Zach Witman: 'Take a second look'

Zach Witman: 'Take a second look'

There are 545 comments on the The York Daily Record story from Dec 19, 2010, titled Zach Witman: 'Take a second look'. In it, The York Daily Record reports that:

Ron and Sue Witman say they would exhume their son Gregory's body if it would help prove their other son, Zachary, was not the person who stabbed Gregory to death.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at The York Daily Record.

First Prev
of 28
Next Last

York, PA

#1 Dec 19, 2010
OMG, are the Witmans and their denial issues ever going to go away. Get some help for your denial issues---never underestimate the power of denial.





Reply »
Report Abuse Judge it!

York, PA

#3 Dec 19, 2010
It is easy to understand the parents pain, and no one denies them that right.This story is very sad and this should never happen to anyone,but if Zach did not kill his brother, who did? I have also noticed that there have not been any similar killings in the area since this tragic event.Zach has been proven guilty, by law.

York, PA

#6 Dec 19, 2010
I don't think he did it

York, PA

#7 Dec 19, 2010
How are the parents still living in that house??

Simpsonville, SC

#8 Dec 19, 2010
On e important fact not in the article is what about all the other incriminating evidence pointing to the fact that the brother DID IT!!! I understand parents standing by their kids but ENOUGH, he did it and they know he did it !

York, PA

#9 Dec 19, 2010
After reading the article, and self-admittedly thinking his brother did kill him without question initially, the time lines prove to be evidence enough to "consider" maybe he really didn't. The suspicious hanging up the phone before he got home, to the calm phone call after the murder. The carrying of Greg over the gate is also a very valid point since no 90lbs kid could lift a totally bloody 65lbs BODY over a gate without smearing it somewhere. These are valid points and more people should open their minds to this being a random act by another sick person that isn't Zach. The courts should hear this out, and I think new/old investigators could be brought in to rework the scene better.

Etters, PA

#10 Dec 19, 2010
This whole thing has been a flustercluck since day 1
john doe 000069

York, PA

#11 Dec 19, 2010
Zach Witman was railroaded from the begining. How many times will the law get away with the abuse of their offices. The high school principal Jay Smith was handed 3 death sentances before being released from prison. Ray Crone was on death row in Arazona before he was released. How many people are in prison for crimes they didn't commit because of the egos of the da's. How much is it going to cost taxpayers when Mr. Witman is finally released and he sues the crap out of Pa?

Wilmington, DE

#12 Dec 19, 2010
All murderers want to get out of prison. Keep this sicko where he belongs, in prison for life for taking his brother's life!!!

York, PA

#13 Dec 19, 2010
I just want to say that I hope the best for all of you! I agree our justice system is blind. The people that are doing the investigations this that are just out to convict someone and make a name for themselves. I have been put into a situation myself that that is all they wanted! Best of wishes for you and family!

York, PA

#15 Dec 19, 2010
I will say I do not know all the evidence in the case. I am just saying that I think why not grant a new trial see what happens then it can be put to rest!

Wilmington, DE

#16 Dec 19, 2010
The kid even hid his bloody gloves in the yard by a tree. And you can see the devil in his eyes!!

Streator, IL

#17 Dec 19, 2010
It's an absolute shame that our justice system allows this abuse. Let him rot in jail. Zach along with the parents never gave a crap for the victim. Will this ever stop and will the taxpayers money ever stop being thrown down the toilet. Heres a thought...If found guilty again, Mr and Mrs Witman pay the state of PA all of the money that was spent over the years.
Darwin is my Zero

New Freedom, PA

#20 Dec 19, 2010
He's a freak. Leave him in the whole. I'm sick of this story and sick of the stain its left on New Freedom. Bury it and Whitman.

Jarrettsville, MD

#21 Dec 19, 2010
A random killer would not stop in the backyard to bury evidence. And a random killer would have done something else, like rob the house. I highly doubt there has been a killer lurking around New Freedom for the last 12 years. I'm so sorry for the Witman's pain, and I cannot say what I'd do in that situation but I hope I would be strong enough to accept the facts as they are. Mr. & Mrs. Witman, I hope whatever happens next, God grants you peace in some way.

United States

#22 Dec 19, 2010
They should ship the whole family out of this country forever. They have wasted enough of our time and money.

Since: Feb 08

Location hidden

#23 Dec 19, 2010
smf9973 wrote:
I will say I do not know all the evidence in the case. I am just saying that I think why not grant a new trial see what happens then it can be put to rest!
There is NO grounds for a new trial. Every appeal they filed as been denied because there was no grounds for a new trial and no new evidence to support a new trial being granted.

Shrewsbury, PA

#24 Dec 19, 2010
Regardless of some of these idiots above, this is an excellent piece of journalism. Great job YDR.
john doe 000069

York, PA

#25 Dec 19, 2010
John wrote:
They should ship the whole family out of this country forever. They have wasted enough of our time and money.
They should ship you out of this country. You think they have spent a lot of money now? Just wait until he gets let out of prison and sues the crap out of Pa. Not to mention the fact that tihe liar pigs said Greg's head was almost cut off. How? Did you see the small knives they have logged in as evidence? If you can believe the liar pigs.
Rick Tracy

East Berlin, PA

#26 Dec 19, 2010
I'd love to believe Zacharytman didn't kill his brother, but there is not one mention of any evidence linking anyone else to the crime but Zachary Witman. Never was, never will be.

Just farfetched sightings of white vans and the assertion that Zach Witman spoke normally during the 911 call. Also, the statement that Zachary Witmman loved his brother.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 28
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

New Freedom Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
zachary witman "rage turned murder" (Jan '07) Dec 19 Erin 34
News Friends of Fawn Twp. homicide victim call abuse... (May '11) Nov '17 Joe dirt 24
News A look at the family rescued from Taliban-linke... Oct '17 Lucky 1
News Reading & Northern Railroad... Sep '17 YouChewPoop 6
News Cider fest returns to Gettysburg (May '17) Aug '17 Costard 10
Seiling Furniture Co. Railroad, Pa (Aug '10) Aug '17 Gloria Lauria 29
News If your neighbor's house is falling apart, don'... (Mar '11) Aug '17 Denise Leigh 53

New Freedom Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

New Freedom Mortgages