Ugly Little Liars

United States

#353 May 9, 2013
Thiswillbeonsnappedimsure

Thanks for the info! But there's a show called I Killed My BFF, that might be a bit more appropriate ;).
Concerned

United States

#354 May 9, 2013
thiswillbeonsnappedimsure wrote:
from what ive heard from a reliable source. they told skylar they were going to a party when they picked her up. previous to picking her up, they lined shelias trunk with trash bags. took a steak knife from shelias kitchen, slit her throat and proceeded to stab her for ten minutes at least. cause after ten minutes rachel said she got tired and pretended to pass out. they went back later on and moved her body to pa. the reason she snitched on herself and shelia was because the cops knew it was them and she knew there wasnt any getting out of it. so she told them everything, pretended to befriend shelia again, if you look on shelias twitter and see the picture of them together. thats when rachel was wired with a "new watch" and got her to talk about it. so even if she still proceeds to not talk, they know her involvment in it.
Thanks for the information. The story about her body being moved was accurate? Do you know if she was murdered at or near the golf course as previously stated and when did they go "back" to move her?

The garbage bags in the trunk intrigue me. Meaning, they knew what they were setting out to do (premeditated).
sosick

Gilbert, AZ

#355 May 9, 2013
Does anyone know WHY they did this? What is their excuse? Did they really hate her that much?
Judy Bloom

United States

#356 May 9, 2013
law and order wrote:
P.S.(Yes, I know it is technically 'poor' grammar and spelling but that sounds ostentatious to me. I am not talking about sounding like a prep school brat. I am talking about just basic punctuation and spelling. I am not even trying to knit pick. I know this is a chatboard so nobody is going to be careful about what they are writing. But some of these people have a major percentage of their words misspelt and obviously don't know what a sentence is. It goes beyond being careless or casual on the internet. It is to the point that you know they are very poorly educated. WTF is going on in that part of the country? And what is going on in the schools? Grade inflation? Low standards? Lots of pampering of the kids? What?)
There truly is something wrong with you. We are discussing a true tragedy in our community & THIS is what you say? You are evidently a judgemental unkind individual. We are having a casual conversation not writing an essay for class. Morgantown WV was voted the best small city in the US a few years back. Get a life, cut people some slack and make sure you stay away from our "uneducated " little town I dont think you would fit in.
Judy Bloom

United States

#357 May 9, 2013
a West Virginian wrote:
I really hope we get the full story. Maybe dateline should take a look at this case and make a show of it. I really would like to get all the facts. I feel like since RS confessed this case didn't even make national news.
Yet
law and order

Forest Hill, MD

#358 May 9, 2013
Somewhat Casual Observer wrote:
<quoted text>

Also, I'm a West Virginian...born and raised.
I can tell.
Somewhat Casual Observer wrote:
<quoted text>
know one but you
funny
1 post removed
dof

Arlington, WA

#360 May 10, 2013
America as a whole is one of the least educated countries in the west. Congratulations, you're the king of the ignoramuses of the planet. Can we move on now?
Pshaw

Calgary, Canada

#361 May 10, 2013
law and order wrote:
<quoted text>
Indeed, you are discussing it with great appetite.
<quoted text>
Of course, but the level of literacy displayed among some of you is a little hard to miss. As I said, it goes beyond being explained by being casual on a chatboard.
<quoted text>
When you get voted Queen of the Universe and can decide who can go where, I'm sure I'll hear about it. In the meantime, you can f*ck off.
Again, chat board is two words. Superiority-yer doin' it wrong.
Anonymous

Morgantown, WV

#362 May 10, 2013
I heard there was not one bit of forensic evidence in Shelia's car. Does anyone know if law enforcement ever found the trash bags?
Concerned

United States

#363 May 10, 2013
If Rachel was "wired" since January and was able to get Eddy to discuss it and admit her part in the murder, why did it take until May for them to be taken into custody?
Concerned

United States

#364 May 10, 2013
Also, did anyone else notice that she did not reference Rachel by name in any posts or pictures after that picture was taken in January? By her tweets though, IMO, it seems that some of her posts were directed at Rachel and they seemed like they were full of anger.
I wonder If Eddy was suspicious in why Rachel wanted to "discuss" the murder?
Concerned

United States

#365 May 10, 2013
Anonymous wrote:
I heard there was not one bit of forensic evidence in Shelia's car. Does anyone know if law enforcement ever found the trash bags?
If you look back through the posts ( it may be in the other forum) there seemed to be an indication that her body was "in" bags.
I don't know if this is accurate. Can anyone confirm or deny this?
law and order

Forest Hill, MD

#366 May 10, 2013
Pshaw, it is you who are wrong. Chatboard is a fairly new term in the English language so if you want to write it as two words, it doesn't matter to me. But for you to tell somebody that they are incorrect for choosing to spell it as one word makes you a real moron. Blackboard, billboard, whiteboard, chessboard, checkerboard, chalkboard, keyboard, scoreboard, overboard, washboard, snowboard, skateboard, surfboard, and dozens of other common words ending in 'board' all are spelled as one word, and yet you think the new term chatboard is going to be two? You are gonna be fighting a losing battle on that one. That is where you want to take your stand in your stupid spelling war? You, are truly an idiot.
law and order

Forest Hill, MD

#367 May 10, 2013
dof wrote:
America as a whole is one of the least educated countries in the west. Congratulations, you're the king of the ignoramuses of the planet. Can we move on now?
International TIMSS tests and other multi-country tests of academic competence say otherwise but nice try. Oh, you want to move on after YOU'VE had the last word? Once again, nice try but no cigar.
law and order

Forest Hill, MD

#368 May 10, 2013
Pshaw wrote:
<quoted text>
Again, chat board is two words. Superiority-yer doin' it wrong.
By the way, you might want to go inform everybody on this board dedicated to teachers who teach spelling and teachers interested in spelling education that they are ALL spelling 'chatboard' incorrectly. LOL. Idiot.

http://teachers.net/mentors/spelling/posts.ht...
Concerned

United States

#369 May 10, 2013
Anonymous,
I found this in the Skylar Neese forum. Post #203

You don't know if she was in the mine shaft or just near it. You don't even know if her body was found whole or in pieces stuffed in a garbage bag. Most people don't just go searching in trash bags found in the woods. Even if her body was whole, if she wasn't covered with something, she was likely just a pile of bones by that time.
Judy Bloom

United States

#370 May 10, 2013
Concerned wrote:
<quoted text>
If you look back through the posts ( it may be in the other forum) there seemed to be an indication that her body was "in" bags.
I don't know if this is accurate. Can anyone confirm or deny this?
No she was not.
Paul

Charleston, WV

#371 May 10, 2013
Concerned wrote:
If Rachel was "wired" since January and was able to get Eddy to discuss it and admit her part in the murder, why did it take until May for them to be taken into custody?
Maybe they didn't get enough from her until then.

Eddy is not stupid. Most sociopaths are intelligent people.Now think about this... these two 16 year olds would have pulled off a very likely unsolvable crime had Shoaf just kept quiet.

I doubt if Eddy was stupid enough to start yacking right away as soon as Shoaf came back around asking questions. Some of her tweets hint that she was on to her. I believe she said "things like this is why I will never talk to you again." Things like that.

So, I believe it just took a while to put it all together. We will see what they have when the Eddy is transferred.
Paul

Charleston, WV

#372 May 10, 2013
Concerned wrote:
Anonymous,
I found this in the Skylar Neese forum. Post #203
You don't know if she was in the mine shaft or just near it. You don't even know if her body was found whole or in pieces stuffed in a garbage bag. Most people don't just go searching in trash bags found in the woods. Even if her body was whole, if she wasn't covered with something, she was likely just a pile of bones by that time.
You have to take that in the context in which it was written. There was a petty argument over whether a buried body is easier to find than an unburried one. This respons was not implying Skylar was in a bag. Just that no one but those involved know where or how she was found.
Judy Bloom

United States

#373 May 10, 2013
thiswillbeonsnappedimsure wrote:
from what ive heard from a reliable source. they told skylar they were going to a party when they picked her up. previous to picking her up, they lined shelias trunk with trash bags. took a steak knife from shelias kitchen, slit her throat and proceeded to stab her for ten minutes at least. cause after ten minutes rachel said she got tired and pretended to pass out. they went back later on and moved her body to pa. the reason she snitched on herself and shelia was because the cops knew it was them and she knew there wasnt any getting out of it. so she told them everything, pretended to befriend shelia again, if you look on shelias twitter and see the picture of them together. thats when rachel was wired with a "new watch" and got her to talk about it. so even if she still proceeds to not talk, they know her involvment in it.
The murder did not take place in the trunk of the car. I know that everyone is hearing a lot of stories. LE processed Eddy's car thoroughly around 40 days after Skylar's disappearance -some evidence was collected - if their had been a blood bath in the trunk of the car (garbage bags or not ) it would have been discovered. Shelia would have been arrested immediately if this kind of evidence would have been discovered.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Morgantown Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Colton Balasko 10 hr Loaded 9
Herbal Incense/Potpourri 16 hr Loaded 6
Maleah baber 19 hr Mrs Friendly 2
Rachel Shoaf and Shelia Eddy (Jun '13) 21 hr Just a thought 158
Proposed new WV carry laws Thu Free 6
TWO YEAR PROBATION: For Mountedqueers Wed Granny 8
Lindsay Cochran Feb 23 Tanya Tucker 1
Morgantown Dating
Find my Match
More from around the web

Morgantown People Search

Addresses and phone numbers for FREE

Personal Finance

Mortgages [ See current mortgage rates ]

NFL Latest News

Updated 6:15 pm PST

Bleacher Report 6:15PM
Pittsburgh Steelers' Ultimate Free-Agency To-Do List
NBC Sports 9:09 PM
Reports: Browns still in the mix for Josh McCown
Bleacher Report 4:00 AM
6 Best Options to Replace T-Rich This Offseason
Bleacher Report 4:00 AM
What Are the Steelers' Options at Slot Receiver?
Bleacher Report 4:00 AM
Why the Browns Need to Stay Far Away from Bradford