Judge overturns California's ban on same-sex marriage

[NorCal Native]

Brian_G wrote:

<quoted text> Proposition 8 is almost identical to Minnesota's law defining marriage as one man and one woman.
Judge Walker ignored the precedent of Baker v Nelson and excluded evidence showing the universal nature of male/female marriage.

No, it's not because there are 18,000 legally married Same-Sex Couples and those marriages remained valid, legal and recognized even after the passage of Prop 8.

Again, Baker vs Nelson was about getting a marriage license.......Perry vs Hollinsworth(Prop 8) is about a right that Same-Sex Couples had and was ELIMINATED by a vote........and the evidence you claimed was excluded, was more like NOT presented and totally irrelevant because it was about having something and then having it removed or taken away!!!

[akpilot]

Rose_NoHo wrote:

<quoted text>
But that is nowhere to be found in Skinner v OK
http://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/html/histori...
<quoted text>
Again, Skinner v OK was not a case about marriage. The use of the word was incidental. It was a case from the 40's...
The case was about using forced sterilization as a means of punishment. Marriage laws were not changed at all.
Anyway, WTF is your point? You don't have to be able to procreate in order to marry.

You are a f-ing idiot. There is a reason the SCOTUS referenced Skinner V Oklahoma.

I am sorry that you failed to learn critical thinking.

Yet another example as to why you are collecting that welfare check.

SQUAWK-- RACIST-- Beat ya to it, now how about you formulate an intelligent response.

Tell us how the SCOTUS was incorrect in Loving V Virginia when it referenced Oklahoma V Skinner as the source of marriage as a "right". Show us how much smarter than you are than a sitting Justice.

BTW, have you looked up stare decisis yet?

[akpilot]

Rose_NoHo wrote:

<quoted text>
LOL. You didn't even read my response, you just replied!
For one, Rock claimed I site false reports and bogus surveys. Tell us how my response proved I site false reports and bogus surveys.
Speaking of keeping your mouth shut, looks like you are going to have to!

Like I said Rose, you prove his point.. You are simply too stupid to know when to shut up.

[akpilot]

Rose_NoHo wrote:

<quoted text>
LOL. You didn't even read my response, you just replied!
For one, Rock claimed I site false reports and bogus surveys. Tell us how my response proved I site false reports and bogus surveys.
Speaking of keeping your mouth shut, looks like you are going to have to!

R Hudson wrote:
<quoted text>
You aren't even worth responding to.
1 You refuse to answer direct questions with anything other than deceit and spin.

You Wrote:
Total BS.

You failed to answer, as usual.



R Hudson wrote:
3 You apply a double standard to the posters this room.

You Wrote:

Example?

Here is one- Calling everyone a racists without providing the same requirement of stating which race they hate that you require from someone calling you a racist.
This is also another example of what Hudson claimed in Item 1.

R Hudson wrote:
4 You are on welfare, thus presenting yourself as the lowest form of dirt in here.

You Wrote:LOL! A total lie. I get you are a racist, and assume I'm on welfare because I'm black. But I have an advanced degree and I'm fully employed.

Proving my point. No one thinks you are on welfare because you are "black" Rose, in fact we don't even know for sure that you are- we claim you are on welfare because you are too ignorant to support yourself.

No need to go further, all of your other responses simply provided further examples of what was claimed in item 1.

[akpilot]

Rose_NoHo wrote:

<quoted text>
You are the idiot.
IF god existed, there would be evidence of his existence.
He's supposed to be all knowing, all powerful and involved in our lives.
It's quite possible there is life on another planet without our having any evidence of it.

So you claim, as fact, that there is no life on any other planet in the Universe?

[akpilot]

Rose_NoHo wrote:

<quoted text>
You are the idiot.
IF god existed, there would be evidence of his existence.
He's supposed to be all knowing, all powerful and involved in our lives.
It's quite possible there is life on another planet without our having any evidence of it.

Everyone pay attention here to Rose!!

Only in the fantasy world of Rose could anyone accept this response as logical.

Let's follow the nonsense of Rose.

Rose claims, it is quite possible there is life on another planet even though there is NO EVIDENCE OF IT!!

But, she also claims, that because there is NO EVIDENCE of god, then definitely god does not exist.

The court jester never lets us down!!

[Vinkville]

No peats, next time ask permission.

[Big D]

wait.. not all the Gods are all knowing and all powerful, depends on which of the billions of Gods man has made up you are talking about.

[Rebecca]

R Hudson wrote:

Do you work in the gay film industry as an actor, Mister Hudson? Your face looks like one I've seen in my nephew's collection of gay porn.

[Mike DiRucci]

Big D wrote:

wait.. not all the Gods are all knowing and all powerful, depends on which of the billions of Gods man has made up you are talking about.

Take your god schtick to the religion threads. There are plenty of them for you religious whack jobs. This one is about same sex marriage.

Will you be spewing more anti marriage equality rhetoric again today?

Fun!

[cable guy]

Mike DiRucci wrote:

<quoted text>
Take your god schtick to the religion threads. There are plenty of them for you religious whack jobs. This one is about same sex marriage.
Will you be spewing more anti marriage equality rhetoric again today?
Fun!

another day, same old phagg.^^^

[Big D]

Mike DiRucci wrote:

<quoted text>
Take your god schtick to the religion threads. There are plenty of them for you religious whack jobs. This one is about same sex marriage.
Will you be spewing more anti marriage equality rhetoric again today?
Fun!

I dont take order from you kid

[Mike DiRucci]

Big D wrote:

<quoted text>
I dont take order from you kid

No one has called me "kid" in over 60 years sonny! Thanks feels kind of good.

[You Could]

Douglas Tessitor, Gene Murabito, Judy Nelson, Joseph Santoro and Karen Davis all need to take heed of these proceedings:

Harrisburg, PA..

Penn State's former president is accused of perjury, endangering children and other charges in the Jerry Sandusky sexual molestation scandal of the century.

[Winston Smith]

R Hudson wrote:

<quoted text>
Straight up, Big D, no sarcasm.
My marriage was a declaration that I intended to take my wife and raise a family, according to old tradition and custom, going back thousands of years. This new redefinition allows a mockery of that declaration. It allows anyone with a desire to call another a "wife" or a "husband" to claim that title, in spite of the timeless nature of that cherished institution. Anyone can live together, that is a common type of relationship. A marriage is not. I feel that the ceremony is cheapened by lowering the bar.

Then every failed marriage, every divorce, every marriage of convenience, every instance of spousal abuse/homicide, etc. cheapen your marriage.

[R Hudson]

You Could wrote:

Douglas Tessitor, Gene Murabito, Judy Nelson, Joseph Santoro and Karen Davis all need to take heed of these proceedings:
Harrisburg, PA..
Penn State's former president is accused of perjury, endangering children and other charges in the Jerry Sandusky sexual molestation scandal of the century.

I guess its now just a matter of time before they get to me.

[Big D]

They are desperately trying preserve the sanctity of Britney’s "just for fun" 4 day marriage.

[Big D]

Mike DiRucci wrote:

<quoted text>
No one has called me "kid" in over 60 years sonny! Thanks feels kind of good.

You are how you act kid

[Brian_G]

Down with same sex marriage.

Vote Republican

[Mike DiRucci]

Winston Smith wrote:

<quoted text>
Then every failed marriage, every divorce, every marriage of convenience, every instance of spousal abuse/homicide, etc. cheapen your marriage.

No just yours!

Funny stuff!