JusticeInTheCour troom

New York, NY

#21 Dec 5, 2012
Pho wrote:
And what ever came of the person that sold them dope?
You mean the dope that always was readily available? I wonder by who...?
U r a moron

Burnt Hills, NY

#22 Dec 6, 2012
oopsie daisy wrote:
Pho are you for real?!!?!? The Menke girl CHOSE to get behind the wheel KNOWING she wasn't licensed, was under the influence and the conditions were horrible. WHY would the Collette girl get time, for getting in the vehicle when she shouldn't have - a price she's paying now and will continue to. The ONLY BAD parents in this whole mess, as Judge Main eluded to are the Menkes for giving this girl access to a vehicle before she was licensed. Then the Menke mother has done nothing but run her mouth about her poor, poor baby. If these girls were 4, 5 or 6 yep I'd look at the parents but this girl was old enough to know better, just spoiled and catered to enough to not care cause mommy and daddy will ALWAYS fix it. In my opinion she didn't get ENOUGH jail time, and her parents should be charged also. They would've if the

weapon had been a gun.....
Everyone can cast judgement. But u tell me that u did everything perfect when you were a kid. U never drank a beer or drove a car or did anything stupid. Of course u did the only difference is u did not get caught. Grow up u moron. And to your last question no the parents would not have been charged if it was a gun. Not enough jail time??? So if Tanya would have gotten ten years then that would bring the Lyon girl back to life?? Or the collet girl injury free?? Point is she was sentenced by the LEGAL SYSTEM. And will do her time. But just remember she has to live with this for the rest of her life.
Pho

United States

#23 Dec 6, 2012
From what I hear she left because she herself had been under suspicion of taking narcotics. Real winner she is.
Pho

United States

#24 Dec 6, 2012
Thank god for the last few posts there truly are people out there that give a s?!'k about people instead of these bloodsuckers out there. Brushton girl and oopsy daisy I'm sorry your both to slow too understand small things like mistakes and forgiveness. Money nor vengeance solves anything, with that being said if I can continue to irritate the sh$&8,$ out of both of you Until your days come to an end :)
correction

New York, NY

#25 Dec 6, 2012
Pho wrote:
Thank god for the last few posts there truly are people out there that give a s?!'k about people instead of these bloodsuckers out there. Brushton girl and oopsy daisy I'm sorry your both to slow too understand small things like mistakes and forgiveness. Money nor vengeance solves anything, with that being said if I can continue to irritate the sh$&8,$ out of both of you Until your days come to an end :)
your birth was a mistake. the lyons girls death was a crime and the killer should be so punished. as to did i ever drive drunk, regrettably i did, but i never killed anyone doing it and would have deserved lots of jail time if i had. if you can't see the differences, you are totally clueless
northofnowhere

New York, NY

#26 Dec 6, 2012
Money is all these families want.
Money wont bring the girl back only give them pleasures they cant afford now, Why live high on the money you make from a tragedy?
Leave the menkies alone they have enough to contend with.
brushton girl

Fort Edward, NY

#27 Dec 6, 2012
Aggravated77 wrote:
.she was served with a life sentence having to face that every day of her life that was number ONE for her sentencing of the other 32 things that was served to her. No one has the right to say she shows no remorse for what had happened she feels inside she is HUMAN she goes on with life every day smiling on the out side how ever inside is torn apart unless you have been in her shoes NO ONE has the right to judge or say how she should feel, I personally know Tanya very well and she is one stronge girl and has to be for all the stones thrown at her, The Menke family has been through hell and is suffering just the same they to have had to cope with the accident, The loss of a family member/freind of the family, as well as another who suffered injuries and is currently still recovering, there loss of there house, the pain they go through with there daughter's mental suffering, The nasty comments of all the negitive people, The news paper, Right up to having to sit behind there daughter as she read her paper she had wrote and had to read in front of the judge, and about 100 people that sat in that court room and as well as the other two families SINCERLY CRYING saying how she was SORRY for all the pain she had caused and her mom and dad could not even console her, how would you people feel if that was your child any normal parent would be hurting inside, but see there again the paper makes her sound heart less and never did they put the whole story in the paper just the part they wanted to, while the other two families had there pages printed in the paper, I also felt it was important for the Collette's mom to speak on her daughters behalf but felt that only parts of that were true and I felt money was more of the plea, I remember back when the school had a benifit for alexis her mom stated she was thankful for all the money the community had donated that they raised enough to where she could be finacially stable to care for her family so that she did not have to work so she could take care of her daughter....so how can you ask for 18,000 for loss wages... and how she has to sit in a certain kind of chair, or she has trouble with reading and writing, how is she is regular classes and manages to stay on the honor role mmm and as stated in the paper she was sitting in court with her helmet that had been decorated with stickers [FALSE ADVERTISING] her helmet was sitting on the floor and she was sitting on a court bench at one point leaning forward when the judge had spoke about the sentencing for Tanya, alexis was leaned forward with her hand on her moms shoulder...she also manages to go around laughing and joking while shopping why is she carrying on with life so happy with the loss of her best freind.DOES THAT MEAN SHE DOES NOT CARE EITHER.. No it means they are all learning how to cope and deal with this in there own way the same as Tanya. And then there was the Lyon's whom spoke on behalf of there daughter which was also needed for the healing process and there wish was granted by Tanya serving a jail sentence. So why keep carrying this on ALL THREE FAMILIES WERE TREATED FAIR..Let the Menke family move on from this nightmare stop bashing them as Tanya will be serving her life sentence with the pain leave her alone, Let Alexis recover from her injuries and move on live life to the fullest as you were given a second chance, and for the Lyon's I hope you all can move on as I cant say how you feel loosing a child my heart goes out to you but lets let Brook rest in peace.
YOU HAVE CLEARLY LOST YOUR MIND OR WERE RAISED IGNORANT! EVERYONE SEES THAT!
Sick Bird

United States

#28 Dec 6, 2012
What she did was illegal and she admitted it and she got sentenced. Hopefully everyone learned from this, but sadly, judging from a lot of these comments I don't think many did.

A young girl's life was taken. Another was injured to the point it will linger with her the rest of her days. And the girl who ultimately had control over the situation (regardless if you think she did or didnt , she was driving and therefore responsible for everyone in the car) has to live the rest of her life as a convicted criminal and knowing her decision killed her friend and seriously injured her other friend. In the end there are three victims...

I applaud the sentence as it also sends an example to you people that just because you are young does not mean you will not be held responsible for your actions.

I think it is time everyone moves on.
brushton girl

Fort Edward, NY

#29 Dec 6, 2012
Sick Bird wrote:
What she did was illegal and she admitted it and she got sentenced. Hopefully everyone learned from this, but sadly, judging from a lot of these comments I don't think many did.
A young girl's life was taken. Another was injured to the point it will linger with her the rest of her days. And the girl who ultimately had control over the situation (regardless if you think she did or didnt , she was driving and therefore responsible for everyone in the car) has to live the rest of her life as a convicted criminal and knowing her decision killed her friend and seriously injured her other friend. In the end there are three victims...
I applaud the sentence as it also sends an example to you people that just because you are young does not mean you will not be held responsible for your actions.
I think it is time everyone moves on.
BRILLIANT! Ive often thought Tanya Menke could be a hero.....a huge hero to her peers who dont realize their actions. instead she has to suffer due to her ignorant hillbilly familys ways.....if they would just shut up!
mrsc

Hudson, NY

#30 Dec 6, 2012
I dont know any of these girls and I feel the sentence was not enough.You see other people getting alot more than that come on it was a slap on the hand.Yes it was a accident but someone still died and someone was still seriously injured I dont see the justice
Pho

Swarthmore, PA

#32 Dec 6, 2012
Once again wah wah wah save the justice for the pedophiles
Really

Massena, NY

#33 Dec 6, 2012
I do feel that she is responsible for the crash. However I feel it is being overlooked at the fact that I am pretty sure these other girls knew they were getting into a car with someone that was not ok to drive whether it was the drugs or that she didnt have a license. They knew they were all taking a chance and chose to take it. Do I feel they should have had to pay with their lives...ABSOLUTELY NOT. However its not like they were innocent bystanders who were driving another car and she hit them. They got in that car with her. And no I wasn't there and don't know all the facts. But it seems to me the guilt and just the knowledge she has to deal with knowing she killed one friend and severely injured another is more punishment then any judge could ever place on someone.
And these families need to realize these girls were friends and nothing is ever going to change that or bring anyone back to life, or bring someon'e life back to normal. And her rotting in jail is not going to change the outcome of this. HOwever with her going around and having to speak to other teens about this is a fantastic idea. Even if it saves only 1 life to me it's worth it.
I also don't feel that blaming the parents is the way to go here. These girls were not 5 and the Menke's family can be blamed all you want to about letting her have the car to drive. But to me if you are going to place blame here, what about the other girls parents allowing them to hang out together and obviously weren't supervising their teens either.
I feel very badly for all 3 families and the community.
YouShouldKnow

Jamaica Plain, MA

#34 Dec 6, 2012
brushton girl wrote:
<quoted text>
BRILLIANT! Ive often thought Tanya Menke could be a hero.....a huge hero to her peers who dont realize their actions. instead she has to suffer due to her ignorant hillbilly familys ways.....if they would just shut up!
"Ignorant hillbilly family"? If a faithful Christian family that goes to church every Sunday and helps out in the community regularly is that than I applaud the hillbilly ways of the Menke family!! Through all of this instead of hating and being mean like others choose to do they have instead enveloped the whole community in LOVE begging them to stand together and heal! Kudos to them..may we all strive to have the love that they have on a daily basis!

Since: Dec 12

Burnt Hills, NY

#35 Dec 6, 2012
brushton girl wrote:
<quoted text>
YOU HAVE CLEARLY LOST YOUR MIND OR WERE RAISED IGNORANT! EVERYONE SEES THAT!
Ok lol and apperently you are to young to understand any of this and you probally should be in bed getting ready for school in the morning there BRUSHTON GIRL, if ignorance is saying I feel bad for all three of the girls and stating a fact well THEN HELL I AM PROUD TO BE IGNORANT At leaste I was raised with morals and feelings and care for others. You my Freind should be taught the same! OH LMAO WAIT judging from your posts you must be one of the PERFECT GIRLS that have no skeletons in ur closet u must lead a boring life to be perfect!
Teddy bear

New York, NY

#36 Dec 6, 2012
So true Aggravated77 .this Bruston girl needs to be in bed getting ready to go to school in the morning to bad they don't teach kids in school what it means to have morals and to care for others insted of bullying .Maybe some day Bruston girl will grow up and realize kids don't always make right decisions and i'm sure this person is not perfect either .before passing judgement maybe u need to look in your own back yard .If u are perfect maybe u should be out there teaching the young and teens right from wrong/good choices ,bad choices instead of bullying .then we would have a perfect wold .Lets see how perfect u are .
brushton girl

Fort Edward, NY

#37 Dec 7, 2012
Aggravated77 wrote:
<quoted text> Ok lol and apperently you are to young to understand any of this and you probally should be in bed getting ready for school in the morning there BRUSHTON GIRL, if ignorance is saying I feel bad for all three of the girls and stating a fact well THEN HELL I AM PROUD TO BE IGNORANT At leaste I was raised with morals and feelings and care for others. You my Freind should be taught the same! OH LMAO WAIT judging from your posts you must be one of the PERFECT GIRLS that have no skeletons in ur closet u must lead a boring life to be perfect!
Just because my name says Girl doesnt mean I am in school Dylan. I already graduated a few years ago...now what soapbox are you gonna stand on? Sad part is the DA wanted NO jail for her but your familys facebook got her 45 days!
brushton girl

Fort Edward, NY

#38 Dec 7, 2012
Teddy bear wrote:
So true Aggravated77 .this Bruston girl needs to be in bed getting ready to go to school in the morning to bad they don't teach kids in school what it means to have morals and to care for others insted of bullying .Maybe some day Bruston girl will grow up and realize kids don't always make right decisions and i'm sure this person is not perfect either .before passing judgement maybe u need to look in your own back yard .If u are perfect maybe u should be out there teaching the young and teens right from wrong/good choices ,bad choices instead of bullying .then we would have a perfect wold .Lets see how perfect u are .
i should be in bed, i should have morals, i should care for others????? if someone had taught Tanya Menke (parents) any of this sadly she wouldnt have to live like she does.....now she will hopefully teach others. How will she do that though since family has convinced her she did nothing wrong?
Pho

Woodbury, NJ

#39 Dec 7, 2012
Well it's obvious Bruston girl school and your parents did very little for you.

Since: Dec 12

Burnt Hills, NY

#40 Dec 7, 2012
brushton girl wrote:
<quoted text>
Just because my name says Girl doesnt mean I am in school Dylan. I already graduated a few years ago...now what soapbox are you gonna stand on? Sad part is the DA wanted NO jail for her but your familys facebook got her 45 days!
Well family ok I would be proud to say my family I am not ashamed if I was related how ever see ur like all other accuse the wrong people of typing or saying stuff lol guess ur not so perfect r cause u have no idea who I am lol but yea ur just perfect so you will find out who I really am and by the way Dylan is a nice kid I met him a few time!!
Teddy bear

New York, NY

#41 Dec 7, 2012
way to go Aggravated77 .Again shows how people point fingers when they have no clue who they are even talking to .just easier to point fingers at innocent people .I don't think the judges decision had anything to do with things that were posted on facebook .so get over it the judge gave the sentence she will do it and it's done and over with .so move on find someone else to point your fingers at and leave the menkee family alone .maybe look in your own back yard your far from perfect .

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Malone Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Voter fraud 24 min Hahaha 22
News Former U.S. Border agent sentenced in attempted... 27 min He was not convicted 406
TBoneSteak Arrested 9 hr Know the facts 22
Passed away 11 hr Person 4
Desire hart (Apr '15) 12 hr concerned 24
Malone Village Police (Jul '11) 12 hr Malone 77
Price of sh## 19 hr Birth Control 4
T Bone steak 21 hr Bullseye 139

Malone Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

Malone Mortgages