Perry County Man Charged With Rape

Jul 15, 2010 Full story: WHIZ-TV Zanesville 81

A Perry County business owner is in jail charged with rape. New Lexington Police Sgt.

Read more
Taco

Columbus, OH

#65 Jul 25, 2010
Marcy, You are nothing but a nosy busybody. Everyone knew it involved Dutiel. If you didn't, then you are stupid. You were just sticking your big nose where it doesn't belong because you have no life and you thrive on cheap gossip. Moreover, it was because your asinine question that that snake Decklin exposed the name of that poor girl. You are just trying to avoid responsibility for what you did. I put you in the same class as
Decklin. You, like Decklin, should be banned from this forum. Leave. Everyone hates people like you. The best place for people like you is church. Taco
Marcy wrote:
<quoted text>First, I only wanted to know who was being accused. So Taco,keep your opinion to yourself, K? Furthermore, as far as a slumlord, yes he does sell houses to people to fix up but he doesn't tell them they will never own the land. And, if he can't take care of those pets he has for sale then he needs to turn them over to the shelters becasue he DOES NOT take care of them. Who cares who he is or where he comes from, big deal. If he did what he has been accused of then he needs to pay the consequences. Period.
Love Me

Dublin, OH

#66 Jan 16, 2011
Innocent bystander wrote:
How much is Dutiel paying you to say this?
<quoted text>
He is wrong cheating on his WIFE AND GF??? He is f**ked up all together. The correct thing to say would've been to say for cheating on his WIFE. NOT both.
Indicted

Athens, OH

#67 Feb 25, 2011
Dutiel indicted for rape, four other counts.

Since: Aug 09

Bowling Green, OH

#68 Feb 25, 2011
About dang time too!!! Kudos to the Ohio Attorney General!!!
beenraped

Williamsburg, VA

#69 Sep 14, 2011
I was raped when I was young and I can tell she is lieing. I also know girls who said they were raped and they lied. It is such a shame that a mother would use her child that way. Disgraceful!!!
beenraped

Williamsburg, VA

#70 Sep 14, 2011
Yes, I rent from Dutiel and since the rent is so reasonable and he charged me 0 deposit... I put that savings into the place and it is now pretty nice. When I call, he answers and has always been there within the day. He has paid for maintaining the property and I have paid for bringing the property up to my standard of living. I am an attractive, single and live alone female and I haven't had any problems with him at all. In fact, he never comes alone. All he ever said to me is "you are too pretty to smoke". My brother took me to his "zoo" a few years back and the animals looked healthy. It is my opinion that his ex flame is trying to hurt him cause she didn't succeed in stealing him from his wife in an effort to get to his money so she put her daughter up to sleeping with him and crying "rape". As far as him being married, it is their personal business if they choose to have an open relationship, not ours. As far as having the city officials in his hip pocket, then why is the city always citing him? I read that here and the author needs to reread what you wrote because you contradict yourself. It is apparent that you just have an axe to grind. Shameful!
beenraped

Williamsburg, VA

#71 Sep 14, 2011
Decklin, I appreciate you naming the girl. I had just rented from Dutiel when all this came out and it concerned me for my own safety so I used my resources, position, experience and education to investigate all parties. Any person who charges any person with such a heinous crime is open to public scrutiny people. I was not impressed by what I found all the way around but the facts are important and the mother's credibiltiy won't hold up in court; IMHO.

Taco, why are you name calling? How am I suppose to give your statements any validity when you are displaying such immaturity? Go ahead, attack me too. But know this, I will gladly compare black and whites with you any day of the week. My bet is I live cleaner, have better credit, have friends with more influence and I am more than positive that my education level is much higher. Knock yourself out Baby. Hit me with your best shot! You can measure my concerns for your opinion of me in micro-give-a-shatz ;P

*black and whites = credibilty on paper*
ISeeStupidPeople

Thornville, OH

#72 Oct 28, 2011
Decklin, just how many different names do you use on this forum? It's not hard to tell which ones are you.

If Dutiel was such a great man, why do you think mostly everyone in 3 counties hates the guy? What has he done that pisses everyone off so much?#1:He's a slumlord. When my child was small, she made friends w/a little girl whose parents rented from him. They had NO HOT RUNNING WATER for YEARS. They were afraid to say anything because he said he'd throw them out & they couldn't afford other housing. Many tenants live like this in his homes. I've also seen copies of his Land Contracts. I'm surprised that they're legal. You end up paying 3 times what the original house is sold for, IF you ever get it paid off (& it's not burned to the ground first)...& if you miss ONE pymt, it's HIS AGAIN.
#2:He's run a filthy, disease-infested puppy-mill. Just Google his name & you can read the evidence that the Z-ville Times Recorder has (PDF file) on their site. He kept some of these sick animals in a trailer that was over 90 in the summer w/no A/C. I've seen his "Ranch". There's nothing good about it. I feel dirty just looking at it.
#3.He's scum & I'm surprised the church he attends doesn't cave in on him & that stupid-looking cowboy hat he wears. He looks like a clown. His brother Ron is just as skanky. The whole lot of them are low-life's & everyone knows it. The only people who associate w/them are JUST LIKE THEM. Trash. People hate Don because he brings trashy people into his trashy houses in their neighborhood. People who are trashy, like Don, don't understand this. How could they? It's all they've ever known. It's like people who can't smell themselves but stink like crazy.

What would the rape victim get out of charging Don w/rape? What's her goal? If I had sex w/this animal, I certainly would not want everyone in the state to know, even if I were raped. How humiliating. He's a disgusting pig & I cringe every time I see the dirtbag. I just want to punch him right in the face & have felt that way since I was a kid (I'm 50 now) & he would look at me the way no man should ever look at a little girl. I was told when I was young that he molested his own children. What a sick bastard.

It's too bad that they still don't hang people in the public square any longer because this SOB deserves it, especially for the rape. He's screwed over, taken advantage of people, has caused the death of too many animals & is responsible for the deaths of 3 people (who died in a fire due to the lack of smoke alarms in the house they rented from him) for way too long and now he's going to reap what he's sown.

I hope Emily Pelphrey (Ohio Attorney Generals Office) fries his ass at the end of November. The whole county will celebrate the end of this dirtbag who is an embarrassment not only to the town of New Lexington,(which used to be a beautiful small town to live in until he started his slum business that brought more poor to this area & lowered the value of our homes), but to the whole friggin' county. 99% of people who have heard of Don Dutiel hate him. And that IS a fact.
foryoutofindout

Dayton, OH

#73 Jan 23, 2012
Dutiel is a slum lord.Some of his place don't even have walls or floors. And i heard if you don't have the rent he has sex with you.
foryoutofindout

Dayton, OH

#74 Jan 23, 2012
He is a slum lord.
Wang

Delaware, OH

#75 Feb 25, 2012
Decklin is uninformed
Kymmie

Steubenville, OH

#76 Jul 3, 2012
Decklin is Donald Dutiel............
memilitant

Columbus, OH

#77 Jan 1, 2013
Dutiel Properties brings a level playing field to the communities that outcast the poor -or- those whom are in a rut. Most landlords in Ohio make tenants go thru endless hurdles and pay extreme amounts before they can rent. I've worked in the rental property field for years and if I've seen it once, I've seen it a thousand times where a family sits at a desk for hours hoping to get an apartment or house only to be told, you have bad credit - so we can't rent to you ... or you've got a misdemeanor on your record from 20 years ago so we can't rent to you ... or you owe the library fifty cents so we can't rent to you. This is where Dutiel Properties comes in to save the day. Dutiel charges no up front fees, like application fees or pet fees [which both are a joke in Ohio], does not charge a deposit and tells the new tenants to use that $ to clean the rentals if need be, doesn't do background checks where most LLs will not rent if you have a misunderstood 20 year old misdemeanor on your record, and probably best of all, Dutiel doesn't even ask for names in case you may be hiding from a abusive spouse.

Though many that personally know Don [as I do] do not respect his marriage arrangement, even tho most Old Testament folks lived the same way. The bottom line is ... if you can't afford the govt's way to rent a place, Dutiel Properties will save you from becoming homeless, even when the govt says no.

Since: Dec 12

Location hidden

#78 Jan 1, 2013
He had consensual sex with Matt Stickdorn in the snow last winter behind the abandoned house next door to him. The snow keeps ole tubby from sweating too bad so not to over exert his fatt ass.:)
Tiffany New Lex Resident

Findlay, OH

#79 Mar 4, 2013
My husband and I rented off him BC we could not afford anything else at the time. DUTIEL made several advances toward me. He even tried getting me to go to a farmhouse of his with him instead of paying rent... He's a very nasty man... if you want to call him that.
Diana

Columbus, OH

#80 Mar 4, 2013
memilitant wrote:
Dutiel Properties brings a level playing field to the communities that outcast the poor -or- those whom are in a rut. Most landlords in Ohio make tenants go thru endless hurdles and pay extreme amounts before they can rent. I've worked in the rental property field for years and if I've seen it once, I've seen it a thousand times where a family sits at a desk for hours hoping to get an apartment or house only to be told, you have bad credit - so we can't rent to you ... or you've got a misdemeanor on your record from 20 years ago so we can't rent to you ... or you owe the library fifty cents so we can't rent to you. This is where Dutiel Properties comes in to save the day. Dutiel charges no up front fees, like application fees or pet fees [which both are a joke in Ohio], does not charge a deposit and tells the new tenants to use that $ to clean the rentals if need be, doesn't do background checks where most LLs will not rent if you have a misunderstood 20 year old misdemeanor on your record, and probably best of all, Dutiel doesn't even ask for names in case you may be hiding from a abusive spouse.
Though many that personally know Don [as I do] do not respect his marriage arrangement, even tho most Old Testament folks lived the same way. The bottom line is ... if you can't afford the govt's way to rent a place, Dutiel Properties will save you from becoming homeless, even when the govt says no.
Although you certainly seem somewhat educated, you're missing one big factor here. The Dutiels aren't helping the outcast; they're exploiting them. The Dutiels rent out houses (and I use the term loosely) that couldn't/shouldn't pass a health inspection and are virtually uninhabitable. They take hard-earned money from individuals who are forced to rent from them because they've bought up all of the lower-income properties in the county. IF the Dutiels were (as you suggest) at all compassionate desiring to help the outcast, they would ensure that the properties were brought up to code and SAFE before renting them. Are you forgetting the wrongful death suit pending against them for the loss of a family in their first few days living in a Dutiel property? Donald Dutiel is many things, but compassionate is not one of them. Get your facts straight.
beenraped

Athens, AL

#82 Nov 20, 2013
ISeeStupidPeople wrote:
Decklin, just how many different names do you use on this forum? It's not hard to tell which ones are you.
If Dutiel was such a great man, why do you think mostly everyone in 3 counties hates the guy? What has he done that pisses everyone off so much?#1:He's a slumlord. When my child was small, she made friends w/a little girl whose parents rented from him. They had NO HOT RUNNING WATER for YEARS. They were afraid to say anything because he said he'd throw them out & they couldn't afford other housing. Many tenants live like this in his homes. I've also seen copies of his Land Contracts. I'm surprised that they're legal. You end up paying 3 times what the original house is sold for, IF you ever get it paid off (& it's not burned to the ground first)...& if you miss ONE pymt, it's HIS AGAIN.
#2:He's run a filthy, disease-infested puppy-mill. Just Google his name & you can read the evidence that the Z-ville Times Recorder has (PDF file) on their site. He kept some of these sick animals in a trailer that was over 90 in the summer w/no A/C. I've seen his "Ranch". There's nothing good about it. I feel dirty just looking at it.
#3.He's scum & I'm surprised the church he attends doesn't cave in on him & that stupid-looking cowboy hat he wears. He looks like a clown. His brother Ron is just as skanky. The whole lot of them are low-life's & everyone knows it. The only people who associate w/them are JUST LIKE THEM. Trash. People hate Don because he brings trashy people into his trashy houses in their neighborhood. People who are trashy, like Don, don't understand this. How could they? It's all they've ever known. It's like people who can't smell themselves but stink like crazy.
What would the rape victim get out of charging Don w/rape? What's her goal? If I had sex w/this animal, I certainly would not want everyone in the state to know, even if I were raped. How humiliating. He's a disgusting pig & I cringe every time I see the dirtbag. I just want to punch him right in the face & have felt that way since I was a kid (I'm 50 now) & he would look at me the way no man should ever look at a little girl. I was told when I was young that he molested his own children. What a sick bastard.
It's too bad that they still don't hang people in the public square any longer because this SOB deserves it, especially for the rape. He's screwed over, taken advantage of people, has caused the death of too many animals & is responsible for the deaths of 3 people (who died in a fire due to the lack of smoke alarms in the house they rented from him) for way too long and now he's going to reap what he's sown.
I hope Emily Pelphrey (Ohio Attorney Generals Office) fries his ass at the end of November. The whole county will celebrate the end of this dirtbag who is an embarrassment not only to the town of New Lexington,(which used to be a beautiful small town to live in until he started his slum business that brought more poor to this area & lowered the value of our homes), but to the whole friggin' county. 99% of people who have heard of Don Dutiel hate him. And that IS a fact.
I know you didn't direct that at me. I will be the first to tell you to get out of the mirror and you won't see stupid anymore. I am who exactly who I say I am. You; however; are not stating facts. I spent weeks interviewing strangers all over New Lex as I knew nobody in the town and was concerned for my safety after hearing about this case. I found that the love/hate for DD is right at 50/50. I do find it sad that you feel you have to lump people together as 1 person in speculation just like you speculate knowing what happened. Just shows your credibility holds water like a bucket with holes.
beenraped

Athens, AL

#83 Nov 20, 2013
Go ahead, ask me why my location shows up different when I post. Then look at the locations. See Newport News, Virgina? See Athens, Alabama? I am a govmt. contractor and do investigations for a living on a federal level. This site records the location from which you are posting.
And Dianna, I have known and worked with some of the top rated investigators in Ohio and the country. I have NEVER seen an investigator discuss an open case asking for intel rather than doing your groundwork; especially on a public forum! VERY UNPROFESSIONAL! I highly doubt you are a legitimate PI!
beenraped

Athens, AL

#84 Nov 20, 2013
Have any of you read the civil case findings? Note that the DNA findings actually cleared him. Imagine that! Now, I will say it once again but a little bit louder "I AM SINGLE, ATTRACTIVE AND DID RENT FROM DUTIEL. HE NEVER DISRESPECTED ME! Of course he did understand that I am a fed and the 50,000 dollar truck I drove while on assignments may have been intimidating. I paid my rent, fixed the place up and then moved out because I came home from DC to find his gf in my place cutting electrical wires after I had all ready been told by my neighbors who petset for me that she had tried to burn my place down but they put it out right after she left. He needs to leave crazy women alone and work on his marriage. I told him that the day I left along with get a better attorney and hire my former PI boss. Now that I see "Dianne" is the PI against him and that his attorney talked him into a plea bargain even though she had the evidence shown in this civil case ,that would have been the best thing he could have done. He should've listened to me! I just hope it is not true that he has spent 350,000 dollars defending all this bs against him. I will call and find out. If it is true, you will see exactly who I am! What I am is someone with a 127,000 dollar education who knows how to use it and the connections to get it done. On the other hand, if DD has 350,000 dollars to pay to get out of trouble then yes he should invest in his properties. Insuring the one that burnt down for 24,500 dollars does not set well with me at all. That doesn't cover liability on a rental. Of course he sold that property. It is a sale even if it wasn't qualified as a land-contract. The people who signed those papers made themselves 100% liable with those signatures. However, on a moral note, he should have insisted they insure it before giving them possession. But a sale is "as is". I have to wonder if that woman was attractive and DD's psycho gf didn't cause that fire like she tried to in my place TWICE! She was lucky I was mid-stream in the restroom when I heard her in my place as I had just came in from DC and jetted straight for the RR. By the time I got free, she was spinning out of the back alley. My neighbors and I all told him; and that we would testify. He said that his attorney was her aunt or friend or something of that nature and he felt stuck because he had all ready paid her in full. So he has a heart of gold, an infidelity issue (of which I understand is wife makes dinners for him and his gfs which is what makes it their biz not ours and he has very lil biz sense on sooo many levels. I am glad he turned the properties and ranch over to his wife to run. At least she is not a target and she seems pretty intelligent.
beenraped

Athens, AL

#85 Nov 20, 2013
Let me make this point, there are women on here who claim that he came on to them, looked at her wrong when she was a child, made lil kids live with no heat or water for years. I have seen accusations that he forced people to let him have sex with their daughters in exchange for rent. Why has their never been a law suit, a report made with child services or at least a letter to the BBB? My neighbors were a young man with an attractive gf and they were months behind on their rent. She said they had rented from him for years and he never made advances to her. He remodeled their whole apartment while they were behind on rent. DD is twice the size of her bf so it wouldn't be fear and if he has the town in his pocket, why didn't he rape her or at least come on to her? I interviewed women all over town and very few said he made advances on them. The few that did were not attractive at all and were quick to fill my ears with several other types of unbelievable stories as well. I was told he raped a little girl and was a murderer who brutally killed a whole family in their sleep by these few women, making it as if he went in their home and chopped them into pieces or burnt the house down because they were behind in rent said another. They had lived their that day only. How could they be "so far behind"? I will say this, I have lived in 11 states and Ohio seems to home of the bs artists. Not even Florida comes close and half of that population is either running from the law or just released. You have non-profit country clubs that cost 10,000 dollars to join, a former governor stealing from the treasury while publicly stating there is no funds for school books, an EPA willing to change the standards for drinking water to appease the corporate big dogs, courts that lock people in the courthouse til they sign their property rights over to them on arraignment so that if they don't show up for court, the county or city can seize their property then prosecutors who call the day before and lie to you saying your court date was changed and you don't need to show up, cat houses next to police stations, strippers riding around in cop cars, cops having sex with hookers then arresting them... Oh I could go on and on. It's no wonder everybody is slap smooth out-of-it. Your leadership is a joke.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

New Lexington Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Police intrapment Mar 9 bao 4
anyone know? Feb 28 that guy 2
Anyone know Robert hackler out of Buckeye Lake ... Feb '15 FagsDonewrong411 1
Kayla Cauthon Feb '15 shesacompletewh0re 1
help Feb '15 tank 1
steven danielson Feb '15 logan 1
any one know eric barnes from sissonville ? Jan '15 Martha 1
New Lexington Dating
Find my Match
More from around the web

New Lexington People Search

Addresses and phone numbers for FREE

Personal Finance

Mortgages [ See current mortgage rates ]