Alum

Murray, KY

#1 Apr 17, 2012
Anyone been before? Got an anniversary on Monday and Cynthia's is closed. Would like a "nice" place, which I realize is a stretch in Paducah, but their website makes the place at least look decent. Any thoughts or other suggestions?
Alum

Murray, KY

#2 Apr 17, 2012
Supposed to say *Brick oven
DaBizz

Brentwood, TN

#4 Apr 17, 2012
Alum wrote:
Anyone been before? Got an anniversary on Monday and Cynthia's is closed. Would like a "nice" place, which I realize is a stretch in Paducah, but their website makes the place at least look decent. Any thoughts or other suggestions?
Does, best food in town.
Brian Allcock

Chicago, IL

#5 Apr 17, 2012
Does is ok. Overpriced for what you get though. Goto a good butcher and cook your own, if you know anything about grilling at all, you'd cut your expense by half. They reflect prices of steakhouses in NYC, and are nOt even in that caliber. Max's is a great place to go, many choses on the menu. Shandies is a good place as well, like there wine and food selections. You can dine outside there like Cynthia's and people watch, which On the right evening can be entertaining!!
local

Murfreesboro, TN

#6 Apr 17, 2012
Max's is very good. Doe's and JP's are also quite good. JP's and Max's both have beautiful outdoor dining. I don't much care for Shandies though.
UK Grad

Canton, OH

#8 Apr 18, 2012
I agree that I don't care for Shandie's, their menu was nothing special, but just my opinion. Max's is very good and has everything from steaks to pasta (and their Maker's Mark Chocolate Cake is to DIE for) and Restaurante de Fratelli's is very good and has a great ambience if your looking for fresh homemade italian (Lobster Ravioli.....YUM). I also like Doe's. We eat there quite regularly and can get out for less than $60 for a HUGE steak with sides and salad (and usually a beer and glass of wine). Prices are no more expensive than one of the Mall chains if you know that the steaks are sized to share. Hope you have a great anniversary wherever you choose!
just me

Nashville, TN

#9 Apr 18, 2012
The service at Doe's is normally terrible, or at least it always has been for us. They overbook reservations and when you show up your table can take up to an hour. Additionally, they try and have a "Band" (a guy playing a guitar and a girl singing) and its loud and intrusive not to mention the room it takes up in an already small bar and restaurant. The food is OK but over priced for what you get. They do have THICK steaks but there's more to a good steak then just being thick. Additionally, the manager there as WELL as the wait staff have TERRIBLE attitudes and look at people standing and waiting on tables as a bother instead of an opportunity.

Back you your original q (sorry for the rant) yes, Max's is a very nice place to eat. The service is normally good, a good wine list, the menu is complete, the specials are always well prepared and taste good, portions are never skimped on. Also, the outside seating is very nice as well as is the bar.

Happy Anniversary! Enjoy your meal and night out where ever you choose to eat!
never again

Louisville, KY

#10 Apr 18, 2012
Alum wrote:
Anyone been before? Got an anniversary on Monday and Cynthia's is closed. Would like a "nice" place, which I realize is a stretch in Paducah, but their website makes the place at least look decent. Any thoughts or other suggestions?
the chicken Chardonnay is fab!
Brad

United States

#11 Apr 18, 2012
Max's is a wonderful place. Great atmosphere, wonderful food, and great service. I go there all the time. The most important aspect is their consistency. It is always wonderful.
yea

Murfreesboro, TN

#12 Apr 18, 2012
Bick oven....more like d!ck oven...
just me

Nashville, TN

#14 Apr 19, 2012
ya know, FINALLY there's a reasonable thread on here about a decent topic, someone actually looking for useful information about something local and someone like "Leroy" has to bring it down to a 3rd grade level. amazing...
clearly

United States

#16 Apr 19, 2012
Max's is good but waaaay too pricey for what it is. JP's is good also and more reasonable. Shandies, overpriced.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Paducah Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Ruth Chris 18 min Doll 1
hot chick at sonic 18 min JASON 7
Ruth's Chris coming to Paducah 21 min Doll 11
News New cab company thriving in Paducah 27 min Iceman232 6
Easy woman in paducah and metropolis area 33 min Blt 14
Keep A Word - Drop A Word (Feb '10) 35 min So what 3,918
Trendy Repeats 44 min Redd 1

Paducah Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

Paducah Mortgages