Comments
661 - 680 of 1,606 Comments Last updated 11 hrs ago
Lee Jay

Huntington, NY

#667 Apr 1, 2014
Joan wrote:
<quoted text>
Im so sorry you have to go through this!
And I'm even more sorry you and your family are being attacked by these people! Keep your head up , truth will prevail !
You are so hypocritical.
Joan

Elmont, NY

#668 Apr 1, 2014
Lee Jay wrote:
<quoted text>
Holy shit you are obsessed about her past issues. Truth is one thing. Publically outing a drug problem is NOT necessary.
Sure am, shows the kind of person she is capable of being. Your defense is protection of her kids and what not , I call bullshit... Wasn't so worried then was she?
Drug problem and leaving with a gun changes everything ! If you are too stupid to realize that and are one of her minions , explains why the whole search is ass backwards!
Continue your cute quotes on the search page , hopefully he reads one that he really likes and comes home!
Joan

Elmont, NY

#669 Apr 1, 2014
Lee Jay wrote:
<quoted text>
You are so hypocritical.
When you need to MAKE UP that a missing man was estranged from his family, you have SERIOUs serious issues!!!!!!
Supporting honest people is not being a hypocrite!
Go search arrow you jerk!
Lee Jay

Huntington, NY

#670 Apr 1, 2014
Joan wrote:
<quoted text>
When you need to MAKE UP that a missing man was estranged from his family, you have SERIOUs serious issues!!!!!!
Supporting honest people is not being a hypocrite!
Go search arrow you jerk!
Calm down. You're going to give yourself an aneurism. Jesus Christ. The Ida-obsessed on here's mentality cannot handle anyone disagreeing with their point of view. So typical.
Minion 1

Murrieta, CA

#671 Apr 1, 2014
Christine wrote:
@Lee Jay Really? I wouldn't believe so quickly or easily what Ida tells you…did she tell you that we were with Rob and Ida and the kids the Saturday before he went missing…did she tell you that Rob, Ida the kids, and her parents came to my house for Mother's Day the month before he went missing…that Rob was the 1st person to call and wish me Happy Birthday @ 6:30 in the morning the day of my birthday a few weeks before he went missing…or that I was the 1st person Ida called when he didn't come home from work on June 14th and my husband and I rushed over no questions asked to help her…or did she tell you that I was at her house everyday for the first 3 weeks that my brother was missing…does that sound like a sister that was not close or did not care??? I took a giant step back, when stories did not make sense, and especially when we found out that she was a convicted FELON…that info was hidden from us…after 18 years of knowing someone and finding out they were not the person that we thought we knew! Obviously something else was going on!! Nobody knows what really happened but Rob…and I really hope that he is somewhere safe….
18 years of 'knowing' someone. Yes, I'm sure you were quite close. Maybe her legal troubles weren't yours or anyone's business. But then you attempted to use it to trash Ida on public TV, when it had nothing to do with Rob or his disappearance. What a classy woman. Even his 'Mother's' account of what happened in Rob's accident isn't correct. Show's just how close they really weren't. But tell us, what have you done to find Rob? Have you launched your own search? Aside from your little gossipy piece on Murphy, have you gone to other media? The police? Have you called and asked for updates?
Minion 1

Murrieta, CA

#672 Apr 1, 2014
Joan wrote:
<quoted text>
You mean you are upset that she spoke the truth ? You have nerve attacking his family , when Ida herself said in the beginning how close they were!!!
His family wants him found!!!! So they put aside people opinion and spoke TRUTH! Which is what anybody would do if it meant finding their loved one!!!!! When it's more important to someone how they come across , DO NOT say they would do anything to find their missing loved one.
Clearly she wants to find her husband only if she can uphold her image. You believe who you want, but to bash people for speaking truth when possibly a man life is at stake, is DISGUSTING.....
LOL Um, Rob's family is attacking Rob's family. I wouldn't say they put aside opinion either, quite the opposite. That interview is loaded with opinion, more so than facts.
Joan

Elmont, NY

#673 Apr 1, 2014
Minion 1 wrote:
<quoted text>
18 years of 'knowing' someone. Yes, I'm sure you were quite close. Maybe her legal troubles weren't yours or anyone's business. But then you attempted to use it to trash Ida on public TV, when it had nothing to do with Rob or his disappearance. What a classy woman. Even his 'Mother's' account of what happened in Rob's accident isn't correct. Show's just how close they really weren't. But tell us, what have you done to find Rob? Have you launched your own search? Aside from your little gossipy piece on Murphy, have you gone to other media? The police? Have you called and asked for updates?
Her husband is LE, as a dtr, sister and wife of one, I can tell you they protect their own!!! Is be willing to bet my house they have more info than Ida!
Minion 1

Murrieta, CA

#674 Apr 1, 2014
Joan wrote:
<quoted text>
Sure am, shows the kind of person she is capable of being. Your defense is protection of her kids and what not , I call bullshit... Wasn't so worried then was she?
Drug problem and leaving with a gun changes everything ! If you are too stupid to realize that and are one of her minions , explains why the whole search is ass backwards!
Continue your cute quotes on the search page , hopefully he reads one that he really likes and comes home!
Nobody knows if he left with a gun, only that one is missing. Again all this what LE already knew. What was important for the public to know was already given by Ida in NUMEROUS interviews. Where has the mother and sister been all this time?
Minion 1

Murrieta, CA

#675 Apr 1, 2014
Joan wrote:
<quoted text>
Her husband is LE, as a dtr, sister and wife of one, I can tell you they protect their own!!! Is be willing to bet my house they have more info than Ida!
LMAO!!!
Joan

Elmont, NY

#676 Apr 1, 2014
Minion 1 wrote:
<quoted text>
Nobody knows if he left with a gun, only that one is missing. Again all this what LE already knew. What was important for the public to know was already given by Ida in NUMEROUS interviews. Where has the mother and sister been all this time?
Numerous interviews with lies! Clearly it's been quite useful crocodile tears and all, that's why he's been found!
Ohhhh only one gun was gone, my mistake didn't realize he needed an arsenal!
Lee Jay

Huntington, NY

#677 Apr 1, 2014
Joan wrote:
<quoted text>
Numerous interviews with lies! Clearly it's been quite useful crocodile tears and all, that's why he's been found!
Ohhhh only one gun was gone, my mistake didn't realize he needed an arsenal!
Comprehension. A gun is missing. It is not known if he took it with him or he could have gotten rid of it at an earlier time.
Charlotte

Thornwood, NY

#678 Apr 1, 2014
Christine wrote:
@Lee Jay Really? I wouldn't believe so quickly or easily what Ida tells you…did she tell you that we were with Rob and Ida and the kids the Saturday before he went missing…did she tell you that Rob, Ida the kids, and her parents came to my house for Mother's Day the month before he went missing…that Rob was the 1st person to call and wish me Happy Birthday @ 6:30 in the morning the day of my birthday a few weeks before he went missing…or that I was the 1st person Ida called when he didn't come home from work on June 14th and my husband and I rushed over no questions asked to help her…or did she tell you that I was at her house everyday for the first 3 weeks that my brother was missing…does that sound like a sister that was not close or did not care??? I took a giant step back, when stories did not make sense, and especially when we found out that she was a convicted FELON…that info was hidden from us…after 18 years of knowing someone and finding out they were not the person that we thought we knew! Obviously something else was going on!! Nobody knows what really happened but Rob…and I really hope that he is somewhere safe….
My heart goes out to you and Mom and 2 kids.
Many of us pray Rob is safe somewhere away from her.

Thanks so much for validating her obvious lies.

Question: do you think Mary Murphy will do a part 3?

Some of us are watching closely. Hang in there.
Maybe start your own Find Rob FB page?
Dan

Huntington Station, NY

#679 Apr 1, 2014
Minion 1 wrote:
<quoted text>
18 years of 'knowing' someone. Yes, I'm sure you were quite close. Maybe her legal troubles weren't yours or anyone's business. But then you attempted to use it to trash Ida on public TV, when it had nothing to do with Rob or his disappearance. What a classy woman. Even his 'Mother's' account of what happened in Rob's accident isn't correct. Show's just how close they really weren't. But tell us, what have you done to find Rob? Have you launched your own search? Aside from your little gossipy piece on Murphy, have you gone to other media? The police? Have you called and asked for updates?
Hey professor, you seem to know so much. How do you know Ida's CRIMES were unrelated to Rob's disappearance? I thought she had NO IDEA where he is or why he is gone.
Have a bit of respect for Christine. She has every right to be worried, it is HER BROTHER! Go back to your prayer and support group. You will serve better there. Jerkoff.
Dan

Huntington Station, NY

#680 Apr 1, 2014
Lee Jay wrote:
<quoted text>
Comprehension. A gun is missing. It is not known if he took it with him or he could have gotten rid of it at an earlier time.
Is there a bullshit button?
They should add one.
Lisa Watson

Sag Harbor, NY

#681 Apr 1, 2014
So far I see MINION is a MORON, all this person does is call names, no English? You must be Ida or her best friend, this person knows nothing but bullshit and bullshit answers on this, IDIOT...is the only language you know, OH, I just looked today and there are no flyers posted anywhere's, WONDER WHY!!!!

WONDER WHERE IDA IS WORKING? FULL TIME? No time to post flyers???? clueless
Sue

Commack, NY

#682 Apr 1, 2014
Minion 1 wrote:
<quoted text>
Nobody knows if he left with a gun, only that one is missing. Again all this what LE already knew. What was important for the public to know was already given by Ida in NUMEROUS interviews. Where has the mother and sister been all this time?
Exactly, nobody knows IF he left with that gun, that gun could have also been scrapped who knows when, BUT, Ida used it to get the cops to take a Missing Person Report!! If not they would have just told her Sorry, "looks like he left Ya Babe"
As for what the public should have known? NOTHING!! Because SHE should have never put it out to the public....This was between her & her husband BUT IDA being the spoiled Bitch & Liar that she is, couldn't DEAL with the fact that Rob left her and she went with the I MUST WIN Mentality. Trouble is she thought she was smarter then everyone else and she would get over on everyone.
I guess she didn't learn from her pass, she got caught lying again, so not too smart!!
ONE MORE thing HTF DO YOU KNOW What his MOTHER & SISTER ARE DOING? Your head is BURIED so far up Ida's Ass & your eating her BS!

Now you can add your dumb little comment to what I said Minion, Observer, or what ever else you want to call yourself J, Try calling yourself an "ASSHOLE" for believing her......
Sue

Commack, NY

#683 Apr 1, 2014
Charlotte wrote:
<quoted text>
My heart goes out to you and Mom and 2 kids.
Many of us pray Rob is safe somewhere away from her.
Thanks so much for validating her obvious lies.
Question: do you think Mary Murphy will do a part 3?
Some of us are watching closely. Hang in there.
Maybe start your own Find Rob FB page?
Agree, so we can get rid of the trolls and their Ida worshiping.
Charlotte

Thornwood, NY

#684 Apr 1, 2014
Lisa Watson wrote:
So far I see MINION is a MORON, all this person does is call names, no English? You must be Ida or her best friend, this person knows nothing but bullshit and bullshit answers on this, IDIOT...is the only language you know, OH, I just looked today and there are no flyers posted anywhere's, WONDER WHY!!!!
WONDER WHERE IDA IS WORKING? FULL TIME? No time to post flyers???? clueless
Minion is Observer from CA. AKA JP friend of Derp.
Ask Patrick McStay about them, he knows what sickos they are, and how
they effect grieving families.
Charlotte

Thornwood, NY

#685 Apr 1, 2014
Sue wrote:
<quoted text>
Exactly, nobody knows IF he left with that gun, that gun could have also been scrapped who knows when, BUT, Ida used it to get the cops to take a Missing Person Report!! If not they would have just told her Sorry, "looks like he left Ya Babe"
As for what the public should have known? NOTHING!! Because SHE should have never put it out to the public....This was between her & her husband BUT IDA being the spoiled Bitch & Liar that she is, couldn't DEAL with the fact that Rob left her and she went with the I MUST WIN Mentality. Trouble is she thought she was smarter then everyone else and she would get over on everyone.
I guess she didn't learn from her pass, she got caught lying again, so not too smart!!
ONE MORE thing HTF DO YOU KNOW What his MOTHER & SISTER ARE DOING? Your head is BURIED so far up Ida's Ass & your eating her BS!
Now you can add your dumb little comment to what I said Minion, Observer, or what ever else you want to call yourself J, Try calling yourself an "ASSHOLE" for believing her......
Best post ever!!!!!!!!!!
Charlotte

Thornwood, NY

#686 Apr 1, 2014
One more thing to "the Minions"..........
No one has ever judged Rob for having a possible pain pill problem.
NO ONE. It IS NOT dirty laundry to those that say that.
It is a real life problem that effects millions.

This needs to be brought to attention of all.
The next step is heroin-it's cheaper.
Just ask many suburbanites.

My co-worker lost her son to heroin OD after he went from pain meds.
BTW, he was NYPD detective. It happens to the best of them.

Get your head out your arse minions.

Tell me when this thread is updated: (Registration is not required)

Add to my Tracker Send me an email

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Melville Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
NY New York Primary Election Sept 14: Will you vote? (Sep '10) 12 hr Lol 16,781
Cutting of pastor's role called 'vindictive' (Oct '08) 18 hr Bruser 7,873
NY Who do you support for Governor in New York in ... (Oct '10) Wed Vote Zornow 6,408
Women's Fund of LI to Honor Four Long Island Women Aug 27 WFLI 1
American Home Mortgage chief Michael Strauss ta... (Aug '07) Aug 11 Alice Broadhurst 40
NY Who do you support for Comptroller in New York ... (Oct '10) Aug 9 JEWISH VOICE 438
NY Who do you support for Lieutenant Governor in N... (Oct '10) Aug 7 dew4794 673
•••

Melville News Video

•••
Melville Dating

more search filters

less search filters

•••

Melville Jobs

•••
Enter and win $5000
•••
•••

Melville People Search

Addresses and phone numbers for FREE

•••

Melville News, Events & Info

Click for news, events and info in Melville
•••

Personal Finance

Mortgages [ See current mortgage rates ]
•••