Sayville man gets 4 months for killin...

Sayville man gets 4 months for killing cat -- Animals, New York

There are 98 comments on the Newsday story from Apr 3, 2008, titled Sayville man gets 4 months for killing cat -- Animals, New York. In it, Newsday reports that:

For throwing his ex-girlfriend's cats across a bedroom, killing one of the felines and seriously injuring another, a Sayville man was sentenced Thursday to 4 months in jail.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at Newsday.

Marilyn

Irvine, CA

#23 Apr 3, 2008
Laid off and drunk wrote:
haw haw haw
kat killa
I hates katz. he shoulda thrown them under a lawnmower.
Then thrown you next!
NYC

San Francisco, CA

#24 Apr 3, 2008
No the Navys fault wrote:
Please don't make the argument that this guy is indicative of the men and women serving in our armed forces.
One bad apple should not spoil the barrel.
You are correct, instead we should also look at all the troops coming home who have killed their spouses, or the ones in Iraq that are also in gangs, or the ones in Abu Ghraib or..........
Question

AOL

#26 Apr 3, 2008
4 months is not enough time for this ingrate! I would hardly call this justice. Maybe when this sicko hurts a child then the courts can look back and relize they had a chance to keep the creep locked up. Only time will tell, and it usually does.
george

United States

#28 Apr 3, 2008
consider this wrote:
if he treats inocent animals that way, imagine how he must treat humans.
only 4 months?
can someone tell me why we put up with this in our society? tell me, why do we need to have this guy among us?
exactly why are we obligated to have him among us?
any rational society would banish this guy to someplace far, far away from the rest of us. at the very least they would not give a mere 4 months.
Because it's over! The liberal scum have got the ship. They, through their stupidy and degenercy and through organizations like the ACLU and the various Gay Rights and other liberal organizations who run the media which controls everyhing you see, everything you read, everything you hear, etc., run the show here in America. We lost.
not again

Great Neck, NY

#29 Apr 3, 2008
Disgusted wrote:
<quoted text>
Why not, John White is a FREE man for taking the life of a teenage boy. Makes sense to give someone who kills a four legged fur ball time.
any rational society would banish this guy to someplace far, far away from the rest of us. at the very least they would not give a mere 4 months.
good point our justice system is going to the dog's or should i say cat's!!!! Any one for some Chinese take out tonight?
JAT

Long Beach, NY

#30 Apr 3, 2008
Question wrote:
4 months is not enough time for this ingrate! I would hardly call this justice. Maybe when this sicko hurts a child then the courts can look back and relize they had a chance to keep the creep locked up. Only time will tell, and it usually does.
Unfortunately 4 months is extremely harsh. A cat is property. It is the same as breaking a TV. Who gets 4 months for a criminal mischief?
kile

United States

#31 Apr 3, 2008
They Navy says "they will overlook his indescretion" - just pathetic. But I guess our depraved military needs scum like him to staff prisons in Iraq like Abu Gharib!
I LOVE ANIMALS

Buffalo, NY

#33 Apr 3, 2008
They should have cut each of this guys hands off so he doesn't do this to any animal again especially a cat!
Daniel Ciccairo Jr

Farmingdale, NY

#34 Apr 3, 2008
I am only worth an extra year in jail, as compared to a cat. That is because I was a punk and my daddy is a racist.
Johnny

Atlanta, GA

#37 Apr 3, 2008
Laid off and drunk wrote:
haw haw haw
kat killa
I hates katz. he shoulda thrown them under a lawnmower.
Hard to see why you're laid off.
Johnny

Atlanta, GA

#38 Apr 3, 2008
no testimony wrote:
What's with the owner in all of this? She refused to testify and that's why his charges weren't so bad. Obviously she didn't care enough to see that her cat's killer actually serve some time.
Maybe she is terrified of him.
Ned

Patchogue, NY

#39 Apr 3, 2008
If you own an animal aren't you allowed to kill it?
Maybe he should say that he paid for them?
This way the judge will have to let him off.
Yay

United States

#40 Apr 3, 2008
george wrote:
<quoted text>Because it's over! The liberal scum have got the ship. They, through their stupidy and degenercy and through organizations like the ACLU and the various Gay Rights and other liberal organizations who run the media which controls everyhing you see, everything you read, everything you hear, etc., run the show here in America. We lost.
Now that is funny. Gay rights and the ACLU have nothing to do with what happened here. Nothing nothing nothing. If you were a real conservative you would think that all these liberal organizations would be calling for the hanging of this person(that tends to be their MO, that liberals value other lives over human lives).

Keep with the polarized thinking. It's the far right wingers and the far left wingers ruining things. They think everything is a black and white issue when in reality almost EVERYTHING has a grey area. They've got many of us divided and leaving us sane, grey area recognizing people with no candidate worth voting for because the only way to get elected anything is to declare yourself as part of one of these polarized groups.

The cat killer by the way, needs to undergo serious anger management, maybe a little bit more jail time for what he did. I won't compare what he did to the serial killer comparison made. Serial killers when they are young are not flinging animals off of walls out of rage and accidentally killing them. What he did was horrible, but I will not value a pet's life the same as a person's.
Kosher Kat

Melbourne, Australia

#41 Apr 3, 2008
Lucky for him the cat wasn't a jew. They would have charged him with a hate crime.
I LOVE ANIMALS

Buffalo, NY

#42 Apr 3, 2008
I wish this a-hole looser would take his own life he is worthless and will burn in hell for what he did to the cats! I HATE HIM!
No Comment

Levittown, NY

#43 Apr 3, 2008
Litter Box wrote:
Animal cruelty is part of the psychological profile and pattern of serial killers. I wonder when this jerk will start his killing spree.....
When he has access to firearms in the military.
FROM DEER PARK

Mastic, NY

#44 Apr 3, 2008
Laid off and drunk wrote:
haw haw haw
kat killa
I hates katz. he shoulda thrown them under a lawnmower.
YOU SHOULD BE THROWN UNDER A LAWN MOWER YOU DUMB AS* SHUT UP ALREADY!
FROM DEER PARK

Mastic, NY

#45 Apr 3, 2008
Daniel Ciccairo Jr wrote:
I am only worth an extra year in jail, as compared to a cat. That is because I was a punk and my daddy is a racist.
tell me, do you think you're ever going to grow up, why don't you turn off your computer so no one has to read what you're typing because none of it makes any sense as*wipe
nancy

United States

#46 Apr 3, 2008
Yay wrote:
<quoted text>
Now that is funny. Gay rights and the ACLU have nothing to do with what happened here. Nothing nothing nothing. If you were a real conservative you would think that all these liberal organizations would be calling for the hanging of this person(that tends to be their MO, that liberals value other lives over human lives).
Keep with the polarized thinking. It's the far right wingers and the far left wingers ruining things. They think everything is a black and white issue when in reality almost EVERYTHING has a grey area. They've got many of us divided and leaving us sane, grey area recognizing people with no candidate worth voting for because the only way to get elected anything is to declare yourself as part of one of these polarized groups.
The cat killer by the way, needs to undergo serious anger management, maybe a little bit more jail time for what he did. I won't compare what he did to the serial killer comparison made. Serial killers when they are young are not flinging animals off of walls out of rage and accidentally killing them. What he did was horrible, but I will not value a pet's life the same as a person's.
While your remark is quite wordy, it reeks of the fact that you must be on a regiment of feel good drugs that delude you into thinking that you are cabable of rational thought. Nothing could be further from the truth. You are a moron and just don't get it! Look! It is only the third of the month, I'm sure your meds are in the mail!
Unreal

Bronx, NY

#47 Apr 3, 2008
NYC wrote:
<quoted text>
You are correct, instead we should also look at all the troops coming home who have killed their spouses, or the ones in Iraq that are also in gangs, or the ones in Abu Ghraib or..........
We are still in Iraqi because of cowards like you...COWARD...say bad things about situations you have no idea about, so you can feel good about your cowardis. Cowardis is the first one of the sins Jesus listed up in the book of Revelation!!! But you pobablity don't believe in God...so you latch on to someother useless cause to make believe you have purpose. Global warming freak!!!

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Sayville Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Animal Hoarder Busted on Long Island (Apr '13) 1 hr Lynda 25
News Southampton Town Police reports (Feb '09) 4 hr SH Brokerage 4
all drownings (Jun '07) 19 hr Dicky Schwimmer 79
Don Woolley (Dec '10) Wed Gaylord 14
News Suffolk votes to pay off $10.8M settlement over... Wed commoner 1
Memories Of Old Ronkonkoma (Jul '09) Wed Scott battelie de... 125
Review: Fairharbor Owners (Feb '15) Nov 18 Sweet 35

Sayville Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

Sayville Mortgages