Review: Pennicas Pizza
First Prev
of 2
Next Last

Tenafly, NJ

#1 Sep 11, 2009
Awesome food a real family place!! owner is the cook people are great. Food is the best anywere around

United States

#2 Nov 5, 2009
I'm not a big pizza person but I could eat Penneca pizza everyday! Perfect amount of cheese/ crust/sauce. I won't eat pizza anywhere else

New Rochelle, NY

#3 Nov 11, 2009
Excellent food!! Great Pizza, and they are always nice when you call! I am so happy they opened.
Patty McBrady

United States

#4 Dec 18, 2009
Vinny is just as hot and delcious as the pizza! Go try a taste ;)

Farmingville, NY

#5 Jun 14, 2010
Great food, friendly people we order from them all the time!

East Hampton, NY

#6 Feb 25, 2011
I would never eat pizza at pennicas again. The regular pizza tasted like it was from the supermarket and the food in the showcase looked like it was there for a week. No thank u. I think ill pass

East Hampton, NY

#7 Jul 11, 2011
I couldn't agree less with Jimmy above. Every single thing i have ordered from Pennica's has been off the charts delicious! Their food looks fresh out of the oven no matter what time I go in there. Delicious food, friendly service, family style place. What more could you ask for?

Randolph, NJ

#8 Nov 22, 2011
Jimmy must be from another world!! I have to say Pennicas is the total opposite of what he said. We eat there allot and everything is always fresh fresh!! By far Pennicas is the best pizza around!!
Jeff Spicoli

Torrington, CT

#9 Nov 26, 2011
Is it me or does every chicken parm hero taste the same no matter where you go? Will one pizza owner ever dare to be different and not get the same chicken from restaurant depot as everyone else does??

Randolph, NJ

#10 Dec 5, 2011
I know for a fact Pennicas pizza gets NO meat from the depo. All of their meat comes from a small family owned butcher shop!!
Adam C.

Frisco, TX

#11 Dec 7, 2011
That is true Jeff. The breading is the dead give away. I worked in 3 different pizzerias through high school and all used precooked frozen chicken. People aren't stupid give them fresh quality ingredients and they'll come back and pay.. bottom line!
pizza lover

Huntington Station, NY

#12 Feb 11, 2012
Pennica's food is ok. We have switched to Gino's down the block which we find is much better.
pizza lover

Huntington Station, NY

#13 Feb 12, 2012
pennicas is no more. New owner now.
jeff spicoli

Port Jefferson Station, NY

#14 Feb 12, 2012
Chicken Parm Update: I ordered a CP from Lombardis market and it was the real deal chicken and it was awesome! Pizza shop owners in the area need to take a lesson.
Pizza Girl

Woodbury, NY

#15 Feb 15, 2012
I've eaten at Pennica's Pizza before and I have to say that I am happy that it is under new ownership. The food tastes so much better and the product is made from FRESH produce. The food that they display looks delicious and the service is much better than Pennica's.

Woodbury, NY

#16 Feb 15, 2012
I recently ate here and the food was great! We took my son here for his birthday and he and his friends had a ball! He got to make his own pizza. Excellent service! New owners as well!
Brock Landers

San Mateo, CA

#17 Feb 16, 2012
Ok it's obvious the last two posts were from the new owners.

Randolph, NJ

#18 Mar 12, 2012
LOL So obvious those posts are from the new owners... Sad that they seem to be so desperate!!
Jeff Spicoli

Port Jefferson Station, NY

#19 Mar 12, 2012
Hey Pizza Girl & Brown family, I'm coming in for a chicken parm let's see if u get it right!
Pizza Girl

Woodbury, NY

#20 Mar 23, 2012
That's funny because I actually have lived in Ronkonkoma my entire life and my family and I have been customers for years as that place has changed owners over the years. I was strictly voicing my opinion in hopes to giving new customers an honest review of the new owners. Sorry that seems to bother you others who are on here for other purposes than rating food.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 2
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Ronkonkoma Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Sperm Counts Continue to Decline in Western Nat... 37 min Good News 1
News LI's worst offenders (Jan '07) 5 hr Frank Lehmann 44
all drownings (Jun '07) 21 hr Red Man 50
ralphs fishing station (Apr '12) Mon Ralphie 20
Hookups in sayville (Jul '16) Sat Philly Freeze 39
Moving To Patchogue ? (Oct '14) Jul 19 Peter Bamboli 10
News Arrest in bank robbery string (Apr '14) Jul 19 sussie 5

Ronkonkoma Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

Ronkonkoma Mortgages