Rachel shoaf and Sheila eddy
law & disorder

Clarksburg, WV

#945 May 19, 2013
What made her talk to someone from the news paper?
please

Morgantown, WV

#946 May 19, 2013
Ugly Little Liars wrote:
I wonder why Shania all of a sudden stopped supporting Shelia? It's just curious to me that she defended her so much up to this point, up to just a handful of days ago really, and wanted to believe she was innocent - but now she's decided Shelia is no longer to be associated with. Very interesting to see her dissociate herself with Eddy, deny knowledge of the crime, and even say the supposed motive was "repulsive".
And I'm going to call bullshit on Shelia Eddy being a crying wimp who never fought, stood up for herself, or showed a violent side. Unless literally ALL of her many, many psycho thoughts and tendencies were only displayed publicly through her Twitter. What are the odds of that, really? As just one example of many, Eddy was casually laughing and joking about smashing her baby turtles to death with a hammer because she was too lazy to take care of them anymore, but her best friend never saw a weird or violent side to her? Weird that Ammons would be trying to paint this picture of a timid, shy, bullied Shelia Eddy.
For the record, I don't necessarily believe Ammons knew of the crime, though I feel there is a possibility that she did given the brazen nature of the two murderers, the fact that they openly joked about the killing, and the fact that MANY people knew WAY too many details WAY before they became public. Eddy and Shoaf were talking, the question is, to whom?
Something just doesn't seem right about that article, for me. I could believe that Ammons was deceived by the two psychopaths, but why is she trying to make Shelia look so timid and innocent when she is, by all accounts, anything but?
I absolutely agree. Shannon's words raise many red flags. She speaks so personally of Shelia, wanting us to paint a picture of what she describes, when in reality, Shelia is the total opposite. Why does she go into detail of how timid and shy she is? Does that have anything to do with her arguing that she didn't know anything about the murder? Seems as though she is avoiding that question and instead speaking "good" of someone she is supposedly not defending anymore.

All I'm saying is... If it were me, and that were my friend who committed a murder, the last thing I would be doing is try to defend her personality. There's no reason to sugar coat anything. The truth is out. The girl is a cold blooded murderer with no remorse; nothing more, nothing less. If anything I would be thanking GOD it wasn't me that she targeted.
Only the facts

United States

#947 May 19, 2013
[QUOTE who="law & disorder"]What made her talk to someone from the news paper?[/QUOTE]

I think it was to get the heat off of her. She has run her filthy rude obnoxious mouth on twitter defending her bestie & she wonders why people think she was involved or knew something. FYI: When you lay down with dogs you get fleas.
law & disorder

Clarksburg, WV

#948 May 19, 2013
Only the facts wrote:
[QUOTE who="law & disorder"]What made her talk to someone from the news paper? "

I think it was to get the heat off of her. She has run her filthy rude obnoxious mouth on twitter defending her bestie & she wonders why people think she was involved or knew something. FYI: When you lay down with dogs you get fleas.
Oh Lordy my momma has told me that line once in my younger years .. And boy was she right !
neighbor

Cuero, TX

#949 May 19, 2013
Was the article cited actually from a valid news source? I only ask because of how crudely it was written. "Could've" alone brings questions to the source. Neither here nor there, I know. But what an odd choice of topic...why would they choose to run with a story so rudimentary? At least Skylar's name stays in the news. I wish we'd hear of her nationwide, however.
Lisa

United States

#950 May 19, 2013
neighbor wrote:
Was the article cited actually from a valid news source? I only ask because of how crudely it was written. "Could've" alone brings questions to the source. Neither here nor there, I know. But what an odd choice of topic...why would they choose to run with a story so rudimentary? At least Skylar's name stays in the news. I wish we'd hear of her nationwide, however.


It was in today's Dominion Post.
Theyre Not That Innocent

Springfield, NJ

#951 May 19, 2013
That article is very suspicious - it really makes me think Ms. Ammons is trying to cover or hide something. The lies about Shelia being some kind of frightened, innocent bullying victim are disturbing. Make no mistake - those are lies. Eddy is an aggressive bitch.

Why is Shania Ammons lying about Shelia Eddy's character? To make herself seem like she didnt know anything about Skylar because Shelia was so deceptive? To make her buddy Shelia seem less guilty (in the sense that Shoaf was the mastermind)? Or a little bit of both...
Paul

Charleston, WV

#952 May 19, 2013
I said in an earlier comment that Sheliar's defense will be that she had nothing to do with Rachel killing Skylar. She only told the lies after because she was afraid of Rachel and Rachel threatened to kill her.

Ammons is setting up that defense.

NYB

Since: May 13

Location hidden

#953 May 19, 2013
Theyre Not That Innocent wrote:
That article is very suspicious - it really makes me think Ms. Ammons is trying to cover or hide something. The lies about Shelia being some kind of frightened, innocent bullying victim are disturbing. Make no mistake - those are lies. Eddy is an aggressive bitch.
Why is Shania Ammons lying about Shelia Eddy's character? To make herself seem like she didnt know anything about Skylar because Shelia was so deceptive? To make her buddy Shelia seem less guilty (in the sense that Shoaf was the mastermind)? Or a little bit of both...
May I ask how you know that? Are you a personal acquaintance of these two girls or is your judgement coming from your knowledge of their social media. I am just asking so that I can better understand how you might have a different opinion than her best friend.
askmeaboutmywein er

Suffolk, VA

#954 May 19, 2013
its too bad autumn claims to never have heard of rachel. but rachel retweeted her tweets numerous times.
Chill

Monongahela, PA

#955 May 19, 2013
anonymous user wrote:
<quoted text>
You best watch what you say. Libel, even on a forum such as topix, is punishable. Might want to see what happened in Steubenville to some people who spoke "out of turn". They were arrested and imprisoned.
I find it disgusting (and disturbing) that so many of you "arm chair detectives" and "voyeuristic vultures" are saying the things you're saying, and namedropping students, family members, and even random people who share the last name of one of the alleged perpetrators. My advice is to research cyber criminal law. Freedom of speech doesn't cover quite as much as some of you think it does.
What if Rachel's and the other girl's parents knew nothing of any of this until court? What if, due to attorney-client privileges, and doctor-patient privileges, these parents were in the dark until they entered the courtroom? Socios and psychopaths are adept at deception. What hasn't been discussed much is the mental illnesses likely involved in this case.
1. Psychopath behavior doesn't usually manifest itself until approximately age 15.
2. Many well-trained and renowned mental health professionals continue to debate "nature vs. nurture" aspects of sociopathy and psychopathy. They're complex diseases.
3. Regarding mental illness, I frankly am more concerned re: Rachel's mental health than I am for the other girl's. Most psychopaths and sociopaths are extremely adept at acting and displaying the expected emotions, although they honestly don't really know what empathy or conscience is. The other girl's tweets, for example, appear to be more of a narcissistic personality disorder and less of psychopathy or sociopathy, as she verbalizes "in your face" messages on social networks. Most with psych or socio illness HIDE that kind of behavior. They literally rely on their acting abilities to fit in and express themselves like they know they're supposed to. The phrase "still waters run deep" can apply to the more quiet ones with the more serious mental defects.
4. Please remember that no one sets out to raise a mentally ill child, and no one suffering from one of these diseases asks to be mentally ill, either. Not much can be done to improve these illnesses, and there is no "cure". However, you wouldn't shame a person for being ill with cancer or diabetes (even though those can actually, in some circumstances, be preventable whereas psychopathy cannot).
5. The true test of character of those who reside in Morgantown will be the ones who empathize and embrace ALL THREE SETS of parents. It's easy to join the seek-justice bandwagon for the family of the lost child. In reality, all three are lost kids - just two of them are still breathing. I can guarantee you there will not be one peaceful minute for the parents of the two who allegedly committed this heinous murder. They'll constantly question themselves as to what they could have done differently, what signs might they have missed (which is may be none, due to their age/typical onset of the diseases). They've already been tried & convicted by the "internet court" for being responsible for their daughters' actions, and are basically considered pariahs for doing nothing other than being related to these girls, and (presumably) loving them.
e...
I'm usually not so mean, but you are stupid as f* to think you can make threats about "libel" from that innocent statement. And that is coming from someone who knows for a fact so stfu dumb a**!!
London

Monongahela, PA

#956 May 19, 2013
Theyre Not That Innocent wrote:
That article is very suspicious - it really makes me think Ms. Ammons is trying to cover or hide something. The lies about Shelia being some kind of frightened, innocent bullying victim are disturbing. Make no mistake - those are lies. Eddy is an aggressive bitch.
Why is Shania Ammons lying about Shelia Eddy's character? To make herself seem like she didnt know anything about Skylar because Shelia was so deceptive? To make her buddy Shelia seem less guilty (in the sense that Shoaf was the mastermind)? Or a little bit of both...
She isn't necessarily lying. A lot of chihuahuas are brave when hidden behind their computer desk. Shelia probably was timid and wimpy and then lashed out on her computer to seem brave. U think Miss Ammon's is just trying to get what she believes as the truth, out there so people will leave her alone. She really has been harassed on twitter. And I think-hope-she really did love Skylar.

In looking at the friends, I'd say focus in Alexis, Boggs, and perhaps the other Eddy's, rather than SA. That's just my opinion of course. But it seems funny to me that certain people said Boggs dumped firecrotch and had nothing to do with her after her confession and yet you can clearly see from those tweets by Rachel that he was still the "best boyfriend in the world" as recently as March. What's that say about him being so "innocent"?

Jmo but I believe Rachel really was the jealous mastermind. Skylar and SE didn't even have problems until they met her.....
stunned

New Kensington, PA

#957 May 19, 2013
What did you say wrote:
<quoted text>
How do you defend a CONFESSED murderer? A little articulated with your words there to be "close friends" with a "pot head" highschooler.... Just a thought.
These kids were very intelligent and "higly articulate" themselves. Don't judge the poster...it's their opinion.I didn't see any defense of either suspects (yes, I know Rachel is convicted).

Since: Mar 13

Location hidden

#958 May 19, 2013
Just an FYI in case you're only reading this thread, there is some new information on the 'What are Sheila Eddy and Rachel Shoaf like?' thread.
stunned

New Kensington, PA

#959 May 19, 2013
Not-Long-Enough wrote:
I knew skylar through a mutual friend, and this b**ch rachel shoaf got off easy with 20 years, I hope she either becomes some giant lesbians punching tool (if ya know what i mean) or gets the death penalty. I hope she sufferes as Skylar suffered.
Other chick, Eddy, the only reason she's not being charged is because she didn't admit anything, I can almost gaurentee Shoaf wont do anything about that.
If you're asking me both those girls need to be put away for life, shoaf for murder and Eddy for being an accomplice, or at minimum conspiracy. GOD i hate these to people. who the hell does that?! when i was 16 i was trying to get my first kiss, not smoking pot and stabbing people.
(i looked at shoafs youtube acct. and its obvious she was a heavy drug user.)
I hope to God they both get whats coming for them, and I hope the Neese family gets their justice. God knows they deserve it.
You only know Shoaf's involvement because she CONFESSED to get a plea agreement. The other suspect hasn't done so because they won't give let her plead! So, she doesn't have a choice but to plead not guilty in order to have any chance of saving her butt. So, Shoaf should get a heavier sentence because she confessed and lead the police to the remains and the other suspect should be an accomplice because she says she's not guilty? Wow! Great logic there!!
stunned

New Kensington, PA

#960 May 19, 2013
Anon wrote:
Somebody said they watched Rachel's YouTube channel... What's the name of it?
just google Rachel Shoaf and you'll find it. She's singing a song from Les Mis
stunned

New Kensington, PA

#961 May 19, 2013
mor like stupid lil liars wrote:
u r SO rite that SE has no remorse....lmao tweetin about baby elephants n sleeping...dont 4get the BIG MACS, chikfilet n any n every other food she can stuff in her mouth! What REALLY got me was the crazy amount of times she said she was gonna shOOt herself in the face!!!=0 I just wondered y she would constantly say that...guilt maybe??...there is somethin SERIOUSLY WRONG wit that child! Its really sad, poor poor Skylar n her family :(:( but wut no1 has mentioned is that not only 1 but 3 familys r destroyed n 3 mothers\fathers have lost thier daughters.... I cant imagine how all these parents r feeling its insane. I want to know WHAT N WHY would turn a teenage girl to commit such evil acts... JUDY-Didnt these two, RS n SE stop n beat Skylar up b4 actually stopping a 2nd time to stab nd kill n dump this poor beautiful girl? Wouldnt that kinda count as torture? Or is this rumor?
If you read any of the tweets, Skylar was pissed off because the two were not hanging out with her. She didn't want to be at home. I know nothing about Rachel being mad about Skylar flirting with her boyfriend because Skylar was very shy. But, I do know that the two suspects were in a bi-sexual relationship. Not sure if Skylar was a part of that, wanted no part of it or was getting in the way of it.
London

Monongahela, PA

#962 May 19, 2013
stunned wrote:
<quoted text>
just google Rachel Shoaf and you'll find it. She's singing a song from Les Mis
Not that well either. Funny how she deleted all of her other accounts but leaves the one that she hopes will make her a "star". What a narcissistic cu**!!

Also, just something else to think about; Eddy, while she seems like a demonic person, had the same friends for years..... "Best friends". RS changed friends often. Typical of a sociopath. The only thing she kept was the one boy that was obsessed with her and would do anything for her. And its likely that is only because she knew she needed him after what she had done.
stunned

New Kensington, PA

#963 May 19, 2013
Ugly Little Liars wrote:
Almost a week after she was arrested, there's still no indication on what lead 16-year-old Rachel Shoaf to stab her best friend to death.
However, on Monday one of Shoaf's friends had nothing but kind things to say about Shoaf.
Last Wednesday Shoaf was charged and pleaded guilty to second-degree murder for the death of Skylar Neese. According to court papers, Shoaf admitted to stabbing Neese to death.
Skylar's father, Dave, has previously told 5 News the two girls went to University High School together.
5 News has been able to locate Shoaf's profile on a website deigned for people who want to make a living in the theater industry.
On Monday 5 News talked to a frined of Rachel Shoaf, who said she has known Shoaf for the better part of five years. The friend requested that her name not be used, but she told 5 News that she met Shoaf at a camp. She said she would never expect anything like this from her.
She also gave a statement to 5 News: "she's (Rachel Shoaf) independent and doesn't pick fights. She's very trustworthy and reliable. Rachel has been nothing but a sweet and lovely person the entire time I've known her. She's friendly, outgoing, and caring."
Shoaf is still waiting to be sentenced.
Another teenage girl was also arrested, but no details have been released in her case because she's being charged as a juvenile. It's expected that her preliminary hearing is supposed to take place this week, but officials weren't able to confirm that on Monday.
^^^^From WDTV
OMG Yes Rachel is so trustworthy and reliable! Trustworthy and reliable enough to plan and carry out a murder by stabbing, LIE about it for months, and then turn and rat on the other girl to save her own ass. LOL what a gem!!! Too bad she's locked up, maybe we could be BFFs.
I'm not trying to place blame on any of the parents, but if SE and RS's parents were to blame, Skyler's parents played a part in it too. Skyler was with them every weekend, why didn't they keep better track of her? There were indications on the girls' twitter accounts that they smoked weed with the Skyler's dad and drank with her mom (mom Mary was quoted as saying that vodka was she and Skyler's favorite drink). The girls were permitted to stay in a trailer behind SE's dad's, by themselves. If you are going to blame SE and RS's parents, Skyler's must take some as well (and i'm sure they are beating themselves up for that very thing and don't want to inflict additional hurt on them either).
Huh

Fairmont, WV

#964 May 19, 2013
stunned wrote:
<quoted text>
I'm not trying to place blame on any of the parents, but if SE and RS's parents were to blame, Skyler's parents played a part in it too. Skyler was with them every weekend, why didn't they keep better track of her? There were indications on the girls' twitter accounts that they smoked weed with the Skyler's dad and drank with her mom (mom Mary was quoted as saying that vodka was she and Skyler's favorite drink). The girls were permitted to stay in a trailer behind SE's dad's, by themselves. If you are going to blame SE and RS's parents, Skyler's must take some as well (and i'm sure they are beating themselves up for that very thing and don't want to inflict additional hurt on them either).
Wow cause skylars parents raised a murderer? Placing blame on the victim is ridiculous! Skylar did nothing wrong except trust her best friends. You literally made me sick as i read this.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Morgantown Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
zags gonna beat dat whoot whoot viciously 4 hr charlie dont surf 6
trump - making america great again!!! 4 hr charlie dont surf 3
Visiting Morgantown during the school semester 5 hr Coach 2
The Herd wins first round game. Advances to... 7 hr Marooned 17
WVAQ/Kevin Connoley show cancelled? (Aug '16) 10 hr Pete thompson 75
Create your own Forum (Jun '15) 15 hr cabin creek Cu m 4,010
Marshall will WIN the NIT Tue Larry 8

Morgantown Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

Morgantown Mortgages