfs the whole world.

Even in small towns, people have heard about the Great Recession. What they don't know is that it is tied very closely to exactly the kind of libertarianism that Rand Paul espouses and wants to bring back.

So his libertarian views are a basis for some dismay.

But so is his historical ignorance. He seems almost more ignorant than Sarah Palin, and she was truly the Queen of Clueless.

To not know about Heart of Atlanta Motel -- which was the Supreme Court case that decided the issue of seating people at private lunch counters really reveals deep gaps in this man's education. He must have gone to High School. Did he take US History? How did he do he that course? Or was he raised maybe in Indonesia?

There are also plenty of cases that finally put to rest the issue of non-discrimination when selling a private house. Yes, you can sell your house. But if you put your house up for sale, no you cannot pick and choose the buyer based purely on their skin color. Rand Paul is still struggling with that. He's not retarded, but he's clearly some kind of a throwback. Hey, Rand, join USA, it's the country you live in! We are not coming to your planet.

He's also not sure that BP really ought to pay for the oil spill in the Gulf.

Rand Paul is ignorant and weird. That may not be a problem for a US Senator (see also Senator Inhoff), but surely it would dismay a rational voter if Rand Paul ran for higher office.

The Rand Paul story is a sad one for USA. It bespeaks our inability to learn the big picture factors that cause our national catastrophes, and it betokens the utter failure of our educational system at the High School and College levels.

Sarah Palin says "Now Rand Paul knows what it feels like to be me."

And for a reason, sweetheart, for a reason.
6 days ago
Report Abuse

Best Answer - Chose.
This site can help you finding the best option for you:@www.credit-solutions.info
Rhetor Rick

Lutherville Timonium, MD

#3 Nov 9, 2013
Vatz demolishes Bitzer and "The Rhetorical Situation."

Completely disinterested source...

Check out Vatz and Bitzer.

ztav

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

South Hill Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
VA VA Property Tax Exemption for Elderly and Disab... (Oct '10) Tue gwsbadass 1,360
Debate: Obama-Marriage - Bracey, VA (May '12) Sep 16 CallieFoster210 3
VA VA Property Tax Exemption for Veterans, Question 2 (Oct '10) Aug '14 Time Flys 2,545
VA Missing Va. Girl Alive, Man In Custody (Dec '10) Apr '14 Jim 1,432
JOIN AJAKAJA BROTHERHOOD FOR WEALTH,FAME,AND PR... (Feb '14) Feb '14 Mr Desmond Salami 1
Sabrina Humple (Feb '14) Feb '14 Yoyo 1
Am looking for suggarmum plz whats app m 002773... (Jan '14) Jan '14 Ben 10 1

South Hill Jobs

South Hill People Search

Addresses and phone numbers for FREE

South Hill News, Events & Info

Click for news, events and info in South Hill

Personal Finance

Mortgages [ See current mortgage rates ]