Review: Ashley's Closet
Clothing Expert

Bakersfield, CA

#24 Sep 8, 2009
In reading these posts, I would say that this is an attempt to strum up business - who wouldn't.. Plato's closet is a franchise - they have money to advertise advertise advertise and that they do! Unfortunately the small fry's have to work 10 times as hard to get the word out that they may be just as good or MUCH BETTER! The "pay for clothing" routine has been out there for a LONG time - well before Plato's came to town.... I remember 1993 when the HIP HOP SHOP did the "pay out" thing -(they were downtown St. Pete before it was even built up) and then OFF THE RACK (I think it has been there just as long) but definately longer than PLATO'S. I have been to several (personally Plato's is a bit annoying - long wait (time is money), and I do not believe they pay what they advertise)- OFF THE RACK pays fair and you don't have the attitude or the wait that you have at Plato's... I prefer cash over waiting (for consignment)... I always found that I had an allergic reaction after being in Plato's or Once upon a child.. Good to form your own opinions though - nothing is better than checking it out and experiencing something for yourself to make a judgement!
Oh - just a small add in... I just noticed what posts were saying about fakes... If you knowingly sell a fake - you are liable in the eyes of the law (so seriously, if you take in a fendi bag that says "made in china" -- guess what -- it is FAKE... Fakes support terrorism and sweat-shops -- think about that before taking a profit on the sale of a fake!

Tampa, FL

#25 Sep 18, 2009
forget off the rack!ASHLEYS CLOSET ROCKS

Tampa, FL

#26 Nov 10, 2009
EXACTLYY.! everybody has nothing else to say now huh..i guess you know i win and ashleys closet really is theee best.! thanks for thinking they had competition=)
Crazy Ladies

Holiday, FL

#27 Nov 18, 2009
They both Ashley's and Plato's are over priced. If you go to Aero you can buy a brand new shirt that is REAL for less than what you can at Ashley's or Plato's! Also I rather spend my money at a real shop buying something I no that is real and new. Not used and to worry about what it is made out of and who has worn it. You no they don't wash the clothes so who knows what is in them. I have been to both and I won't ever go back! I'll stick to the stores in the mall or online stores! Note I am NOT rich but I rather get something good for my money!:)

Valrico, FL

#28 Nov 24, 2009
whoaa....what are you talking about? what is in them ..what can possibly be in clothes ladyy?
if anything is...they cant live in clothes longer then 3 days and you defintly cant go to the mall and get it for the same price but its okay while your going to the mall and paying 40$ for one shirt ill be gettin the sames shirt for 10$ at ashleys closet.your smart lmao people got jokes theses days ....

Owensboro, KY

#29 Nov 27, 2009
Yeah I agree

Nashville, TN

#30 Dec 10, 2009
ur all a bunch or retards. get a life losers.

United States

#31 Jan 4, 2010
Hey does anyone actually know who the owner of Ashley's closet is? Has anyone actually ever worked at Ashley's closet?

Saint Petersburg, FL

#32 Jan 6, 2010
First off "Care", before you go ranting and raving about someone else make sure you read their post correctly, seeing how your a teacher in Florida's education system,(which by the way needs a reform) the person you are responding to never said anything about "capitalization" they were talking about capitalism. Just thought you needed to know that.
Care wrote:
ummm....Plato's Closet is not a consignment shop. Maybe you need to know what you are talking about before you talk negative about someone else’s opinions...which is just what that was an opinion about how Plato's Closet is a great store. And I agree! I have been to consignment shops around Florida and place's like Ashley's Closet and Plato's Closet and I definitely prefer the business model of Ashley's Closet and Plato's Closet better, but I do prefer, overall, and love Plato's. They are very professional in the way they buy clothing and sell clothing. Also, I've been in 5 different Plato's Closets around the state and the people who work in all those stores are very friendly and nice, even when they don't buy a thing I drop off and even if I don't choose to buy anything from them. I've been in Ashley's Closet two times and didn't feel welcome. Here are a handful of negative things I didn’t like about Ashley's Closet just after two visits...
-I stopped by at 7:15 pm one evening because the Open sign was lit up and it turned out that the door was locked to the store. I understand closing early if business is slow (close time was 8:00 pm), but at least have the courtesy of turning the Open sign off. The lights were on inside and I knocked and looked in but I couldn’t see anyone. I was going to tell them that the Open sign was still on, but I didn’t care to wait another second because they clearly don’t care about their customers.
-When I did go back to try to sell clothing, I walked in and no one was behind the counter or around the sales floor. I said “Hello” a few times and eventually a lady emerged from the back walking towards me and didn’t say a word as she had an ice pop (I think) in her mouth.
-I had to say the first word and shared that I was there to try to sell clothing. Once again, the lady didn’t say a word to me and then started looking at my clothing.
-I walked around the store and eventually I noticed that the lady started to put clothing out on the sales floor, so I assumed she was finished looking at my clothing. Now, I know at Plato’s, they have a mechanical way to look at clothing and it takes at least 5 minutes to go through a Publix shopping bag. I had a garbage bag full and the lady was done in 5 minutes. So, I walked up to the counter and finally the lady spoke to me. She said she couldn’t buy anything and I was perfectly alright with that. But overall, I wasn’t perfectly alright that I didn’t feel welcome in her store. And by looking at the prices, conditions, and ages of the items, let alone the customer service, in her store, I can promise you I will not be back ever again to Ashley’s Closet.
…Oh, and just so you know, I have a Masters degree in Education, and I have learned that when it comes to “causal” conversation online, capitalization and spelling do not matter, but in the real world, treating people, ie customers, with common decency is appreciated. Oh how I love to incorporate by own “decency” with this message. Haha! Go Plato’s! J

Tampa, FL

#33 Jan 27, 2010
you must have no life if your seriously using your time to write that much...

Since: Jan 10

Bradenton, FL

#34 Jan 27, 2010
Do you people really feel that passionately about where you buy your dicount jeans? I've been to Plato's Closet and I didn't like the smell of the place at all. It was kind of like a moth ball/dryer sheet smell. Plus the customer service wasn't great.

Saint Petersburg, FL

#35 Jan 30, 2010
All of you that are talking up about ashleys closet stop! you are all saying we cant afford ashleys and that is bs! first for everyone money is tight and if you can affort ashleys then just buy it new at the store.

Saint Petersburg, FL

#36 Feb 6, 2010
Hola Como esta soy phillis mi abla espanol
Eurogirl in the US

Sarasota, FL

#37 Jul 2, 2010
I love Ashley's Closet....always get bargain Bebe and other named brand clothing there. Go during the week it's always quiet and you get one on one :-) I much prefer this store to Plato's.
r jim

Secaucus, NJ

#38 Jul 3, 2010
place is dirty and a dump

Singapore, Singapore

#39 Jul 3, 2010
That place ripped me off

Tampa, FL

#40 Mar 1, 2011
Let me be the first to say that Ashley's Closet is CLOSED and Plato's is still open and doing plenty of business. Just sayin ;)

Denver, CO

#41 Mar 31, 2011
Do you miss ashley closrt text 7274103710 I do alot I wish it was thete

Miami, FL

#42 Nov 23, 2011
All posts from anyone in Clearwater was the owner of Ashley's Closet. Her name is Tracey

United States

#43 Feb 19, 2012
Anyone wanna tell me where the new store is

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Palm Harbor Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Horrible Drivers Wed D-Nice 1
News Toddler drowns in Palm Harbor pool Jul 19 Garn 1
News In downtown Clearwater, Scientology's bid for a... Jul 16 Python Swoope 2
Glenn Consagra muder case from 1978 (Jan '11) Jul 16 Barbaraababydoll 4
News Clearwater delays purchase of land in downtown Jul 14 Python Swoope 2
Crystal Beach Music Thread (Aug '16) Jul 12 Musikologist 4
M & W Outboards (Apr '10) Jul 12 Rdwrdw44 8

Palm Harbor Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

Palm Harbor Mortgages