Tanya Kach and Thomas Hose
First Prev
of 3
Next Last
well stated

Pittsburgh, PA

#43 Oct 15, 2011
Apples and Oranges wrote:
<quoted text>
How can you put abductees in the same category as someone who sought out a relationship with an older man and could have left it at any time? She isn't "one of these girls". That is why those that know the story are so infuriated. She flim flammed Dr. Phil but her story is just that, a story.
This makes more sense than any other post in the 5 or 6 strings about this joke of a woman
More Please

Morgantown, WV

#44 Oct 15, 2011
Word Analyst wrote:
<quoted text>
Let me get this straight...what you are saying here is that what is written in the "book" is to be taken as "gospel" and the "absolute truth" barring all other accounts? Please, say it ain't so.
Just because someone says one thing doesn't make it right...or true. The whole thing (book) is reading more like an article straight out of the pages of "The Weekly World News" and "The National Enquirer". Is Miss Tanya going to appear as the "page five girl" in the WWN? LOL!
HAHA, probably on the next page from updated batboy photos!!
Someone Else

United States

#45 Oct 15, 2011
Voicing Own Opinion wrote:
I wonder if Jaycee Duggard or Elizabeth Smart wrote a book and you "lived" where they had survived their captures too, and that they wrote a book if all of you people would say the same thing about them that it was all lies ( wether a neighbor came into their bedroom and kidnapped them or if they were chained to a fence being held captive)! It seems to me that because "Tanya's" story happened localy all of you people are "bashing" her not being the person it happened to and claiming you "know" the truth and what happened and saying its all lies!!! You guys should be a shamed of yourself!!! Leave the girl alone already and go on with your lives!! Put yourself in one of theses girls shoes what would you have done?? Easier said then done, huh!!!
Are you crazy??!!! YOU cannot be in your right mind if you are comparing Tanya to Jaycee Duggard!! Jaycee was held in a tent...right??? Tanya was "held" (comfortably in a home), by choice. AND could roam around freely. Jaycee had babies in those living conditions...Tanya had her hair & nails done! I could go on for ages here describing the differences!! All I can say is that maybe Tanya read up on Jaycee & others in all her free time in ten years & therefore came up with this scheme!!! Maybe while she was WATCHING TV...I dont think Jaycee had that luxury???
Voicing Own Opinion

Mckeesport, PA

#46 Oct 15, 2011
Someone Else wrote:
<quoted text>
Are you crazy??!!! YOU cannot be in your right mind if you are comparing Tanya to Jaycee Duggard!! Jaycee was held in a tent...right??? Tanya was "held" (comfortably in a home), by choice. AND could roam around freely. Jaycee had babies in those living conditions...Tanya had her hair & nails done! I could go on for ages here describing the differences!! All I can say is that maybe Tanya read up on Jaycee & others in all her free time in ten years & therefore came up with this scheme!!! Maybe while she was WATCHING TV...I dont think Jaycee had that luxury???
Just stating that on how people are saying why didnt she scream or yell to let someone know she was there, well then why didn't Jaycee yell when the cops came!! It goes both ways!! I know Jaycee's situation was far more worse but just stating the possiblities!!
Someone Else

United States

#48 Oct 15, 2011
Voicing Own Opinion wrote:
<quoted text>
Just stating that on how people are saying why didnt she scream or yell to let someone know she was there, well then why didn't Jaycee yell when the cops came!! It goes both ways!! I know Jaycee's situation was far more worse but just stating the possiblities!!
My thought is that if ANYONE ANY age is in a situation they dont want to be in they try to avoid it or get out of it. Honestly she didnt even try to get out of there. I think that is the point people are trying to make. She could have tried to get out of there...right? I'm damned sure if I was kidnapped I'd try like hell to get out! Anyone would, any age, any situation!!
Voicing Own Opinion

Mckeesport, PA

#50 Oct 16, 2011
Someone Else wrote:
<quoted text>
My thought is that if ANYONE ANY age is in a situation they dont want to be in they try to avoid it or get out of it. Honestly she didnt even try to get out of there. I think that is the point people are trying to make. She could have tried to get out of there...right? I'm damned sure if I was kidnapped I'd try like hell to get out! Anyone would, any age, any situation!!
I understand that about trying to escape but alot of times its "easier said than done"!
Voicing Own Opinion

Mckeesport, PA

#51 Oct 16, 2011
Apples and Oranges wrote:
<quoted text>
How can you put abductees in the same category as someone who sought out a relationship with an older man and could have left it at any time? She isn't "one of these girls". That is why those that know the story are so infuriated. She flim flammed Dr. Phil but her story is just that, a story.
The point was "captivity" in all three of these stories!!
OMG U Cant Be Serious

Dravosburg, PA

#52 Oct 16, 2011
Voicing Own Opinion wrote:
<quoted text>
The point was "captivity" in all three of these stories!!
Someone who goes out all the time to get her hair done, nails done, the corner deli, church, etc... Is not in captivity. Not even close.
Jonathan

Pittsburgh, PA

#53 Oct 16, 2011
OMG U Cant Be Serious wrote:
<quoted text>
Someone who goes out all the time to get her hair done, nails done, the corner deli, church, etc... Is not in captivity. Not even close.
I agree 100% If you are held captive, you wouldn't be out and about doing all the things she did. She wanted to be there, she wanted it all....if she didnt, why did she stay?
McKeesport for Tom Hose

Pittsburgh, PA

#54 Jan 30, 2012
concerned

Koroit, Australia

#56 Nov 20, 2012
Sunshine48 wrote:
<quoted text>
I couldnt agree with you more!!
Beautifully said!
unconcerned

Pittsburgh, PA

#58 Nov 23, 2012
Isn't it just amazing how trash threads like this one "magically" appear out of nowhere after such a lengthy slumber?
.
Put it to bed once and for all and let sleeping "dogs" lie!
who cares

Spalding, UK

#59 Dec 1, 2012
Just watched a program in the UK about this story. Thomas Hose was patently wrong for having sex with a minor and should be punished for his crime. Their is just something that makes me uneasy about Tanya Kash's story, I believe the she she was abused but she has embellished her story for some financial gain maybe!!!
lookbothways

Stoke-on-trent, UK

#60 Jan 16, 2013
I too just saw this on UK tv & even tho I believe Tanya is withholding certain elements of her story I think for the most part it's been overlooked the key point that Hose was a paedophile who sought out the company of Tanya, he conditioned her during those long walks when she was supposed to be in class. You all say she could have left and if she was being pampered she wasn't really captive e well if you have been conditioned to accept that what id happening is right she was hardly going to run just goes to show how devious Hose was he targeted a girl badly in need of attention and he knew exactly.how to manipulate her. As for the hairdressing and nails a cage is still a cage even if it's gilded plus feeds into Hose making Tanya feel loved and special a typical paedophile tactic and as for her being allowed freedom shows cocky smugness he had her 100% under his control.
Dee123

Ireland

#61 Jan 20, 2013
prest wrote:
My heart goes out to the Krimm family..I know this bullshit has to burn you up because I'm on fire over here!!!No justice for Kimmie but this goofball ball bitch is on Dr.Phil!?!?!WTF!!??!!
I totally agree!!!!
Justice Inches On

Elizabeth, PA

#62 Jan 20, 2013
Dee123 wrote:
<quoted text>
I totally agree!!!!
Does any know if the County, State, or Federal Agents were involved in the unsolved murder??

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 3
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

McKeesport Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
How can Ryan complain 24 min Kortz PFA 14
democratic vs republician 16 hr Voted for Trump 26
Bill Kortz is at PFA Hearing 16 hr Corrupt Comey 8
When is the first Titan home game? (Aug '12) Tue Harvey Weinstein 9
News Ex-teacher charged with corrupting Schenley stu... (Feb '07) Oct 14 Harvey Weinstein 14
most haunted places in mckeesport (Oct '11) Oct 14 History Nut 12
Someone needs to explain how this worrks, Oct 13 Touchables 24

McKeesport Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

McKeesport Mortgages