Rumors of Rory Hall and/or Friends in...
is it odd

Thelma, KY

#62 Apr 30, 2012
MoonShyne wrote:
<quoted text>
As another fellow Ontarian praying for the safe return of this girl, I hope there are some answers soon. Someone, somewhere knows what happened. I hope their conscience prevails and they do the right thing and talk. Something as simple as an anonymous email to the family or the police could finally give the family some peace. I cannot imagine how horrible it would be to have a loved one missing and never know what happened to them. At the very least, this girl deserves a proper burial if she is dead and the family some resolve so they can move on and have some closure and much deserved answers in this case. If you know something or know someone who does, do the right thing and speak up. Put yourself in their shoes, if it was your loved one, you'd want to know either way what happened.
Does anyone find it odd that she has never been listed as a missing person by the KSP?

“lmao I'm a flamer”

Since: Nov 10

Point Pleasant, WV

#63 Apr 30, 2012
Just stopped in to read a few. I am a friend to a relative of hers. So Myrtle, I just want you to know how sorry I am, and that I hope this gets put to rest soon. Never give up, and remember to look at the wolf in sheep's clothing as well. "He was such a nice man" comes to mind to those who live next to serial killers.

Since: Nov 11

Toronto, Canada

#64 May 1, 2012
MoonShyne wrote:
<quoted text>
As another fellow Ontarian praying for the safe return of this girl, I hope there are some answers soon. Someone, somewhere knows what happened. I hope their conscience prevails and they do the right thing and talk. Something as simple as an anonymous email to the family or the police could finally give the family some peace. I cannot imagine how horrible it would be to have a loved one missing and never know what happened to them. At the very least, this girl deserves a proper burial if she is dead and the family some resolve so they can move on and have some closure and much deserved answers in this case. If you know something or know someone who does, do the right thing and speak up. Put yourself in their shoes, if it was your loved one, you'd want to know either way what happened.
Hey fellow Ontarian - fancy meeting you here - how's things in beautiful downtown Keswick
MoonShyne

Keswick, Canada

#65 May 2, 2012
Have you ever contacted America's Most Wanted to see if they could help by running her story?

I'm so sorry your going through this. As a mom myself I can't imagine what your going through. I really hope you get answers and hopefully the police will get off their asses and do their jobs!! Pisses me off because if it was some rich girl from the city they'd have done a lot more to find her.

Never give up and I pray you get answers soon!
MoonShyne

Keswick, Canada

#66 May 2, 2012
mytakeonit ontario wrote:
<quoted text>
Hey fellow Ontarian - fancy meeting you here - how's things in beautiful downtown Keswick
Pretty good my friend :) Can't wait for the weather to stay nice and be able to get out on the lake. Where abouts are you from?
MoonShyne

Keswick, Canada

#67 May 2, 2012
OOps nevermind, I just noticed your from Sudbury. Is there still snow on the ground up there? I was up in Timmins last year and we stayed in Sudbury a few days. Went and saw the big nickel lol.

Since: Nov 11

Toronto, Canada

#68 May 2, 2012
MoonShyne wrote:
OOps nevermind, I just noticed your from Sudbury. Is there still snow on the ground up there? I was up in Timmins last year and we stayed in Sudbury a few days. Went and saw the big nickel lol.
No , no snow - thank God - have you been on any other Topix forums - I've mostly been hangin out on the Holly Bobo one(Parsons TN)Very mysterious case. Check it out. Thoughts and prayers to Crystal's Family and Friends
Anonymous

Richmond, KY

#69 May 24, 2012
Myrtle R wrote:
There has been so many rumors since Crystal Gayle Branham Hall has went missing almost three years ago. It seems to me that most of those rumors include the name of Rory Hall and a friend causing her disapperance. I personally don't know him, but would love to speak to him about his and Crystal's relationship and the last time he saw her. Alot of people have spoken to me freely about their relationships with Crystal and the last time they saw her. I have spoken to the police about many rumors that I have heard, but they seem not to be doing much. If anyone knows Rory, is a friend of his,or has heard of these rumors, I would really appreciate any information. I have a facebook page dedicated to her under her name Crystal Gayle Branham Hall which you can leave a message on or let me know if you would like to speak to me personally. I am not trying to place blame or slander anyone, I just want to know what happened to my baby. I am not even that concerned with any prosecution now, I just want to know where she is so I can bring her home and have closure for her kids and the rest of the family. Someone has to know, look into your heart, look at your daughter, mother, neice, family member and think what it would be like to not know if they were dead or alive, out in the cold, starving...It's the worst feeling a person can feel... Please I just want to bring my baby home, 3 years has been way too long.
The night Chris Lyons died he said that he was there when rory killed crystal. They were all on ky ave. and rory and crystal were arguing. Chris never said how rory murdered her but that he helped rory drive to an old mine to hide her. I am so sorry for your pain.

Since: May 10

Location hidden

#70 May 24, 2012
Anonymous wrote:
<quoted text>The night Chris Lyons died he said that he was there when rory killed crystal. They were all on ky ave. and rory and crystal were arguing. Chris never said how rory murdered her but that he helped rory drive to an old mine to hide her. I am so sorry for your pain.
I really hope this isn't a lie because it would tear her families hearts apart. If it is the truth you need to tell the police or her mother were to find her.
someone with info

Richmond, KY

#72 May 24, 2012
yes i have heard the same thing i know rory hall he is a piece of shit it; hard to tell what he will do he does live up island creek y can see him alot in town his family over hall construction i beleive. the court system does know him it's just werid how he goes to jail so much and get back out yes his family has money so it's probaly bravery. but,to crystal mother i know her i seen her at a few days before she went missing and from my understanding she was areound him and then i heard chris laynes i believe that his name craterface...well hun she was a sweet girl i would be getting some lie detector because her sister friend rebecca been talking alot and saying she know she gone,I know natasha is ur daughter to but i don't understand how she not showing any remorse about what happened and rebeccaeven talking about it i thing they need to be given i lie detector test rebecca didn't say stuff about rory hall and chris so that would be my best bet for u LIE DETECTOR TEST for RORY,CHRIS,REBECCA,And NATASHA.
someone with info

Richmond, KY

#73 May 24, 2012
I Didn't know chris died but that so werid because rebecca anderson knows more info and crystal sister natasha does to they need to be in question rebecca been telling people rory killed her to and her know it
someone with info

Richmond, KY

#74 May 24, 2012
if it an old mines i would look up marions branch on island creek that were rory hall from the left fork of island creek and they are an old minesthat use to be there on marions branch, these cops are letting the killers get away and there just a min away
Myrtle R

Elkhorn City, KY

#76 May 24, 2012
I would like to thank everyone for the info. I will say that I have asked again and again for the detectives to question and give lie detectors to all these people. They always seem to have excuses why not to at this time. I have tried contacting all the shows to get someone to do a story on Crystal's case or to get help with giving tests to people, but it isn't as easy as most seem to think. If I could afford it, I would hire a detective myself to look into it and give them tests, if the would even take it. Even though I was born here and visited often, I only moved down when she went missing three years ago. We have searched places that have been mentioned and I would like to search more. A lot of the problem is there are so many mines, ponds and such mentioned and I have no idea where they are or even how to get help having them searched due to lack of police cooperation. Any suggestions on any of this would be helpful.
why

Virgie, KY

#78 May 25, 2012
You do realize that police cant give lie detector tests to people just because someone asked them to dont you? If the person agrees to it, they can take it, but the police or even a judge can not force you to take one. Even if they did take it because they wanted to and failed it, in Kentucky, the results cant be used in court anyways. Plus, you do know lie detectors can be fooled dont you?
Old friend of crystals

United States

#79 May 26, 2012
I went to school with crystal and natasha. I know Rebecca well also and she has said things about crystals shoes that were found and earrings she was supposedly wearing crystal had borrowed from her. But how does she know what crystal had on is what i have wondered. I also heard she called crystals grandmother and told her somethin about the body being on johns crk someewhere in a field and she talked about a knife and that she was stabbed to death. She didn't say roryu did it but another man crystal had been with and i won't post his name. But Rebecca does need to at least be questioned after knowing this info. She also called a detective and then next day acted like she didn't want to talk or give ny more info but i do think she knows alot more than she says. I was good friends with crystal in school and think about her all the time. I just wish that someone could do something because there are answers to this somewhere.

Since: Mar 12

Location hidden

#80 May 26, 2012
Bobbys_wife wrote:
<quoted text>
I really hope this isn't a lie because it would tear her families hearts apart. If it is the truth you need to tell the police or her mother were to find her.
Hello my Friend (B'sW). And you are correct in the fact that Law Enforcemt need to be advised of any and all leads. As my own sister was the victim of homacide I know full well the angst the family suffers. I can't even begin to try and explain the pain and hurt and suspicion and rumors we are left. It's like you wait and wait for closure and that never comes. In my own perspective...Not even the arrest and conviction of her MURDERer makes me sleep better at night.'Cause I am now consumed w/the punishment not fitting the crime. I guess what I'm trying to say is that even GOOD news itself opens up more cans of sorry. So I caution everyone to please don't keep the pot stirred. Especially if it rumor and speculation. Take it straight to Law Enforcement and let them sort it out. They know best how to decipher the truth and how and/or when to approach the family. Sometimes our best intentions can contribute to the pain of others if not handled propperly. I wish this family some peace of mind and unburdened heart ASAP.
Myrtle R

Elkhorn City, KY

#81 May 26, 2012
why wrote:
You do realize that police cant give lie detector tests to people just because someone asked them to dont you? If the person agrees to it, they can take it, but the police or even a judge can not force you to take one. Even if they did take it because they wanted to and failed it, in Kentucky, the results cant be used in court anyways. Plus, you do know lie detectors can be fooled dont you?
Well let me tell you this first off to clarify any legal things that most don't think I know. I posted this in an eariler post. I am a certified paralegal and I do know the law. I know that the police cannot force lie detector tests on people, but what you don't know is that a couple of these people have asked to be given one and the police refuse. And secondly, there are exceptions to lie detector results being used in court hearings, but that is too much to go into on here. And lastly, lie detector tests, if done by a proper certified person, are not easily fooled. They are generally 99% accurate. There are ways to "try" and fool them but a real certified person can detect when someone is using tacticts to throw the test off. That is just like the detective who keeps telling me he can't bring people in for questioning for no reason at all. That statement is not true. Police can question anyone if they have anything to do with a missing person. They are just being lazy. They have had these people sitting in their jail and then telling me they can't find them at the same time I know they are in a jail cell right there. These police just don't do their job. Plain and simple...
Myrtle R

Elkhorn City, KY

#82 May 26, 2012
Old friend of crystals wrote:
I went to school with crystal and natasha. I know Rebecca well also and she has said things about crystals shoes that were found and earrings she was supposedly wearing crystal had borrowed from her. But how does she know what crystal had on is what i have wondered. I also heard she called crystals grandmother and told her somethin about the body being on johns crk someewhere in a field and she talked about a knife and that she was stabbed to death. She didn't say roryu did it but another man crystal had been with and i won't post his name. But Rebecca does need to at least be questioned after knowing this info. She also called a detective and then next day acted like she didn't want to talk or give ny more info but i do think she knows alot more than she says. I was good friends with crystal in school and think about her all the time. I just wish that someone could do something because there are answers to this somewhere.
The whole deal with the earings, clothes, shoe, and knife, was that there was some found by the highway. The clothes described that Crystal was wearing when she went missing was a long sleeved red type t-shirt with a hood, very dark blue jeans with button back pockets, white gold lg hoop earings, and brown slip on shoes (these were just the last things Natasha remembered her having on). These were not exactly the same clothes that were found. The clothes found were not even determined to be the ones she had on and none of Crystal's dna was on them. So that was a dead end pretty much. The rest was all rumors like everything else. Everyone is talking but no one is telling anything to the police or giving any real proof. We are just praying some day someone will tell the truth and lead us to the truth. Until then we just investigate what we are told and so far none of it has went anywhere. Maybe someday someone will grow a conscience and talk...
Myrtle R

Elkhorn City, KY

#83 May 26, 2012
Fly-Girl wrote:
<quoted text> Hello my Friend (B'sW). And you are correct in the fact that Law Enforcemt need to be advised of any and all leads. As my own sister was the victim of homacide I know full well the angst the family suffers. I can't even begin to try and explain the pain and hurt and suspicion and rumors we are left. It's like you wait and wait for closure and that never comes. In my own perspective...Not even the arrest and conviction of her MURDERer makes me sleep better at night.'Cause I am now consumed w/the punishment not fitting the crime. I guess what I'm trying to say is that even GOOD news itself opens up more cans of sorry. So I caution everyone to please don't keep the pot stirred. Especially if it rumor and speculation. Take it straight to Law Enforcement and let them sort it out. They know best how to decipher the truth and how and/or when to approach the family. Sometimes our best intentions can contribute to the pain of others if not handled propperly. I wish this family some peace of mind and unburdened heart ASAP.
I am so sorry to hear about your sister. I truely feel your pain. I do agree with you that even when we do find out where and what has happened to Crystal, whether she comes home alive or gone, there will never be any total closure. I my heart I do not want to think the worse and I try not to let the rumors get to me. But realistically it has been 3 years and I know my Crystal. In the end though I just want her 3 boys to know their mother did not up and take off on them cause she just didn't love them enough. That is all the closure I need. As for what happened to her and if someone did hurt her, I don't think any punishment will bring closure. I just want some peace of mind to know where she is and that her children know she is at peace.. God bless you and your family for your loss...

“Ladies and Gentlemen WERE HERE”

Since: May 11

Middlesboro Kentucky

#84 May 27, 2012
I know of a shooting he may have been involved in if you want to set up a private chat; we could meet

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Pikeville Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
~*~ Last Post Wins ~*~ (Aug '11) 12 min Hatti_Hollerand 9,746
Add a word, Drop a word (May '10) 24 min Truth 27,810
Bevins And Trump Will NOT be Re-Elected, Fools ... 33 min Mbartley 227
News Bible study rules for public schools proposed (Feb '10) 1 hr Jamie 174,887
Why Are So Many People Leaving Pike County ? (May '11) 1 hr car insurance 1,215
Andy Beshear Next KY Governor!!! 1 hr saving pike county 136
Calls for Investigation in Pike County Property... 1 hr outside help 142
Fiscal Court with Uncashed Checks 1 hr dirty place on earth 15
Stump Speeches 1 hr tell us 45

Pikeville Jobs

Personal Finance

Pikeville Mortgages