Sue

Commack, NY

#567 Mar 17, 2014
Lisa wrote:
<quoted text>
The sis husband is LE right? I would think her info is correct. But then again I guess all based on what Ida reported! Could there even still be an investigation if nothing criminal? I mean he could up and leave if he wants, no?
Yes, I know the BIL is LE but for her to know they had a fight...That had to come from Ida.

As for the gun....also Ida! That could be the reason she got them to make a report so quickly.

Do I believe there is an investigation going on? NO!
Lisa

Elmont, NY

#568 Mar 17, 2014
Sue wrote:
<quoted text>
Yes, I know the BIL is LE but for her to know they had a fight...That had to come from Ida.
As for the gun....also Ida! That could be the reason she got them to make a report so quickly.
Do I believe there is an investigation going on? NO!
Agree with you! Bad move on her part also , to make claims against his family that is LE! Like I said before cops watch out for each other. I'm sure his opinion of her goes a long way!
pam

East Orange, NJ

#569 Mar 17, 2014
There is an open case on this person. You can check that by calling SCPD... But they don't tell you anything.
Sue

Commack, NY

#570 Mar 17, 2014
pam wrote:
There is an open case on this person. You can check that by calling SCPD... But they don't tell you anything.
Yes Pam, but an open case does not mean they're investigating it.
Only that a report was made that he was missing and he was not found so it remains open.

LE said they do not believe a crime has been committed, so why would they be investigating?
stephen poffley

Glenside, PA

#571 Mar 17, 2014
Lee Jay wrote:
Why do you feel free to bash Ida on here but don't open your mouths on the FB page?
I don't and I can't get on to the fb page :-)
Sue

Commack, NY

#572 Mar 17, 2014
Lisa wrote:
<quoted text>
Agree with you! Bad move on her part also , to make claims against his family that is LE! Like I said before cops watch out for each other. I'm sure his opinion of her goes a long way!
I know Lisa, I have very close family who are in LE. Robs family don't need Ida to find out what is going on.....
stephen poffley

Glenside, PA

#573 Mar 17, 2014
Minion 1 wrote:
<quoted text>
Because there is no reason not to.
And. Likewise there is no reason to
stephen poffley

Glenside, PA

#574 Mar 17, 2014
Minion 1 wrote:
<quoted text>
She's stated it many times before. But according to you and others, she lies and lies. Why should you even believe Rob's missing?
At no point have I been against Ida, if you wish I have a lot to say button your mouth
pam

Philadelphia, PA

#575 Mar 17, 2014
Sue wrote:
<quoted text>
Yes Pam, but an open case does not mean they're investigating it.
Only that a report was made that he was missing and he was not found so it remains open.
LE said they do not believe a crime has been committed, so why would they be investigating?
that's sad for his children.
Michael Ellis

New York, NY

#576 Mar 17, 2014
I followed this story when it first came out. I admittedly lost interest when I found out about the mortgage fraud case. But regardless of that and its relevance or irrelevance, it seems a lot of information has changed since those first couple of months, very peculiar. I can detail some of the revisions if desired, but generally there seem to be a number of new "facts" about this case that should have come out back then, but did not for some reason.
Michael Ellis

New York, NY

#577 Mar 17, 2014
If indeed he had a prescription medication addiction, and he possibly returned home after work very briefly to drop off his ID and cash, and then to drive off with his shotgun, it's far more likely to me that the man committed suicide. The stuff he left behind in the garage (when did Ida find that stuff? That was not mentioned early on in this case) seem like a man eager to disappear, no foul play. Maybe he was under pressures that have only been hinted at, leading to his suicide or intentional disappearance.
Sue

Commack, NY

#578 Mar 17, 2014
pam wrote:
<quoted text>
that's sad for his children.
Yes, very sad......
Minion 1

Los Angeles, CA

#579 Mar 17, 2014
Sue wrote:
<quoted text>
The question is WHAT ARE YOU DOING HERE? Isn't the FB page enough for you?
Are you jealous? Booted, huh?
Lisa

Elmont, NY

#580 Mar 17, 2014
Minion 1 wrote:
<quoted text>
Are you jealous? Booted, huh?
Why are you proud that people are booted off of a page that is supposed to help FIND a missing man? That's just stupid! Yes they are jealous they can't post inspirational quoted and
"Hugs" to Ida everyday!
Sue

Commack, NY

#581 Mar 17, 2014
Minion 1 wrote:
<quoted text>
Are you jealous? Booted, huh?
Jealous of what? A bunch of idiots that support her and give their money away to her! Sorry but I just read her page until it went private.....Never joined because I NEVER believed her.....Have a good night JP!!!
Informer

Sound Beach, NY

#582 Mar 17, 2014
Michael Ellis wrote:
I followed this story when it first came out. I admittedly lost interest when I found out about the mortgage fraud case. But regardless of that and its relevance or irrelevance, it seems a lot of information has changed since those first couple of months, very peculiar. I can detail some of the revisions if desired, but generally there seem to be a number of new "facts" about this case that should have come out back then, but did not for some reason.
Please do... I would like to see what's been over looked. If I have different info I will let you know. I think he left. I think she knows that.
Sue

Commack, NY

#583 Mar 17, 2014
Lisa wrote:
<quoted text>
Why are you proud that people are booted off of a page that is supposed to help FIND a missing man? That's just stupid! Yes they are jealous they can't post inspirational quoted and
"Hugs" to Ida everyday!
That page was never to find a missing man.....Just a way to scam more people!
stephen poffley

Glenside, PA

#584 Mar 17, 2014
Minion 1 wrote:
<quoted text>
Are you jealous? Booted, huh?
And you still don't answer me or at least apologise. What you do is called cyber bullying, the one parent listed on your birth certificate must be so proud
stephen poffley

Glenside, PA

#585 Mar 17, 2014
Sue wrote:
<quoted text>
Yes Pam, but an open case does not mean they're investigating it.
Only that a report was made that he was missing and he was not found so it remains open.
LE said they do not believe a crime has been committed, so why would they be investigating?
Exactly. No crime has been committed according to the evidence so far. However if a claim on life insurance should occur after 3 years, the insurance company may well decide to investigate further
Observer

Murrieta, CA

#586 Mar 17, 2014
Sue wrote:
<quoted text>
Jealous of what? A bunch of idiots that support her and give their money away to her! Sorry but I just read her page until it went private.....Never joined because I NEVER believed her.....Have a good night JP!!!
So you never joined, just stalked her. I see.

What money was given to her exactly?

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Melville Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Cutting of pastor's role called 'vindictive' (Oct '08) 4 hr sweet Benny 7,973
Police Say 14 -Year-Old Boy Shot in Copiague, NY 4 hr CopiagueGazette 1
Is there any Daycares in the area that are Not ... 16 hr Mom in Deer Park 1
Swift Named Principal at Our Lady of Lourdes (Aug '09) 20 hr sweet Benny 2,410
La Costa Nostra Mob defendants from Massapequa (Jan '11) Thu Vito HB Ny 34
Town of Oyster Bay officials curroption exposed... Feb 24 robtruth1103 1
Review: Exotic Motor World of Long Island Feb 24 Tiffany Daino 1

Melville News Video

Melville Dating
Find my Match
More from around the web

Melville People Search

Addresses and phone numbers for FREE

Personal Finance

Mortgages [ See current mortgage rates ]

NFL Latest News

Updated 11:14 pm PST

NBC Sports11:14PM
Report: Kyle Wilson not expected back with Jets
Bleacher Report 4:00 AM
The Jets Best Non-QB Options at No. 6
Bleacher Report 9:23 AM
Report: Chris Canty Released by Ravens
Bleacher Report10:18 AM
Fact or Fiction: Breaking Down Revis, Mariota Rumors
NBC Sports 3:23 PM
Casey McGehee's move to Giants a homecoming of sorts