Livonia man charged with killing West Sparta woman

There are 59 comments on the WHEC-TV Rochester story from Jan 25, 2006, titled Livonia man charged with killing West Sparta woman. In it, WHEC-TV Rochester reports that:

A Livonia man is behind bars charged with murdering a West Sparta woman. 44-year-old William J. Wise is facing second-degree murder charges in the death of 56-year-old Amy Sayle.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at WHEC-TV Rochester.

First Prev
of 3
Next Last
LGM

Rochester, NY

#41 Mar 14, 2006
None of us would have even responded if it were not for the 1st post on this site, stating he is being falsly accused of a crime he did not commit. He is being held and was arrested because of evidence that was found immediately. They did not just pick him out and say oh lets say he did it. They do not just charge someone that they have picked randomly. I admit he has not had his day in court yet but he will and then everyone will know the truth. Please let her friends and family grieve and get through this without bad mouthing the victim. Amy was a good, loving giving person that did not deserve any of what happened to her. The only mistake she made was picking the wrong man to be a part of her life.
Sara

Rochester, NY

#42 Mar 14, 2006
I'm sorry if I offend anyone, but, I believe the friends and family on both sides can speak their minds. For both sides your both bad mouthing, yes, Amy is the victim. But, her family your the ones baiting the other sides! You people are speaking so negativity about Bill, I don't know everything, but I do know that Amy choose to be with him no one forced her to be with him! And from my understanding that says that she must have been happy. I think that your so upset about her death that you choose to be hateful. Think the next time you write something, I truly don't believe from all the things I've read on this site that Amy is as inocent as you people are trying to make her out to be! Yes she's the victim, but nobody is perfect. As some of you say looking at porn and going drinking is nomal, I definitly bag to differ.
TC-NY

Rochester, NY

#43 Mar 14, 2006
Sara-
Putting everything to do with this case aside - porn is normal. A lot of happy couples enjoy it together. It may not be for everyone, but there is nothing wrong with it. And drinking - there is absolutely NOTHING wrong with having a few drinks with friends.
I am not attacking you - but don't put people down because they indulge in LEGAL pass times that they enjoy.
Just becuase you may not like it, doesn't make it wrong.
And having to do with this case - what does watching porn and drinking have ANYTHING to do with being murdered???
STAPHNIE CONWAY

O Fallon, MO

#44 Mar 14, 2006
IM SICK OF THE ONES DEFENDING THIS MAN I CANNOT WAIT UNTIL JUSTICE IS SERVED SO EVERYONE THAT IS DEFENDING HIM WILL SHUT THE HELL UP. AMYS FAMILY IS STILL GRIEVING AND CANNOT BECAUSE OF THIS WEBSITE. WHAT SOMEONE DOES IN THERE PAST TIME IS THEIR BUSINESS. I STRONGLY DO NOT BELEIVE IN PORN. BUT THAT IS MY BELEIVE NOT EVERYONE HAS THE SAME BELIEVES AS ME SO I CANNOT JUDGE THEM ON THAT OR I MIGHT NOT HAVE ANY FRIENDS. OKAY IF AMY DID ALL THIS STUFF THEN THEY GUY EVERYONE IS TRYING TO PROTECT MOST LIKELY DID TO I LEARNED ALL THIS GOING THRU NURSING IN PSYCHOLOGY AND SOCIOLOGY. IF SOMEONE ELSE HAS A NURSING DEGREE AND WOULD LIKE TO ARGUE THE MATTER PLEASE DO SO. BUT I BELEIVE THIS CHAT IS NOT GOOD FOR EITHER SIDES OF THE FAMILY AND SOMEONE NEEDS TO FIND A WAY TO GET THIS SITE SHUT DOWN. AMYS SON NEEDS HIS PEACE NOT EVERYONE CRITIZING HIS MOM WHICH IS DECEASED. HE WILL NEVER GET OVER THIS CAUSE NO ONE IN HERE IS GONNA LET HIM ALL EVERYONE IS DOING IS STRESSING HIM OUT AND NO MATTER WHAT HIS MOM DID GIVES ANY OF US THE RIGHT TO KEEP THIS JUNK GOING ON AND ON AND ON. HE NEEDS A BREAK FROM ALL OF THIS SOMETHING TRULY NEEDS TO BE DONE TO SHUT THIS SITE DOWN FROM ALL THE HYPOCRITS IN HERE.
Cody Jenine Bevel

Stuttgart, AR

#45 Mar 15, 2006
I didn't know Amy, just only from what my friend Staphnie Conway has told me. Just because she watched porn, dranked socially, and looked for guys online doesn't mean that she should have been killed. I guess cause I watch porn once in awhile with my fiance, drink once in awhile, and used to meet guys from online I should be killed. What I don't understand is if he didn't kill her why didn't he call the police to report her dead? That just sounds odd to me. Let's just give her family peace and quiet and quit bad mouthing one another.
Sara

Rochester, NY

#46 Mar 15, 2006
Stapanie,
You are just upset that your friend is dead. Yes she is the victim, but if you people don't want to read what people write then don't come on here! We are all intiled to our oppion, just as you and I believe that just because Amy is dead, doesn't give you people the right to bad mouth Bill. You people keep this site going, face reailty. Yes Amy was the victim, but, she wasn't inocent. Face that facts and deal with it! I'm not saying that Bill is inocent, But he is until he's proven guilty! Once again if the family is so upset about what's being said, then don't come on here!
Cody Jenine Bevel

Stuttgart, AR

#47 Mar 16, 2006
Sara,
Amy's privite life is just that, privite. There is nobody in this world that is innocent, they just think they are. I have a question, it's not alright to bad mouth Bill but it's alright to bad mouth Amy?
STAPHNIE CONWAY

O Fallon, MO

#48 Mar 16, 2006
SARA
YOU MUST BE KIN TO BILL,SLEEPING WITH BILL OR SOMETHING BUT ANYWAY HES NOT ALL THAT INNOCENT. AT LEAST HE IS ALIVE UNLIKE AMY. YES WE ARE ALL INTITLED TO OUR OWN OPINION BUT NO ONE IS THINKING ABOUT EITHER SIDE OF THE FAMILIES AND WHAT THIS SIGHT IS DOING TO ALL BUT IM NOT STAYING OUT OF HERE WHEN PEOPLE LIKE YOU ARE WRITING MY NAME OUT AND ADDRESSING ME. YOU NEED TO FACE THE FACT SARAH WHAT IF THIS WAS YOUR MOM OR YOUR SISTER WOULD YOU WANT PEOPLE BAD MOUTHING THEM. OR LETTING PEOPLE KNOW WHAT THEY DID IN THEIR PAST. WE ALL HAVE SOMETHING TO BE ASHAME OF. I HAVE ONE QUESTION HOW COULD HE BE IN THE HOUSE AND NOT KNOW AMY WAS UPSTAIRS DEAD ANSWER THAT. BUT I HAVE BEEN TALKING TO AMYS SON BY EMAIL SO HIS ANSWERS ARE ALL THAT MATTERS HOW MANY OF YOU CAN ACTUALLY SAY THAT YOUR WRITING HIM AND TALKING TO HIM ABOUT WHATS GOING ON INSTEAD OF BAB MOUTHING HIS MOTHER IN HERE. THATS ALL IM STAYING WE ALL NEED TO QUIT BAD MOUTHING EVERYONE CAUSE JUSTICE IS GONNA PREVAIL. I COULD WRITE IN HERE ALL DAY BUT I KNOW NOW TO CONTACT TOMMY AND HIM AND I CAN TALK AND SHARE STORIES WITHOUT ALL THIS B***SH*T.
Sara

Rochester, NY

#49 Mar 16, 2006
Staphanie,
GET A LIFE!
LGM

Rochester, NY

#50 Mar 16, 2006
Sara wrote:
Staphanie,
GET A LIFE!
Sara,

For your information Staphinie has a life and very full one she is a wife, mother, nurse and cheerleading coach. So you tell me who needs to get the life! Enough of this site! Please just let us grieve!
staphnie conway

Ville Platte, LA

#51 Mar 19, 2006
THANKS LGM FOR STANDING UP FOR ME I CANNOT GET IN HERE ON MY COMPUTER FOR SOME REASON BUT I CAN GET IN HERE ON SOMEONE ELSES COMPUTER BUT THANKS AND SARA WE ALL SHOULDNT BE ARGUING WITH EACH OTHER OVER THIS I KNOW MY LIFE SCHEDULE IS BUSY. BUT IM NOT GONNA LET SOMEONE DOG ME OUT AND NOT COME BACK WITH A COMMENT. SO I AM GOING TO TRY AND BACK OFF THIS SITE AND JUST KEEP IN TOUCH WITH AMYS SON HE KNOWS MORE ABOUT WHATS GOING ON THAN THE REST OF US DO.
Tina B
#54 Mar 21, 2006
This site should be shut down, too much hurt and pain is being shared by all. Bills family that is on here will never believe that he is guilty and Amys family will never believe he is innocent.. Mud slinging and hurtful worrds do not help anyone on either side. Lets all agree to disagree and let the healing begin for all....As we all know life is too short, so please no hate mail to me because I am only speaking fairly and just. Let this be the last post and when the trial is over and a verdict is announced then and only then ,will the truth be known and then you can yell, scream , hollar or whatever, Just let this end right here... for now...Too many tears....... A child is being born lets all think of that....A new life is coming and no one wants that child to be born into this horror.. Please..Let it end...

Thank You!
Sara

Rochester, NY

#55 Mar 22, 2006
I agree but, that should go for everyone!
Tina B
#56 Mar 22, 2006
I agree Sara. like I said lets end this all now for everyone.... One life is gone, one persons life may be taken away but we all still have faith and hope for a new child being born on this earth......

May God be with each and everyone of you..

Thank You!
Alan

Binghamton, NY

#57 Apr 22, 2006
I just want all of you to know that thing s are going good for bill .And you all will feel real bad when this is all done. and I know more then you all.
Outsider Looking In

AOL

#58 Aug 10, 2006
Finally I get to speak my peace!!! GUILTY GUILTY GUILY - AMEN
Now all you freaks that think looking at porn or having a few drinks is a reason to be murdered ..... please explain how bad mouthing a deceased woman to her family and friends as a hobby is any better. Quite frankly I'd rather be around social drinkers and occasional porn watchers than evil hateful people who would strike out at man that just lost his mother to murder. May you all reap what you sow.
May Amy Sayle's spirit and love live on through her soon to be born grandson that was deprived of knowing her due to the selfish cruel actions of another.
mei

Rochester, NY

#59 Oct 31, 2007
I am fairly new to this site and have been browsing through alot of these stories. I was under the impression this is a site where you can discuss issues, not sit around and trash talk anyone, dead, alive, guilty or innocent. Everyone always seems to know everyone when it comes to these stories. Peoples personal lives are no ones business to be talking about. I do not know either party involved in this case, but I have to say porn and drinking have no bearing on ANY part of it. I am hoping that in browsing through this site a bit more, i can find some more intelligent discussions. Where people are using this site for its purpose. Not to use their trashy mouths and let their true colors sign. I always say, those who put down others are making up for their own imperfections.
Penny

Horsham, PA

#60 Nov 15, 2007
mei wrote:
I am fairly new to this site and have been browsing through alot of these stories. I was under the impression this is a site where you can discuss issues, not sit around and trash talk anyone, dead, alive, guilty or innocent. Everyone always seems to know everyone when it comes to these stories. Peoples personal lives are no ones business to be talking about. I do not know either party involved in this case, but I have to say porn and drinking have no bearing on ANY part of it. I am hoping that in browsing through this site a bit more, i can find some more intelligent discussions. Where people are using this site for its purpose. Not to use their trashy mouths and let their true colors sign. I always say, those who put down others are making up for their own imperfections.
Mei ... you have to understand that both sides of this tragedy were (and still are) very emotional. It's not easy losing a family member -especially a murder - and I'm sure it was just as difficult for Bill's family to see him accused of a crime believing that he couldn't and wouldn't do it. Regardless, people are human and feel the need to defend their sides and the people they love no matter what. This site had a long an horrible string of comments - but it's over now and should be closed down permanently. Amy is gone and Bill will be in prison for a long time. Nothing can be done to change these events. Amy was my sister and I still miss her every day. We all have to remember the happier times and move on.
mike

York, SC

#61 Oct 3, 2014
Nancy wrote:
I feel this man is being falsey accused of a crime he did not commit. There is no evedince proving how she died.Yet! why is this man still in jail? What kind of a justice system do we have? I thought a man is inacent till proven guilty? but i guess the law doesn't work that way. God bless this man and may the lord be with him!
Completely incorrect. This man beat her. He can rot in jail and then rot in hell. This was my friends mother. This piece of shit can burn for eternity.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 3
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Piffard Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Family court (Dec '11) May 22 Concerned Mother 43
Lets Get Dennis Cohen out (Jan '14) May 12 dlh429 4
News Frost Ridge, complying with court order, announ... (Jun '14) May 4 IQ Problem 8
News 19-year old dies in car accident (Aug '09) Apr 30 StopOrIWillShoot 29
News Mt. Morris man facing burglary, arson charges Apr '15 AubreyIsLesbian 1
Review: Pittsford Management Inc Mar '15 shauna riccione 1
News Gordon W. Davis Mar '15 Agree 2
More from around the web

Piffard People Search

Addresses and phone numbers for FREE

Personal Finance

Mortgages [ See current mortgage rates ]