Best Local Pizza Place

Best Local Pizza Place

Created by PizzaGuy on May 15, 2013

132 votes

Click on an option to vote

Charlies Pizza (any)

Tonys Pizza (any)

Francos

Palermos

Master Pizza

Pizza Classic

Parkway Pizza

O'scunnizo

Nonnis

Rosarios

First Prev
of 3
Next Last
wow

Whitesboro, NY

#47 May 23, 2013
upstater wrote:
Primos next to the Spaghetti Kettle in Kirkland has the best pizza in this area because it is hand-tossed and cooked in a brick oven. At most pizza places, the bottom crust is too soft and soggy. Parkway Pizza is good and comes close to having a real good crust. Rosario's in East Utica may be among the soggiest crusts I've ever had and I find their pizza to be tasteless.
That pizza is horrible

Since: Jan 13

Location hidden

#48 Jun 2, 2013
The Italian Chef on eagle and Mohawk you can not beat the meat lovers.
laughs on you

West Hartford, CT

#49 Jun 3, 2013
Vinny wrote:
<quoted text>
Lol that's funny there not even open anymore. I drove by Saturday and the lights were off no one there at 6 pm.
they are still open but decided to take sat off for the summer.
Just Say No

Utica, NY

#50 Jun 4, 2013
Ricky Ricardo 66 wrote:
The Italian Chef on eagle and Mohawk you can not beat the meat lovers.
I can't support drug fronts in good conscience.
Lots

Utica, NY

#51 Jun 8, 2013
O'scugnizzos- Bleecker St.

Francos-Whitesboro

Little Caesars Pepperoni Deep Dish- its good believe it or not!

Joe's Pizza-Whitesboro
Lots

Utica, NY

#52 Jun 8, 2013
Ricky Ricardo 66 wrote:
The Italian Chef on eagle and Mohawk you can not beat the meat lovers.
I would never buy food from the owners or any other of their establishments.
jethro gibbs

New York, NY

#53 Jun 8, 2013
Venice
Utica Is High Tech LOL

Schenectady, NY

#54 Jun 16, 2013
Definitely Tony's.
Ken Banks

Rome, NY

#55 Jun 21, 2013
O'Baby's HANDS DOWN! Everything is homemade from scratch. Always fresh, always hot

Since: Mar 11

Location hidden

#56 Jun 21, 2013
Ken Banks wrote:
O'Baby's HANDS DOWN! Everything is homemade from scratch. Always fresh, always hot
Haven't tried it, heard it was a little pricey
ex fried baby

Utica, NY

#57 Jun 21, 2013
get ex dead baby w/shroom LOL LOL LOL
Whoa

Utica, NY

#58 Jun 22, 2013
jethro gibbs wrote:
Venice
I love pizza but I love life more. No thanks that place is cursed.
try something new

East Granby, CT

#59 Jun 23, 2013
The problem with utican's they don't' try anything new. North Utica has one of the best pizza' I have ever had. It's crisp the dough is light the sauce is homemade and the toppings are primo. And that is Nonni's. I Come from whitesboro every week to get it. There eggplant is the best. Everyday they have a different special. Try it you'll never go back to the otherS.
yes

Whitesboro, NY

#60 May 21, 2014
Bodhisatva wrote:
Capri Pizza in Oriskany(his father was the original capri on genesee st.his brother is palermo) best thin crust Pizza
yues, capri, very good

Utica Lies and Riggies

Since: May 14

Clifton Park, NY

#61 May 21, 2014
Tonys in Washington mills.
Pizza

Utica, NY

#62 May 21, 2014
Palermos on oneida square
Blondie

New York, NY

#63 May 21, 2014
Ken Banks wrote:
O'Baby's HANDS DOWN! Everything is homemade from scratch. Always fresh, always hot
Nasty food
pizza_eater

Utica, NY

#64 May 21, 2014
SLICE!!!!!!!
Bob

Utica, NY

#66 May 22, 2014
Slice!!
Read

Woonsocket, RI

#67 May 22, 2014
J Houstons

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 3
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Middleville Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Http:// thevalleyside.com / busted 17 min New York Patriot 2
David Gordon - The People's Advocate 32 min Nicole 7
Tonys in New Hartford 47 min use the technology 15
NANO coming undone 1 hr u musta missed it 4
dave Hayes (Feb '09) 1 hr lotsa envy there 36
House of the Good Shepherd ED doesn't have a de... 1 hr gates 3
why IS CRETIN SMITH JEALOUS OF MEN WITH MONEY L... 1 hr NASA Calling Lol 6
More from around the web

Personal Finance

Middleville Mortgages