First Prev
of 3
Next Last
wonderin

United States

#1 Oct 22, 2012
Is it considered suicide if you sacrifice your life for someone else's? Will you burn in hell or will God still want you?
Kazi
#2 Oct 22, 2012
I guess by you giving up your life to save someone else's it would show god numerous things. For one it would show that you were not a selfish person and plus it would show how much you cared for another...but thats just my opinion...but my question would be is it the same for soldier in the act of war...
parasite

United States

#3 Oct 23, 2012
wonderin wrote:
Is it considered suicide if you sacrifice your life for someone else's? Will you burn in hell or will God still want you?
That's not suicide. It's sacrifice as you called it secondly. Greater love has no man than He lay down his life for his friends. That's what Jesus did for us.
wonderin

Pompano Beach, FL

#4 Oct 23, 2012
Yes that's what I thought too. I am a Christian but don't really understand the Bible. Just wanted info from more religious aspects. Thank you both.
Hillary

Lexington, KY

#5 Oct 23, 2012
Only God can judge a person's state of mind that commits suicide.
Kazi
#6 Oct 23, 2012
but still wether or not your stable minded or not suicide is still the ultimate no no...just think how your friends and family would feel...Is it fair to take yourself away from the people who love and care for you.At least i think its wrong but thats just my opinion...Thanks for the replys...
sweet pea
#7 Oct 23, 2012
life is a gift from GOD and no matter your state of mind it is a rejection of HIS gift and that is the ultimate sin and you will go to hell! i grew up in church with a preacher for a father and this is a biggie.
hmm

Fenton, MI

#8 Oct 23, 2012
What if someone has lost their mind? Like dementia...Alzheimer's.... They are not the same person... is their soul judged then?
wonderin

United States

#9 Oct 23, 2012
I was referring to a completely stable minded person. If the person is not in their right mind due to some illness or disease, not due to drug abuse, then I think God understands. He know they know not what they do. As far as the stable minded person I am still confused.
parasite

Paris, KY

#10 Oct 23, 2012
Kazi wrote:
but still wether or not your stable minded or not suicide is still the ultimate no no...just think how your friends and family would feel...Is it fair to take yourself away from the people who love and care for you.At least i think its wrong but thats just my opinion...Thanks for the replys...
When your at that point. There are no family or friends or anyone who cares. At least not in your mind. Impossible to understand unless you've been to that place
sweet pea
#11 Oct 23, 2012
that would be different thats a hereditary disease that robs you of your facalties. i'm talking about people who *uck up their lives and give up instead of fixing it. GOD never gives you more than you can handle!
wonderin

United States

#12 Oct 23, 2012
sweet pea wrote:
that would be different thats a hereditary disease that robs you of your facalties. i'm talking about people who *uck up their lives and give up instead of fixing it. GOD never gives you more than you can handle!
Yes my point exactly. But didn't he ask Abraham to kill his son for a sacrifice? Kinda the same difference.. All this is confusing. Would love to understant..
sweet pea
#13 Oct 23, 2012
wonderin wrote:
<quoted text>
Yes my point exactly. But didn't he ask Abraham to kill his son for a sacrifice? Kinda the same difference.. All this is confusing. Would love to understant..
sacrifice is not suicide! its murder and GOD told him to do it to test his loyalty...when GOD saw he was loyal he stopped him before he did it. thats besides the point though
wonderin

United States

#14 Oct 23, 2012
Ok ty didn't know God stopped him
parasite

Paris, KY

#15 Oct 23, 2012
wonderin wrote:
Is it considered suicide if you sacrifice your life for someone else's? Will you burn in hell or will God still want you?
It is not considered suicide.
Charlie

Paris, KY

#16 Oct 23, 2012
a deer jumped out in front of my mini van last week... is that considered suicide?
wonderin

United States

#17 Oct 23, 2012
parasite wrote:
<quoted text>
It is not considered suicide.
Ty
Hillary

Lexington, KY

#18 Oct 24, 2012
sweet pea wrote:
life is a gift from GOD and no matter your state of mind it is a rejection of HIS gift and that is the ultimate sin and you will go to hell! i grew up in church with a preacher for a father and this is a biggie.
You or anyone else can in no way judge if a person is going to hell.

I think it is wrong too but only God can judge a person's state of mind.
Hillary

Lexington, KY

#19 Oct 24, 2012
hmm wrote:
What if someone has lost their mind? Like dementia...Alzheimer's.... They are not the same person... is their soul judged then?
That is what my comments were towards. I said only God can judge a person's state of mind. Only he knows. So I agree with what you are saying, things happen to people and they are not in the right state of mind. And I believe we have a just God, and he will judge accordingly.

I was at a funeral once of a suicide victim, I overheard a conversation of "oh well we all know where he's going"... I stayed out of it because it wasn't my family, and I thought to myself NO we don't know where this person is going, only God can judge that.
sweet pea
#20 Oct 24, 2012
Hillary wrote:
<quoted text>
You or anyone else can in no way judge if a person is going to hell.
I think it is wrong too but only God can judge a person's state of mind.
i'm not judging anyone but maybe you need to reead your bible and talk to a preacher!

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 3
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Paris Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Steven dale Sat Knowssteven 11
Dale bro's have STD's (Feb '14) Fri Ray 9
darts Fri the bulls 1
Meth Fri Herkimer 2
Is Junie Turpin still around? (Sep '15) Nov 30 Jubal Early 3
Bourbon middle Nov 30 Rastus 2
Gina Lawson (May '16) Nov 30 wow 37

Paris Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

Paris Mortgages