Understanding the law: A barís liability for serving minors alcohol

Posted in the Natchitoches Forum

big boy

United States

#1 Apr 16, 2010
Posted On: March 2, 2010 by The Berniard Law Firm
Understanding the law: A barís liability for serving minors alcohol
Recently, in Lafayette, Louisiana, The Advocate reports that ďlocal bars ... allegedly sold alcohol to [two] underage drinkers, both of whom later died in separate and unrelated incidents.Ē An obvious tragedy, the matter serves as a stunning reminder that liability for businesses goes beyond what happens on their property. When a bar serves alcohol to a minor, it can be held legally liable for the ensuing injuries and harm to the minor.

If a bar óor any other liquor retaileró serves alcohol to a minor, determining whether the bar is liable for the minorís ensuing harm is a difficult and tricky process. This article is intended as an introductory guide to help you better understand your legal rights and whether you should seek legal representation.

A bar has a duty to not serve alcohol to minors. If the bar negligently breaches that duty, it will be held liable for the harm caused to the minor when it is both (1) a cause-in-fact and (2) a legal cause of the underage drinkerís resulting harm.

The Supreme Court of Louisiana case of Berg v. Zummo is the legal authority on a barís liability for serving alcohol to minors. According to Berg, a bar negligently breaches its duty to not serve minors alcohol when it ďfails to exercise the care of a reasonable person under the circumstances.Ē

Determining what is and isnít a reasonable effort of a bar's efforts in preventing minors from purchasing or consuming alcohol on the premises depends on the specific facts of the situation. As a general guide, if a bar doesnít check the minorís identification when he or she enters the bar or when he or she purchased the alcohol, the bar likely breached its duty.

The issue of the purchase or consumption leading to the event is called "cause-in-fact." Cause-in-fact basically means that if the bar had not served alcohol to the minor, the minor would not have been harmed. As recognized in Berg, a cause-in-fact need only be ďa substantial factor in bringing about that harm.Ē Thus, the barís service of alcohol does not need to be the only cause-in-fact of the minorís harm.

The following is an example illustrating cause-in-fact. For the following two situations, assume a bar breached its duty and served alcohol to a minor. If the minor then gets in a car accident solely because he is intoxicated, the barís conduct is a cause-in-fact. If the minor gets in a car accident solely because he is a horrible driver and the accident would have happened if he didnít drink, the barís service of alcohol is not a cause-in-fact.

A barís service of alcohol to a minor is a legal cause of the minorís harm when the risk of that harm occurring was within the barís scope of duty. Basically, legal cause means that the minorís harm must be sufficiently connected to the barís service of alcohol to the minor.

For example, in Berg, the court stated that ďthe risk that a minor who is served alcohol might become intoxicated and get into a fight and injure someone with his car is clearly within [the barís] scope of dutyĒ to not serve alcohol to a minor and, thus, is a legal cause of the minorís harm. However, the risk that a minor who is served alcohol might be struck by lightning on the walk home from the bar is probably not within the barís scope of duty and is not a legal cause.

If you need help with legal claims arising out of a bar service of alcohol to a minor, call the Berniard Law Firm Toll-Free at 1-866-574-8005 and an attorney will help you with the legal assistance you deserve.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Natchitoches Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Who do you support for U.S. Senate in Louisiana... (Oct '10) 50 min Mick 3,288
who's this guy name Jock!!! 1 hr Bobby 6
oh i see the parish roads has not changed one bit 2 hr freddy 2
natchitoches parish roads (Apr '13) 8 hr freddy 54
What happened at tithe school board meeting ? 8 hr NCHS 58
Kim Jarrett (Jul '12) 8 hr this is me 98
WHITE women love BLACK MEAT. (May '11) 8 hr granny 52

Natchitoches Jobs

Enter and win $5000

Natchitoches People Search

Addresses and phone numbers for FREE


Natchitoches News, Events & Info

Click for news, events and info in Natchitoches

Personal Finance

Mortgages [ See current mortgage rates ]