Marines expelled, disciplined for vid...

Marines expelled, disciplined for video of puppy being thrown

There are 47 comments on the KOMO News story from Jun 12, 2008, titled Marines expelled, disciplined for video of puppy being thrown. In it, KOMO News reports that:

The Marine Corps on Wednesday said it was expelling one Marine and disciplining another for their roles in a video showing a Marine throwing a puppy off a cliff while on patrol in Iraq.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at KOMO News.

First Prev
of 3
Next Last

“Tu ne cede malis”

Since: Dec 06

Lots of different places

#41 Oct 17, 2008
josh allan wrote:
<quoted text>harkin?.... im afraid your too old ... or too nerdy ..wtf is harkin? great cumbk
Well, let's see here: D I C T I O N A R Y.

Got that?

Let me guess: You attended one of them thar so-called 'publik skools,' right?

Figures.

TOO BAD: >YOU< LOSE!
whatever

Saint Louis, MO

#42 Oct 18, 2008
Infamous wrote:
Okay, I agree. As long as my opinion is heard. But at the same time does anyone think an NJP would suffice? I mean, I have seen Marines/Sailors/Soldiers get a DUI and recieve nothing more than a reduction in rank, and some extra duties. I think that is much more of a flaw of character. But hey, that's my own opinion right?
of course you are entitled to your opinion,and it is great that you are allowed to be heard,just as i am.that's something that most people forget,we truly do live in the best country in the world,and again i thank the men and women who serve to make that possible.many people have flaw's,but,i think i have less of a problem with a dui,and i mean 1 dui,no fatalities,and you straighten your life up,than i do for someone who could throw an innocent animal over a cliff,just for amusement.the man had no remorse,he laughed about it.to me that speak's of a serious mental defect.no conscience.i mean if he was capable of that,what else will he do? perhap's to a human?i believe most of our serial killer's started out killing animal's......point's to ponder,i suppose.i do respect your opinion,and am at least willing to hear it.to many people are only interested in their own.
What ills or kills me

Seattle, WA

#43 Oct 18, 2008
I'm going to go out on a limb and guess that most of the posts here that point fingers at people of different races/cultures may themselves be 2nd, 3rd, or 4th generation Americans and not at all native to this country. Hmm, who is?(You might find them on reservations and that's unfortunate)
As for the discharge, they deserved at least that, but I am thankful for the men and women who honor their uniform and the country they serve and protect.(excluding "Lance Cpl" David Motari and his fellow murderer Sg Encarnacion)
josh allan

Bridgewater, VA

#44 Oct 19, 2008
Highlander wrote:
<quoted text>
Well, let's see here: D I C T I O N A R Y.
Got that?
Let me guess: You attended one of them thar so-called 'publik skools,' right?
Figures.
TOO BAD: >YOU< LOSE!
OK I GOTTA HAND IT TO YA ... HERES YOUR BLUE RIBBON N GUESS WHAT IT SAYS RIGHT ON THE FRONT,thanks for the stimulating conversation... n did you know that scott anderson cooks meth in gold bar on 8th street? not many people do ... so i cant blame you for being ignorant... have a great day :)

“Tu ne cede malis”

Since: Dec 06

Lots of different places

#45 Oct 19, 2008
josh allan wrote:
<quoted text>OK I GOTTA HAND IT TO YA ... HERES YOUR BLUE RIBBON N GUESS WHAT IT SAYS RIGHT ON THE FRONT,thanks for the stimulating conversation... n did you know that scott anderson cooks meth in gold bar on 8th street? not many people do ... so i cant blame you for being ignorant... have a great day :)
THAT, dear readers, was yet ~another~ example of why >you< shouldn't 'do drugs.'

:-))
Jay

United States

#47 Aug 5, 2009
Jeremy wrote:
Since you are obviously the most ignorant person alive you deserve the following statement...
Obviously you are a towel wearing, building bombing terrorist. If you think someone who has spent four years of their life defending your complete idiocy and right to live in this country should be dishonorably discharged from the united states military for killing an animal, then maybe you should have taken the dogs place. Being given a court martial will ruin a persons life. Because of a stupid animal? Are you serious? And being from NEW YORK maybe you'd have somewhat of a clue. But obviously a piece of the building must have fallen on your head.
<quoted text>
whomever wrote this is evil...if a marine cannot treat an animal properly, he cannot be trusted to protect our country. This is shameful, evil and he should be punished more severely than he is
Jay

United States

#48 Aug 5, 2009
IF THERE IS A MARINE THAT DEFENDS THE ACTIONS OF THAT PUPPY KILLER, HE IS NOT A TRUE MARINE. LISTEN TO YOUR OWN OFFICER AND LEADERS...THIS IS NOT AN ACT TO DEFEND OR BE PROUD OF. THIS MAN WAS EVIL, AND STUPID AND SHOULD BE PUNISHED.
A TRUE MARINE KNOWS THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN DEFENDING A CAUSE AND PERPETRATING EVIL.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 3
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Monroe Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
local service companies Mar '16 Paul Franks 2
Election Who do you support for U.S. House in Washington... (Oct '10) Jan '16 judi byrne 6
City Of Monroe WA 98272 Info Dec '15 city of monroe wa 1
News Youth gangs emerge in the Sky Valley (Dec '08) Oct '15 GOFASTCUMSLOWBABY... 17
Review: Grace Fellowship Preschool (May '15) May '15 jeanniebelanger 1
Snohomish Garage Door Repair (Oct '14) Jan '15 Calvin James 3
News Boyfriend Who Smothered Child Gets Prison (Nov '07) Jan '15 Relative of the M... 29
More from around the web

Personal Finance

Monroe Mortgages