Jason vs. Michael Myers: Who wins?

“He who laughs last...”

Since: May 09

...laughs best of all.

#21 Jan 13, 2011
That depends on whose rules we are playing by.

IF you want to go with the sheer mythology(I have seen every Jason movie about 10 times, including the terrible number 7 remakes, with the exception of Jason X which sucked) then the winner is Jason.

The Lake is NOT Jason's power source its actually his mask according to Victor Miller and Tom Savini.(Even though he did not wear the hockey mask until movie 3)
Jason's soul is trapped in the mask by his anger and desire for revenge on those who killed his crazy mother.
The Mask is capable of possessing the body of anyone who wears it.(though not shown in the movies) Each Jason is actually a different person possessed by the evil mask. Originally he only possessed the strength of whom ever's body he was using. In the case of Movie 2 it was a back woods inbred hillbilly. So he had all the extra retard strength.
Though as he grew in anger and power his mask then began to bestow superhuman strength on the wearers.
Which is why in movie 6 he was able to smash that chicks head into the inside of the RV that it showed her face imprint on the outside.(music by Alice Cooper, He's Back 1986)

Michael Myers(aka The Shape) is just a mentally retarded psycho with an extraordinary resistance to pain and injury,(seen retard comment above)according to Debra Hill and John Carpenter.
His inability to die is just sheer luck and the fact he doesn't feel pain.

This mental short coming is why he is so strong.
Normal people do not use 100 percent of our bodies full strength because the constant use would destroy our bodies. So most people only use about or less than half.
People like Myers who have mental or nerve damage can use more strength because their brain is unable to restrict the amount of force used.
This give them their "superhuman" strength and resistance.

So since Jason is an unkillable spirit whose soul prevents the mask it is trapped in from being destroyed(they did try that in one movie) and can possess and transform anyone who wears it into and unstoppable killing machine, and Michael is just a human being no matter how strong and crazy: Jason would win hands down.

See part two for my take on how Freddy stacks up to these two retarded momma's boys.

“He who laughs last...”

Since: May 09

...laughs best of all.

#22 Jan 13, 2011
Freddy is different from both parties simple because he is in no way physical.

According to Wes Craven Freddy is a Dream stalker created by the twisted soul of a murdering pedophile who was burned to death by vigilante justice.

While smarter and more sadistic than both Michael and Jason combined(not by much since he wasn't smart enough to talk until movie 3) and on their best days, he lacks real power. Freddy's powers are amazing and quite deadly he can only prey on the fears and dreams of his victims. He does not have any power of his own.

He is summoned when a human of extraordinary psychic or paranormal ability feel uncontrollable fear and dreams him into existence. This is from the Wes Craven mythology as revealed in the TV series Freddy's Nightmares, as this fact was left out of the movies though it was referenced in Dream Warriors, Dream Master, And Dream Child.
This psychic or "Dream Child" is the only person to who can truly defeat Kruger, and according to Jason VS Freddy, can summon Freddy from the dream world into reality where he can be physically killed.
Physically killing Freddy in the real world only returns him to the nightmare world he came from.

As for mentioned Freddy really has no power of his own, only what is given to him by the fears of his victims. If they do not fear him he had no power.

Only when in the physical world does Freddy have the ability to kill anyone he likes though he is no stronger than he was when he was alive. As shown in Jason VS Freddy he does how every have good speed and agility to work with. Would not recommended challenging him to a knife fight.

Since the original question was Jason vs Michael not really an issue here, but if we did throw him into the mix Freddy would not be able to kill either Jason or Michael.

Michael is a retarded psycho path and doesn't feel fear so in dream land Freddy couldn't touch him and in the real world since Freddy is just basically a normal guy with bad skin and a terrible sweater Michael could eat him alive, literally. Freddy is only about 5'6"-5'8".(Robert England however is 5'10")

Jason is unkillable, though the water in Crystal Lake is the only thing that can put him back to sleep it does NOT KILL HIM.

So in dream world while Kruger could feed on Jason's fears of water and losing his mother, Freddy couldn't actually kill him.

In the real world again Jason doesn't die while Freddy is still pretty much human.

Jason: 2
Michael: 1
Freddy: 0
Manchester United: 3(sorry football joke)
mr giggles

Maysville, KY

#23 Jan 14, 2011
nobody cares about your stupid 25 paragraph comments ronin! you nerd!!!!!!!!
dolphin

Maysville, KY

#24 Jan 15, 2011
Ronins Comments wasn't that bad
Kevintt

South Dennis, MA

#25 Jul 7, 2012
Mikes 7 ft and immortal end of story
Cristian Gheorghiu

United States

#26 Aug 2, 2012
Jason wins, period.
Cristian Gheorghiu

United States

#27 Aug 2, 2012
Oh, and Kevintt, Myers is nowhere near 7 feet tall. Only in that terrible rob zombie remake is he portrayed as a giant.
justathought

Maysville, KY

#28 Aug 3, 2012
Michael Myers.......HANDS DOWN
Stephen

Richlands, VA

#29 Oct 21, 2012
Mike Tyson
mich with no worries

Virginia Beach, VA

#30 Oct 29, 2012
Micheal all the they way Jason cant even beat chucky so ima say Mich with no worries
bull

Maysville, KY

#31 Oct 29, 2012
depends on if it's the rob zombie "micheal myers" cause the rob zombie one would win...
Neogenics

South Africa

#32 Nov 4, 2012
Dustin wrote:
A movie WOULD be absolutely amazing between the two but they would both continue to survive. One thing that no one ever seems to remember is that Michael has been beheaded, shot in the heart numerous times, and crushed by a car twice within a matter of minutes after which he was still living and had to be put to sleep by what I can only guess as being an axe through the skull. The beheading alone (considering he does return) proves that Micheal can return to life. As far as weapons go, Jason uses more on a frequent basis, but they're mostly related to a slashing blade of sorts. Micheal has used cars on numerous occasions, I believe at least once to kill someone, and he mostly sticks with a trusty, gigantic, kitchen knife. Technically according to Jason Goes to Hell, if Jason's heart is destroyed Jason won't come back (or we're led to believe that). Michael has never had any hidden loop hole (at least to my knowledge) that will stop him from returning. Now my question is, if Michael were to eat Jason's heart, would he become Jason, destroy Jason, or be some sort of hybrid of the two?(I apologize if I ended up getting some facts wrong as it has been a while since I've watched most of the Friday the 13th saga)
u couldn't have sed that any better, I think michael is the better killer
Neogenics

South Africa

#33 Nov 4, 2012
Ronin_LLC wrote:
That depends on whose rules we are playing by.
IF you want to go with the sheer mythology(I have seen every Jason movie about 10 times, including the terrible number 7 remakes, with the exception of Jason X which sucked) then the winner is Jason.
The Lake is NOT Jason's power source its actually his mask according to Victor Miller and Tom Savini.(Even though he did not wear the hockey mask until movie 3)
Jason's soul is trapped in the mask by his anger and desire for revenge on those who killed his crazy mother.
The Mask is capable of possessing the body of anyone who wears it.(though not shown in the movies) Each Jason is actually a different person possessed by the evil mask. Originally he only possessed the strength of whom ever's body he was using. In the case of Movie 2 it was a back woods inbred hillbilly. So he had all the extra retard strength.
Though as he grew in anger and power his mask then began to bestow superhuman strength on the wearers.
Which is why in movie 6 he was able to smash that chicks head into the inside of the RV that it showed her face imprint on the outside.(music by Alice Cooper, He's Back 1986)
Michael Myers(aka The Shape) is just a mentally retarded psycho with an extraordinary resistance to pain and injury,(seen retard comment above)according to Debra Hill and John Carpenter.
His inability to die is just sheer luck and the fact he doesn't feel pain.
This mental short coming is why he is so strong.
Normal people do not use 100 percent of our bodies full strength because the constant use would destroy our bodies. So most people only use about or less than half.
People like Myers who have mental or nerve damage can use more strength because their brain is unable to restrict the amount of force used.
This give them their "superhuman" strength and resistance.
So since Jason is an unkillable spirit whose soul prevents the mask it is trapped in from being destroyed(they did try that in one movie) and can possess and transform anyone who wears it into and unstoppable killing machine, and Michael is just a human being no matter how strong and crazy: Jason would win hands down.
See part two for my take on how Freddy stacks up to these two retarded momma's boys.
Wow, a spirit u say, in the mask? So if he's mask is taken off an put on a monkey, the monkey woudl become jason? Then I guess michael wouldn't need much strength then, just put his mask on a little animal an put him in a zoo, if u mix fiction with real life then both of them are even coz everybody will always have something new to add
bar scene

United States

#34 Nov 5, 2012
Dustin wrote:
A movie WOULD be absolutely amazing between the two but they would both continue to survive. One thing that no one ever seems to remember is that Michael has been beheaded, shot in the heart numerous times, and crushed by a car twice within a matter of minutes after which he was still living and had to be put to sleep by what I can only guess as being an axe through the skull. The beheading alone (considering he does return) proves that Micheal can return to life. As far as weapons go, Jason uses more on a frequent basis, but they're mostly related to a slashing blade of sorts. Micheal has used cars on numerous occasions, I believe at least once to kill someone, and he mostly sticks with a trusty, gigantic, kitchen knife. Technically according to Jason Goes to Hell, if Jason's heart is destroyed Jason won't come back (or we're led to believe that). Michael has never had any hidden loop hole (at least to my knowledge) that will stop him from returning. Now my question is, if Michael were to eat Jason's heart, would he become Jason, destroy Jason, or be some sort of hybrid of the two?(I apologize if I ended up getting some facts wrong as it has been a while since I've watched most of the Friday the 13th saga)
Michael wasn't actual beheaded. It was another guy in his mask. Michael escaped in the creek.
bar scene

United States

#35 Nov 5, 2012
bar scene wrote:
<quoted text>Michael wasn't actual beheaded. It was another guy in his mask. Michael escaped in the creek.
Michael was smart enough to put his mask on that guy. Jamie lee thought it was Michael then cut that poor guys head off. At the end if the movie it seemed like it was Michael but the next movie it showed Michael escaping while another guy got his head chopped off.
JASON 09

Berwick, PA

#36 Jan 25, 2013
Jason 2009 was highly more sophisticated then previous films.. forget zombie Jason! micheal Myers while capable of driving is product of environment! Jason didn't need to drive he is surrounded by trees.. anyway if you took the giant mike from robs movie nd Jason from 2009, Jason wins hands down, after spiking mike with an arrow to the leg so he couldn't run like a b****, Jason would simply split his wig with an axe or the famous machete.. Jason used ranged weapons while mike stick with his knife nd ate dogs lol
aj money

Indianapolis, IN

#37 Jan 30, 2013
frist jason will win because think back the man was burn in Freddy vs Jason and still walking blowed up hang and was shot by high tech weapons frozen he got upgrade and stabbing in the eyes and shot down to Earth. micheal myer that guy can not run think back jason may walk but how the hell he get right to killing did micheal get shot by a torpedo no micheal cum on Halloween and kill people and die on halloween jason cum back on friday the 13th and go all out die so let say u at china and jason at Crystal Lake he will walk his big dead self there and kill most all people there micheal got to talk a car jason will win I said wat I said
Michael

Barnsley, Australia

#38 Apr 22, 2013
Technically Michael wasnt beheaded because it is later revealed Laurie went to a mental institution for decapitating an innocent man :)
Noze

Georgetown, KY

#39 Apr 22, 2013
Who cares
ikeal

Chicago, IL

#40 May 8, 2013
I think michael myers would win.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Maysville Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Tiffany Hook 17 min Lol 4
News Bible study rules for public schools proposed (Feb '10) 20 min Family Man 141,260
Grand Buffet 1 hr asianwomanishot 45
emily fletcher 2 hr Exactly 13
Emily Fletcher thief 2 hr Craziness 11
Cops in maysville 4 hr Lol 15
Police rodeo round-up 10 hr Old school 18
More from around the web

Maysville People Search

Addresses and phone numbers for FREE

Personal Finance

Maysville Mortgages