Livonia man charged with killing West...

Livonia man charged with killing West Sparta woman

There are 60 comments on the WHEC-TV Rochester story from Jan 25, 2006, titled Livonia man charged with killing West Sparta woman. In it, WHEC-TV Rochester reports that:

A Livonia man is behind bars charged with murdering a West Sparta woman. 44-year-old William J. Wise is facing second-degree murder charges in the death of 56-year-old Amy Sayle.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at WHEC-TV Rochester.

First Prev
of 3
Next Last
Nancy

Johnson City, NY

#1 Feb 2, 2006
I feel this man is being falsey accused of a crime he did not commit. There is no evedince proving how she died.Yet! why is this man still in jail? What kind of a justice system do we have? I thought a man is inacent till proven guilty? but i guess the law doesn't work that way. God bless this man and may the lord be with him!
STAPHNIE CONWAY

O Fallon, MO

#2 Feb 7, 2006
YOU MUST BE SLEEPING WITH THIS MAN OR JUST CRAZY EVERYTHING POINTS TO HIM HE CLAIMS HE TOOK HER TO WORK AND WAS LAYING ON HER COUCH WHEN THE COPS ARRIVED I KNOW SHE DIDNT BEAT HIM BACK HOME RUN UP STAIRS AND TO THAT TO HERSELF. I BELIEVE THIS MAN DID IT AND I HOPE IN YOUR STATE HE GETS WHATS COMING TO HIM. IM A CHRISTIAN WOMEN BUT I BELEIVE IN TRUE JUSTICE FOR MY FRIEND. HE EVEN LOOKS LIKE A CRIMINAL. BUT IM NOT TRYING TO OFFEND YOU NANCY BUT IF THE TWO OF YOU DONT HAVE A THING GOING ON THEN YOU MUST BE KIN TO HIM TO DEFEND A MURDERER.
TFG

Hilton, NY

#3 Feb 7, 2006
The man is behind bars and that is where he should be. Lets hope he stays there. As for you Nancy you are in your own kind of prison...
Alan

Johnson City, NY

#4 Feb 8, 2006
If this man was guilty, they would of figured it out right away. It's called forensic. They have no cause of death, she wasn't strangled, beated, stabbed. How would everyone feel if she died of natural causes? How you feel if he did not do this? With people like you out there this man is already guilty. I'm not in the family or was sleeping with him. just a bystander....god bless
STAPHNIE CONWAY

O Fallon, MO

#5 Feb 9, 2006
it takes a while to figure stuff out. its not instantly they know. but everything sounds guilty to me. some of you say she wasnt beaten but i read where she had bruises on her wrist and ankles and the inside of her mouth had sores that sounds like a beating to me. but your right we dont know what went on none of us was there but he sure sounds guilty to me. if you are a bystander then how do you know exactly what was going and no one else does. i know how to read and i know what ive read and everything points to him or he was really suspicious i just hope amy gets the justice she and her family deserves and gets to rest in peace. i dont know the person that did this to her and i just know her thru the telephone but she touched my heart with her kind soul and thoughtfulness. i just hope you all see that what this man did was wrong and stop defending him.
Alan

Johnson City, NY

#6 Feb 9, 2006
I'm not defending him, if he did this then he deserves to be punished for his crime, but if he didn't he should be set free,yes as a bystander i do know more than what's in the papers. May justice be served. god will do the right thing
TC -NY

Hilton, NY

#7 Feb 10, 2006
Nancy & Alan-
First of all - if you have read the papers, it states there was brusing, bleeding, etc...generally - that is not considered natural causes. Does it mean he killed her? No. BUT again, if you read the papers, you would see that he was in her house when the police discovered her body. Now, I am not sure what common sense in Alfred is - but common sense to me says that if you are in someones house - and they are hurt or deceased - you call the police. He did not...I can only think of 1 reason why. Until all the evidence is released, he is sitting in jail where he belongs...and when he is found guilty - he should burn in hell. "God bless" is right - God Bless her family, friends, and the people who loved her.
Penny

Finland

#8 Feb 10, 2006
My sister did not deserve to be killed and left as she did. There is plenty of evidence against him, otherwise he wouldn't have been charged with 2nd degree murder within hours of the police finding her body. What you read is not all the information that there is - and there is plenty more information about this whole situation. They have in custody who they should have. Anyone in doubt of his guilt will know the truth when they read that he will be going to prison for a very long time once this whole nightmare is over.
STAPHNIE CONWAY

O Fallon, MO

#9 Feb 10, 2006
PENNY,
I JUST WANT YOU TO KNOW THAT IT WAS AN HONOR TO MEET YOUR SISTER SHE WAS A VERY WONDERFUL FRIEND TO ME. I MET HER THRU MY CHEERLEADING AND WE TALKED AND GOT TO KNOW EACH OTHER SHE CALLED AND CHECKED ON ME ALOT. SHE TOOK ME UNDER HER WING. EVEN THOUGH I NEVER MET HER IN PERSON SHE HAD MY OUTMOST RESPECT. I HOPE YOU AND AMYS SON GETS JUSTICE. MY THOUGHTS AND PRAYERS ARE WITH YOU GUYS. AND I HOPE THE PERSON THAT DID THIS ROTS IN HELLS. WELL TAKE CARE AND ILL BE PRAYING FOR YOU GUYS.
Alan

Johnson City, NY

#10 Feb 12, 2006
I am sorry for her and her family. I was accused for something that i did't do! i spent 2 yrs in jail! After 2 yrs i was set free, 2 yrs of HELL from the newpapers and people, by the time they figured out and caught the real person. 2 yrs were gone. I know if i just killed someone, i sure would't stick around the house for a day! Something wrong with this picture. That's all i'm saying.
Tina B

London, Canada

#11 Feb 13, 2006
Nancy,
are you NUTS??? I have know this family my whole life and he DID kill Amy. Maybe you need to be behind bars with him... There is evidence and I hope to God that your family member is never killed.. Maybe better yet you can invite Bill to come live with YOU and then after your bruised and battered dead body is laying naked on the floor he can lay down next to you and sleep with you and the tell your family he has no idea where you are.!!! I know every detail so far on what that crazy idiot did to the whole family.. He didnt just kill Amy he killed her Dad, and sisters as well.. nice guy huh?? Or better yet why didnt you come to the funeral and as her only son cried over the loss of his mother you could of walked up to him and told him that Bill is innocent. May God forgive you for being so heartless.

Shame on you!!

Rev Tina B
Alan

Johnson City, NY

#12 Feb 15, 2006
Tina, Are you Nuts?? I knew both of them and they both were drunks! Plus she is on the yahoo personals looking for another man. Plus they both liked porno and bondage. This is a fact! And before you talk about other people, you should look at yourself first, REV! And we all feel sorry for Amy's death and her family's hardship. Everyone is sorry for her death. If this man did this he deserves what he gets, but i'm the kind of person to wait for the results of why she died.I've been there so that's why i don't judge anyone until all the facts are in
Alan

Johnson City, NY

#13 Feb 15, 2006
this is it im done with you all !!!!
STAPHNIE CONWAY

O Fallon, MO

#14 Feb 17, 2006
LOOK I DONT KNOW AMY PERSONALLY I JUST KNOW HER THRU HER WORK SHE DID WITH ME OVER CHEERLEADING. I DONT BELEIVE IN MEETING PEOPLE OFF THE PERSONELS BUT SOME PEOPLE DO IT AND FIND TRUE LOVE. I DONT LOOK AT PORNO OR DRINK BUT THAT DOESNT GIVE ME THE RIGHT TO JUDGE SOMEONE WHO DOES. BUT WHAT I DO BELEIVE IS NO ONE HAS THE RIGHT TO COMMITE MURDER NO MATTER WHAT.ALAN I DONT THINK YOU FEEL SORRY FOR HER DEATH I THINK SINCE YOU WERE ACCUSED OF SOMETHING ADN THEN WAS PROVEN INNOCENT YOU THINK ALL PEOPLE ARE INNOCENT.AND ALAN HOW DO YOU KNOW SO MUCH PERSONEL STUFF ON THEM IT MAKES ME WONDER ABOUT YOU. I THINK WE ALL NEED TO LET THIS GO SO HER SON CAN RELAX AND SO AMY CAN GET THE PIECE SHE ACTUALLY DESERVES.
LGM

Hilton, NY

#15 Feb 17, 2006
ALAN,

WHO THE HELL ARE YOU AND WHAT RELATIONSHIP DO YOU HAVE TO EITHER ONE OF THEM? YOU SAY YOU KNOW SO MUCH ABOUT THIS CASE, HOW? BOTTOM LINE IS I DON'T THINK YOU KNOW AMY AT ALL, OR YOU WOULD NOT BAD MOUTH HER AND TELL LIES ABOUT HER. EVEN IF ANY OF WHAT YOU SAID IS TRUE SHE DID NOT DESERVED TO BE MURDERED. YOU OBVIOUSLY HAVE SOMETHING TO DO WITH THE MURDERER(AND THAT IS EXACTLY WHAT HE IS). IF HE IS YOUR FRIEND I AM SORRY FOR YOU, BECAUSE ANYONE THAT WOULD DO WHAT HE DID DESERVES TO SPEND THE REST OF HIS LIFE IN PRISON OR ON DEATH ROW! SO STOP BEING A COWARD AND STATE WHO YOU ARE AND WHAT YOUR RELATIONSHIP IS OR WAS!

BY THE WAY JUST SO I AM BEING FAIR ABOUT WHAT I HAVE ASKED YOU, I AM A VERY CLOSE FRIEND OF AMY'S. AND WILL FOREVER MISS HER!!!!
Tina B

London, Canada

#16 Feb 17, 2006
Alan,

I just can not believe that you said all of that stuff about Amy. Have you no sympathy??? If your family member died or I should say been murdered. Would you want strangers to judge her?? Would you want all of her personal life spread all over the ineernet sounding like she deserved it??

Have you never drank?? Never looked at Porno?? looked for friendship or love somewhere??..Shame on you .. Those who live in glass houses should not throw stones!.I hope God does not judge you like you have judged Amy and her family.. AND I did not say ANYTHING in my last post for you to say mean things about me being a Rev or asking me to take a look at my self..I have looked deep within my self and its very hard for me to forgive the guy who took her life, BUT I can forgive you for your nasty and mean words. You of all people should have more compassion in this world..God be with with families of all those who are shattered from this horrible horrible ordeal..

God Bless Always,

Tina
STAPHNIE CONWAY

O Fallon, MO

#17 Feb 17, 2006
ALan
I AM REALLY STARTING TO WONDER ABOUT YOU. I WENT ONTO THE YAHOO PERSONALS AND FOUND AMYS INFO AND SHE DID SAY SHE WAS AN OCCASIONAL DRINKER BUT MOST IMPORTANT IT SAID SHE LIVED ALONE AND IT WAS JUST UPDATED 2MTHS AGO. IM WONDERING WHAT YOUR INVOLVEMENT IN ALL THIS IS. IM STARTING TO WORRY THAT YOU MIGHT OF BEEN IN THE MIDDLE OF THIS SITUATION. YOU ARE JUMPING ON EVERYONE IN HERE AND BLAMING EVERYONE BUT THE ACCUSED. SO WHATS YOUR STORY AND WHY ARE YOU SO CONCERNED WITH ALL THIS.
Penny

Oakland, CA

#18 Feb 20, 2006
Staphnie - the Amy you knew was the real Amy. Alan is obviously a friend or relative of Bill's and is entitled to his own opinion, however, to slander Amy like that was unnecessary. That may have been Bill's lifestyle, but not hers. Her personals ad was originally done 2-1/2 years ago when she first moved to the area. To update the ad wouldn't be unusual since she had been finished with Bill for weeks - he just wouldn't go away. I miss her every second of the day. The world would be a better place with more people like Amy in it and anyone who truly knew her loved her and realized what a great person she was. I will always remember her for her love, sense of humor, compassion, and strength. Justice is now needed - and once he is sentenced the healing can possibly begin.
Thank you to all her friends on here who have not let others opinions influence the truth.
STAPHNIE CONWAY

O Fallon, MO

#19 Feb 20, 2006
PENNY
YOU ARE TRULY WELCOME IT WAS A BLESSING TO MEET SUCH A WONDERFUL WOMEN EVEN THOUGH WE NEVER MET IN PERSON. IM ALSO TRULY SORRY NO ONE IS LEAVING THIS SIGHT ALONE SO YOU AND YOUR FAMILY CAN GRIEVE IN PIECE. I WISH YOU ALL THE VERY BEST AND HOPE YOU GET THE JUSTICE YOU GUYS NEED. I TOTALLED MY CAR OVER THE WEEKEND AND ALL I COULD THINK ABOUT WAS MY HUSBAND AND LITTLE GIRL. AND WHAT ALMOST HAPPENED TO ME. AND ITS HARD. SO IVE LEARNED YOU TAKE LIFE AS IT COMES. PLEASE GET SOME REST AND DONT LET WHAT PEOPLE ARE WRITING IN HERE GET YOU DONE. NO ONE HAS THE RIGHT TO JUDGE ANYONE UNLESS THEY TRULY KNOW THAT PERSON. BUT I KNOW WHAT AMY TOLD ME WHEN WE TALKED. AND SHE ALWAYS TOLD ME HOW MUCH SHE LOVED HER FAMILY. SO I WISH YOU AND HER SON THE VERY BEST. JUST LET ME KNOW HOW THINGS GO WHEN YOU GUYS GO TO TRIAL.YOUR IN MY THOUGHTS AND PRAYERS.
George

Rochester, NY

#20 Feb 22, 2006
Alan wrote:
If this man was guilty, they would of figured it out right away. It's called forensic. They have no cause of death, she wasn't strangled, beated, stabbed. How would everyone feel if she died of natural causes? How you feel if he did not do this? With people like you out there this man is already guilty. I'm not in the family or was sleeping with him. just a bystander....god bless
Alan, if you feel you may have information about this case, such as background information on the people involved, you should reach out to the Livingston County Sheriff's Office and let them know what you know. It may help Mr. Wise in this case.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 3
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Piffard Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Election Who do you support for State Senator in New Yor... (Oct '10) Jul 25 josephbarkley 20
News Some consumers boycotting Barilla over homosexu... (Sep '13) Jul 18 josephbarkley 22
Family court (Dec '11) Jun '16 nikki t 47
News D.C.'s Essential Bagels May '16 Zeke the Pinhead 5
News Batavia PD announces annual awards May '16 Rick Jibbity 1
Lets Get Dennis Cohen out (Jan '14) Apr '16 Proudmom 12
News Deputies: New York woman ate drugs to avoid mor... Feb '16 DILF 6

Piffard Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

Piffard Mortgages