SB member Ed Kurtz continues lies on ...

SB member Ed Kurtz continues lies on Dartmouth Wind Turbines

Posted in the North Dartmouth Forum

Rom Kelly

Mattapoisett, MA

#1 Dec 7, 2009

LETTER: No dark side to wind turbine plan
Text Size: A | A | A
Print this Article Email this Article
December 07, 2009 12:00 AM

No dark side
to wind turbine plan
The "Your View" from Barrett A. Hurwitz regarding the proposed Dartmouth wind turbines makes it sound like some sinister process is going on ("Get second opinion on Dartmouth Wind," Dec. 3). It's not sinister at all, and all residents on Chase Road should feel confident that they would not be physically endangered in any way.
Hurwitz casts doubt on the competence of the engineering firm hired to analyze the shadow-flicker problem, assuming that the fact that Dartmouth is their closest customer is evidence of their lack of competence. Actually, that fact can be interpreted as meaning that they are able to get customers far from here, an indication of the confidence others have in their competence.
Atlantic Design Engineers (AD), the firm in question, used a computer program called WindPro to do the shadow-flicker analysis. WindPro is marketed by EMD, a Danish company which markets this program worldwide for such analyses. Anybody running the program again would get exactly the same results AD got.(See the EMD Web site: .)
Shadow flicker can occur only, for example, when a house lies in the shadow of a wind turbine. For the houses on Chase Road, this could occur only when the sun is rising in the east, early in the morning. This condition would exist only several times a year and for only short time periods. Later, when the sun is overhead or when it is setting in the west, there would be no shadow problems.
At any rate, shadow flicker would not be a problem for any of the houses on Chase Road since the chairman of the Alternative Energy Committee has assured us that wind turbines would simply be shut down during any time periods shadow flicker would otherwise be a problem for anyone.
Edward Kurtz
Bill Carson

Greenville, RI

#3 Dec 7, 2009
Why would you write a letter that there is no dark side unless there was a dark side .

Why wouldn't the town get another engineering firm that has no ties to the town . Get another opinion ! If your spending 9 million dollars why wouldn't you get a second opinion ?

Something smells fishy here . Why the rush ?
Mary Delaney

Greenville, RI

#4 Dec 7, 2009
The news article above at the end says :
"the Alternative Energy Committee has assured us that wind turbines would simply be shut down during any time periods shadow flicker would otherwise be a problem for anyone."

This is absolute out and out B S . No where in the world do they shut these down for shadow flicker .

The residents in this town must be Hayseeds !

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

North Dartmouth Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Ever want to learn more about God? Nov 20 SSChurch 1
Boxing Commr. Patrick Bradley of Braintree Anno... Nov 9 jamestjordan 1
News Pols call for homeless czar Oct '16 former democrat 1
News Solar panels not always sunny Oct '16 tell it like it is 8
News Tyler Street TDI Fellow wants to enhance alread... Aug '16 cops are degenerates 1
News Westport police investigation continues into 'l... Jul '16 Roberta cares 1
700 animals Rescued in Massachusettes Jul '16 Uss constitution 1

North Dartmouth Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

North Dartmouth Mortgages