Medina firefighter arrested for criminal sex act

Aug 28, 2012 Full story: WHEC-TV Rochester 12

A six-year veteran of the Medina Fire Department and part-time dispatcher for the Orleans County Sheriff's Office is under arrest.

Full Story
more counts

Batavia, NY

#1 Aug 29, 2012
Well Jeff just got charged with ANOTHER 7 counts. Wonder if this will continue to get worse......I hope not.
yikes

Batavia, NY

#2 Aug 29, 2012
Its actually 9 more counts and the police are quited as saying more charges are pending. Wonder if the few people on facebook defending him will continue to do so now that there are photos of him in the act at the job site.
observer

Batavia, NY

#3 Aug 29, 2012
Horrible accusations and if guilty he deserves state prison time. Rumors yesterday that he was going to get charged again and they actually came true. More rumors today about others being involved but I'll wait to see if true.
Oprrah

Beallsville, MD

#4 Aug 31, 2012
Yes has been accused by another underaged victim. And yes he has issues. And he has been out of the closet since he was outed by a supposed friend back in 2000. He use to date a girl just to have sex with her closet gay brother who since has come out, and he was a minor when Jeff was 18 or 19.
I am GUILTY

Batavia, NY

#6 Mar 18, 2013
Plead guility today in County Court. Sentencing to follow, life now as a registered sex offender.
Help

Batavia, NY

#7 Mar 19, 2013
I am GUILTY wrote:
Plead guility today in County Court. Sentencing to follow, life now as a registered sex offender.
To all charges?
A vacation

United States

#8 Mar 20, 2013
Probably wont get much time but will get and give plenty of anal and oral from cell mates. It will be like a vacation at the homo hotel. Now a real punishment would be putting in the womans cell block
Slapped Wrist

United States

#9 May 14, 2013
2 two year sentences to be served at same time. This guy will be out trolling for boys in 6 months.
SpeakOnWhatYouKn ow

Batavia, NY

#10 May 14, 2013
Actually, he's only serving TWO years. If you do not have your facts together, get them together before running your mouth. No one will ever know what exactly happened, you can make up accusations/lies/rumors all you want, but it doesn't make it true. Worry about your selves, whether than someone else. I'm sure if your house caught on fire you wouldn't second guess asking a him to help. He was a wonderful fire fighter who put his life in harm to help others. He was hard working and never stopped working since he's started, unlike majority of the people in Orleans who sit around collecting unemployment and state assistance. SPEAK ON WHAT YOU KNOW. & since that is very little, stop the false statements.
Unbelievable

Lyndonville, NY

#11 May 15, 2013
SpeakOnWhatYouKnow wrote:
Actually, he's only serving TWO years. If you do not have your facts together, get them together before running your mouth. No one will ever know what exactly happened, you can make up accusations/lies/rumors all you want, but it doesn't make it true. Worry about your selves, whether than someone else. I'm sure if your house caught on fire you wouldn't second guess asking a him to help. He was a wonderful fire fighter who put his life in harm to help others. He was hard working and never stopped working since he's started, unlike majority of the people in Orleans who sit around collecting unemployment and state assistance. SPEAK ON WHAT YOU KNOW. & since that is very little, stop the false statements.
Good people do bad things sometimes. The good things this young man did do not get him a free pass for his illegal actions. He is obviously aware of this because he plead guilty. Stop defending a pedophile. If it were your son that had been his victim I'm sure that you would be singing a different tune. Two concurrent sentences of two years each means that he WILL NOT serve two years. He will get out early for good behavior or whatever.
SpeakOnWhatYouKn ow

Batavia, NY

#12 May 16, 2013
Never said he should be given a free pass. How can you be so judgemental when you don't know the whole case? When you assume things you make a very ignorant and uneducated opinion.

Elsenheimer did not rape or abuse this "victim."

A little FYI: this "victim" approached Elsenheimer after a break up with his boyfriend (whom he had sexual intercourse with during their relationship) Another FYI: this "victim" did NOT want to file a report, his father did. If this "victim" was actually abused, why wouldn't he want to report the crime? OH YEAH.... Because he initiated the crime.

Don't speak on something when you don't have the facts correct. Passing judgement and throwing out rude names: Judge yourself before judging someone else. HMMMMM.....
Unbelievable

Lyndonville, NY

#13 May 17, 2013
Well the LAW says differently. It is against the law for a 30 something year old man to have sex with a minor. The LAW says the minor is a victim. Seriously, you are being closed minded. Do you have children? Would you want your 15 year old having sex with someone over 30? The teenager may have initiated the act, but the adult in this situation did know better and should not have given in to the sexual advances of a child. And what about the 2nd minor? And the inapproprate pictures of minors on his cell phone? And engaging in these activites at his place of employment? I'm not passing judgement, I'm stating facts. You are the one being ignorant, Jeff is obviously a friend or family to you. That being said, I have known Jeff casually since he was a child. He has a wonderful mother and he is an intelligent, educated person who made some choices using very poor judgement. I hate that this happened to him, but unfortunately it did and now there are consequences. I am not surprised that he took responsibility for his actions and plead guilty.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Olcott Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
medina hospital (Apr '13) 4 hr Tele 84
HEALTH: Man bitten by coyote on Sweeney Street ... (Apr '09) Oct 13 HIGh ya 47
Review: Steve's Custom Cycle (Jul '10) Oct 4 Ed B from Newfane 10
Police Arrest Man Accused of Stabbing Queens Li... Sep 30 friv4school 1
Alicia Bentley Sep 23 alphaomega91 1
neglected dog, waits to die Sep '14 ANIMAL LOVER 9
Some upsets in village elections (Mar '07) Sep '14 Vote Zornow 9
Olcott Dating
Find my Match

Olcott Jobs

Olcott People Search

Addresses and phone numbers for FREE

Olcott News, Events & Info

Click for news, events and info in Olcott

Personal Finance

Mortgages [ See current mortgage rates ]