Oprah's magazine features Manlius kil...

Oprah's magazine features Manlius killing

There are 3 comments on the The Post-Standard story from Jun 8, 2010, titled Oprah's magazine features Manlius killing. In it, The Post-Standard reports that:

Manlius, NY -- A Central New York murder case that split a family is featured in an article in the current issue of "O, The Oprah Magazine." The article profiles the case of Timothy Ginocchetti, who killed his mother in 2006, and focuses on Ginocchetti's grandmother, Esther Rufo.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at The Post-Standard.


Sweet Valley, PA

#1 Jun 13, 2010
The article that is written by Mark Obbie a professor a Syracuse University is "focused" on Esther Rufo. As a journalist Mr. Obbie, you should have done more research on your subject and be more objective and interviewed others within the community of the overall situation. I'm sure Mrs. Rufo did not divulge to you that she is mentally unstable, or that she herself had mentally abused her own children for years. Do you think that maybe she is looking for redemption for all the pain she herself had contributed to these circumstances? Many years ago, Oprah had on her television show a gentleman named Gavin De Becker, this gentleman talked about his past history and how he was abused; however, he made a choices to make a difference in his life. He himself made a "choice" to be a better person; to be a contributing member of society. Timothy Ginocchetti made a "choice" to lie in wait for his mother to come home; Timothy made a "choice" to instigate an altercation with her, to "stab" her repeatedly; over and over and over again. Timothy himself made a "choice" to commit this crime, Timothy made a choice to "take a life", Timothy made a "choice" to ruin his own life and of those around him. Many things happen in our own individual lives on a daily basis, how we as individuals "choose" to act is our own responsibility and should not be the responsibility anyone else. Let's all start taking responsibility for our own actions. Mr. Obbie, I question why you would par-take in this article and only write from one perspective; other than to make a name for yourself and money off of the pain of the individuals that were affected by this monstrous act. I will end with this quote by Andy Rand: "Man is being with free will;therefore, each man is potentially good or evil, and it's up to him and only him (through his reasoning mind) to decide which he wants to be." Again Timothy made his choice and his "choice" was not for "good".

Frazeysburg, OH

#2 Jun 17, 2010
I can appreciate the fact that the above person thinks they have details of the families history. What is really important here? Isn't it life itself. We are all human beings that are capable of terrible and wonderful things. I would like to join Oprah in her celebration of supporting our families through hard times. Taking a life would have to be one of the hardest mistakes to live with. I hear all the Christians that want to judge, but my God forgives and shows compassion. If you are so knowledgeable about this family, then as a Christian you need to extend you love and forgiven to a very difficult situation for this family. I call you out to be the example the world needs in extending yourself not placing blame. Bless you.

Natrona Heights, PA

#3 Jun 19, 2010
It's all about forgiveness. God forgives all except blasphemy against the Holy Spirit. When we die we each stand before God and His judgment. Esther had to do one of the hardest things I'm sure a mother ever has to do, forgive her grandson for killing her daughter. How did she find it in her heart to do that? Only she knows. That is a heart filled with the love of Jesus. As for the rest of the family. I hope one day they will forgive Tim for their own sakes, and their own healing. It's such a sad situation. We cannot judge, for we do not walk in their shoes. I pray for the whole family in their pain and suffering.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Manlius Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Ten Pin (Nov '15) Wed Maurice 5
tuscarora road (Apr '15) Jan 17 Stan 21
Keep your Riff Raff out of our town (Sep '10) Dec 26 Too funny 16
Eligible Chittenago men! Young or old! Dec '16 Quirk 3
Mark Welytok Dec '16 Old Flame 1
News Well-known obstetrician Dr. Robert Neulander in... (Jun '14) Dec '16 op tannenbaum 2
News Meth lab busted in Madison County town of Sullivan (Feb '14) Dec '16 John 5

Manlius Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

Manlius Mortgages