McCain meets with evangelist Billy Graham and son
Join the discussion below, or Read more at The Morning Call.
#1 Jul 23, 2008
The success of the surge has not changed Senator Obama's determination to pull out all of our combat troops. All that has changed is his rationale. In a New York Times op-ed and a speech this week, he offered his "plan for Iraq" in advance of his first "fact finding" trip to that country in more than three years. It consisted of the same old proposal to pull all of our troops out within 16 months. In 2007 he wanted to withdraw because he thought the war was lost. If we had taken his advice, it would have been. Now he wants to withdraw because he thinks Iraqis no longer need our assistance.
To make this point, he mangles the evidence. He makes it sound as if Prime Minister Maliki has endorsed the Obama timetable, when all he has said is that he would like a plan for the eventual withdrawal of U.S. troops at some unspecified point in the future.
Senator Obama is also misleading on the Iraqi military's readiness. The Iraqi Army will be equipped and trained by the middle of next year, but this does not, as Senator Obama suggests, mean that they will then be ready to secure their country without a good deal of help. The Iraqi Air Force, for one, still lags behind, and no modern army can operate without air cover. The Iraqis are also still learning how to conduct planning, logistics, command and control, communications, and other complicated functions needed to support frontline troops.
No one favors a permanent U.S. presence, as Senator Obama charges. A partial withdrawal has already occurred with the departure of five "surge" brigades, and more withdrawals can take place as the security situation improves. As we draw down in Iraq, we can beef up our presence on other battlefields, such as Afghanistan, without fear of leaving a failed state behind. I have said that I expect to welcome home most of our troops from Iraq by the end of my first term in office, in 2013.
But I have also said that any draw-downs must be based on a realistic assessment of conditions on the ground, not on an artificial timetable crafted for domestic political reasons. This is the crux of my disagreement with Senator Obama.
Senator Obama has said that he would consult our commanders on the ground and Iraqi leaders, but he did no such thing before releasing his "plan for Iraq." Perhaps that's because he doesn't want to hear what they have to say. During the course of eight visits to Iraq, I have heard many times from our troops what Major General Jeffrey Hammond, commander of coalition forces in Baghdad, recently said: that leaving based on a timetable would be "very dangerous."
The danger is that extremists supported by Al Qaeda and Iran could stage a comeback, as they have in the past when we've had too few troops in Iraq. Senator Obama seems to have learned nothing from recent history. I find it ironic that he is emulating the worst mistake of the Bush administration by waving the "Mission Accomplished" banner prematurely.
I am also dismayed that he never talks about winning the war?only of ending it. But if we don't win the war, our enemies will. A triumph for the terrorists would be a disaster for us. That is something I will not allow to happen as president. Instead I will continue implementing a proven counterinsurgency strategy not only in Iraq but also in Afghanistan with the goal of creating stable, secure, self-sustaining democratic allies.
#3 Jul 23, 2008
read _this_dummocrats 2
When do you think the US should pull out of a country that no longer wants us there? The Prime Minister has said a month ago he wants the US out of Iraq. How do we as a nation prolong a "stay" that no longer will be supported by it's leaders? McCain has said that he will support the field commanders as to how long we need to be there, but can we occupy a space that no longer seems friendly? Obama said 16 months? But now out of Iraq and into Afganistan? I don't see where either of the candidates are being honest or truthful when it comes to ending this thing.
Add your comments below
|Tommy robinson||5 hr||Teresa||3|
|Mental illness, bathrooms and "Transgenders"||6 hr||Matt||8|
|Biogel Injections (Feb '10)||9 hr||Vvvv||171|
|Columbia Carolina 3rd Shift||13 hr||Baron||12|
|Nathaniel Roland (Mar '15)||23 hr||Rachael||39|
|Joey disbrow||Thu||Never know||5|
|Are All Yankee's Jerks or do the just ACT that ... (Jul '09)||Thu||luvnut||295|
Find what you want!
Search Montreat Forum Now
Copyright © 2016 Topix LLC