Worst judge in Rome?

Worst judge in Rome?

Created by Pollster on Mar 21, 2012

190 votes

Click on an option to vote

Judge Tami Colston

Judge Bryant Durham

Judge John Niedrach

Judge Walter Matthews

jen

Rome, GA

#1 Apr 3, 2012
This is going to the bottom of the list with no comments.
Criers

Rome, NY

#2 Apr 3, 2012
Worst, how dumb is this thread? All the trash who didnt get their way in court for being a criminal,,T Y P I C A L.
Lol

Lindale, GA

#3 Apr 11, 2012
Wow
boshcreek

Athens, GA

#4 Apr 26, 2012
Lol wrote:
Wow
lol
July

Chickamauga, GA

#5 Jul 4, 2012
If this thread is so stupid, Why are people voting?
I'm sure the answer will be because they're all criminals, but not all those judges do criminal cases. LOL
MY OPINION

Gadsden, AL

#6 Jul 4, 2012
NIEDRACH is a male chauvinist bastard. Men are given lighter judgements than women. Im not a criminal i have just been in his courtroom and seen it first hand.
Crassaction

Rome, GA

#7 Jul 8, 2012
having the opportunity to work around them all on a regular basis, I will make a comment. All of them have their pluses and minuses and apparently all have their detractors.

There is only one who suffers from a permanent and terminal case of "Robe-itis". That would be Judge Matthews
Crassaction

Rome, GA

#8 Jul 8, 2012
July wrote:
If this thread is so stupid, Why are people voting?
I'm sure the answer will be because they're all criminals, but not all those judges do criminal cases. LOL
Actually July, all Superior Court Judges do criminal cases
rocky

Rome, GA

#9 Apr 21, 2015
July wrote:
If this thread is so stupid, Why are people voting?
I'm sure the answer will be because they're all criminals, but not all those judges do criminal cases. LOL
LOL But yes all four do criminal cases. Get your facts straight.
ManinBlack

Rome, GA

#10 Apr 25, 2015
MY OPINION wrote:
NIEDRACH is a male chauvinist bastard. Men are given lighter judgements than women. Im not a criminal i have just been in his courtroom and seen it first hand.
I know Jack Niedrach and have for years....He is the best Judge at the Courthouse by far...Fair and even in everything he does...He is also the only Judge of 4 who was elected on merit and not appointed to the position first...I have been the victim of malicious judges in the past, so I know where the writer is coming from...However, Judge Niedrach is not one of them....
Guest

Rome, GA

#11 Apr 26, 2015
Judge J. Bryant Durham is by far the worst judge in Rome, Georgia.

Prior to becoming a Floyd County Superior Court Judge. Durham worked for the law firm of Cox, Byington, Corwin, Neidrach & Durham.

I was a plaintiff in a case, and the defendant had Christopher P. Twyman as their attorney.

Christopher P. Twyman currently works for the same Cox, Byington law firm of Cox, Byington, Brumlow, and Twyman.

Despite the Defendant not having any evidence to prove their case or disprove mine. Judge Durham didn't even listen to the case. I believe there was an extreme bias due to the connection listed above.
Street_Baller34

Rome, GA

#12 May 1, 2015
I had the same out come as guest did when going in front of durham. didn't know that he came from the same law firm Twyman works for. I was thinking I had a bad atty.
Larry M

Rome, GA

#13 May 16, 2015
Judge Durham leading the worst judge poll for Rome, GA. Well Deserved!
Sarah B

Kingston, GA

#14 Jun 6, 2015
Now I wish I had Twyman when I went in front of Durham.
Targarain King

Cedartown, GA

#15 Jun 9, 2015
rocky wrote:
<quoted text>
LOL But yes all four do criminal cases. Get your facts straight.
Yes they all do a split docket. Criminal/Civil. Educate your selves. Not all commenters are criminals. Some ate insiders with compelling and factual knowledge. Get a life.....
Targarain King

Cedartown, GA

#16 Jun 9, 2015
@ Guest. There is always a conflict in Rome Courts. They all have worked together in different firms throughout their time as attorneys. Get an attorney from another attorney far from Rome if you have litigation. They all have agendas, some conflicting some not so. Either way, you're screwed in the Rome Circuit, unless you go out of the area for representation.
George Patton

Rome, GA

#17 Tuesday Jul 14
The honorable judge John Niedrach is the most blatantly dangerous (I believe) for one big reason: he has had total endorsement by every court from the Ga. Appeals up thru the Fed 11th cir. on his establishing the precedent by revoking of a probationer for "failing to admit guilt"; All the high emulated him by ignoring the actual subjects and the SPECIFIC hearing appealed; It appears that he has total immunity from the law or all due process. All the high courts refused to rule on the actual subject of the challenge, denying such by applying their universally unsupported denials to UNRELATED previous cases, not even mentioning the specific due process violations challenged (requirement to admit guilt to acquitted charges, missing a 'counseling session in Marietta while incarcerated on the probation warrant in the Floyd jail). So he has been granted a license to use the Constitution as toilet paper, and this effects every defendant in Ga. who expects due process.

Judge Niedrach even excused the state from responding in a pro se appeal hearing, and argued their case for them, even changing the actual case at bar and ignoring all properly made pro-se objections with no response whatsoever (it's in the transcript). The Appeals court wn't even back their own previous ruling regarding the specific probationer not having to admit guilt ( http://law.justia.com/cases/georgia/court-of-... ) 253 Ga. App. 603, 2002. The good judge revoked the specific probationer in that later challenge specifically for the charge of "failure to admit guilt", despite such being specifically prohibited in that 2002 appeals court case by his attorney's unexploited victory 7 yrs eariler, that he had 'overlooked' informing him of at the time of his original revocation for 'failing to admit guilt'.

The probationer's lawyer htat had won the action for him earlier had actually not informed him of it, and 'overlooked' using his own victory to defeat a revocation for "failing to admit guilt."
He can be found in the case. The judge can do nothing that local lawyers don't allow, which is a common theme. Beware getting a lawyer locally. Respectfully........
Anonymous

Rome, GA

#18 Tuesday Jul 14
ManinBlack wrote:
<quoted text>
I know Jack Niedrach and have for years....He is the best Judge at the Courthouse by far...Fair and even in everything he does...He is also the only Judge of 4 who was elected on merit and not appointed to the position first...I have been the victim of malicious judges in the past, so I know where the writer is coming from...However, Judge Niedrach is not one of them....
Respectfully, you have not a clue. I hope he does not owe you any money. He has no concept of what the constitution or due process means, and he likes to make the state's argument for them. I don't know about women v men sentencing, but I do know about how due process is abused in there, and about how he has no familiarity wiht the law. From my research he was a civil court judge wiht little if any criminal court combat experience (but im open to information on that), but from what i've seen, he has no familiarity with actual state law, and I highly recommend checking the max law on sentencing. Like the rest of the state courts, he has no regard for law or due process as applies to probationers it appears, and is so biased for the state that he tends to make their arguments for them while excusing them from doing so, at least in one case for sure. Next time you see him, how 'bout informing him of the process of dealing with objections, and how to answer them, either yay or nay, but not "sit down."

Respectfully.......

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Rome Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
presidential candidates. 10 hr James 2
Jeffersons Tue precious 13
Zorba's (Jul '14) Tue Triedit 23
try as an adult? Tue STOPCRIMENOW 1
confederate flags and monuments. Mon TOW Gunner 15
Donald McGarr ? Jul 26 looking 3
Dead trees in Peek's Park Jul 24 EsomBill 8
More from around the web

Personal Finance

Rome Mortgages