Appeal Denied For Convicted Murderer,...

Appeal Denied For Convicted Murderer, Vincent Doan

There are 147 comments on the WCPO-TV9 Cincinnati story from Dec 1, 2008, titled Appeal Denied For Convicted Murderer, Vincent Doan. In it, WCPO-TV9 Cincinnati reports that:

A convicted murderer will not get a new trial. The 6th Circuit Court of Appeals denied the appeal for Vincent Doan.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at WCPO-TV9 Cincinnati.

Ron

Tipp City, OH

#123 Nov 20, 2013
Carla an old friend told me her husband was working on a road crew near Cincinnati tearing up the road and hauling the old road to a dump, i forget the name of the dump,Carla said her husband and other workers seen Doan with a woman in a dump truck, i think it was the day before Carrie went missing,i was told Doan drove a dump truck working with Carlas husband, she said they thought Carrie was in the dump or under the new road.Anyone know if Vincent drove a dump truck, i used to live in Butlerville and went to Blanchester all the time in late 50's and early 60's, i love the area and still visit.Just thought i would share what i was told, i never knew knew Carrie or Vince.
WHy

Blanchester, OH

#124 Jan 11, 2014
alice kelly wrote:
I don't know if Vincent killed Carrie or not, all I know is that I don't believe this young man had a fair trial. This is the first case that I've known about where testimony was all "hearsay". Why in the world would anyone try a case with nothing but hearsay evidence. If Vincent is guilty then he is where he belongs, but if innocent, he doesn't belong in prison for life. If I were a juror on this case I would have never found him guilty on such flimsy evidence. No body, no forensic evidence, nothing. We're talking about a young man's life here people. He at least deserves a new trial. JMO
If he wants a new trial tell where he hid her remains. If she is alive she is safe because he is in prison for life no parole. True he would be released if she turned up but we all know after 18 years that won't happen. This guy is so sick he won't tell where he left her remains when in fact he is never getting out so he has nothing to lose. If the guy had any morals or his family they would tell and let her be buried properly. doan was offered a lighter sentence to reveal the location of her remains. He is nothing more than a Psychopath. NO WAY HE GETS A SECOND CHANCE. In fact if the opportunity arises someone in prison could make quite a bit of money in their commissary to make him talk. If he doesn't he won't be able to fart agaon only the sound of wind. Personally If she was related to me he wouldn't have made it past a year in prison.
WHy

Blanchester, OH

#125 Jan 11, 2014
sheila wrote:
<quoted text>how do you know? who proved he beat her regularly?
The hospital reports, the police reports, her former employer the neighbor across from doans home who witnessed this, her friends. He beatings are on record and his name came up everytime THAT'S WHO. You have got to be related to this ABUSIVE MURDERER. BTW tell him I hope his backside is stretch wide open and his jaws are sore from all the poles he has had shoved in him.
WHy

Blanchester, OH

#126 Jan 11, 2014
Acecat wrote:
<quoted text> You are so right!! I've read some posts that ask "where were Vince's rights?" "No body--no crime". What is wrong with these people? This jerk beat her up, held her hostage with a gun and then killed her when she finally filed charges against him. No one else had the motive or the opportunity to kill her. And for those that still believe she's alive--just shut up. There is no way Carrie would have ever abandoned her mother and sister without a word. If she were still alive, her family would know where she was. Vincent Doan is a piece of trash and deserves everything he gets.
I agree with everything you said except the part about him deserving everything he gets because he doesn't deserve to get to stay alive he doesn't deserve to eat food he doesn't deserve to breathe air and he certainly doesn't deserve to have visits with his family members. Now he does deserve to get visits in the middle of the night from his boyfriend bubba because bubba likes it rough.
WHy

Blanchester, OH

#127 Jan 11, 2014
Innocent wrote:
This was a complete hearsay testimony, there was no DNA, no evidence, no body,lots of perjury. My family has been friends with Vince since they were little and all played together and they still maintain his innocence. They say he was nothing but a gentlemen and was very polite. So why is it that his own neighbor Billi Jo Brown could not even positively identify him as the man outside the night she disappeared that she was supposedly arguing with? How about Lori Baker, she changed her testimony how many times? Vicki Watkins? Over 20 people have sighted her since her disappearance and even chaged tires for her? How does all of this happen by people who are not even connected to this case show up saying they have seen her yet no one believes them??? For the person on here that says "give him a new trial we have more evidence against him now", there was no evidence from the beginning and they put him in a setting with a biased jury and expected this man to have a fair trial??? Vince Doan is innocent and I will believe that until the day he is set free!!!
So you are going to believe it until his corpse is hauled out of prison? That is your right. BUT all the so called witnesses you said appeared had no connection to vinny have all been found out over the years to be hired guns for the doan family. Don't get me wrong i understand why the doan family hired these people because they were trying to put resonable doubt in the minds of the jury the problem is it failed and he is in prison for life no parole and guilty as charged. Now that is the law and sentence so live with it. I just hope he doesn't get to live a full life in prison. BTW he has ZERO appealable issues left so next time you visit your friend take him some more k-y jelly because he goes thru that really fast and uses more and more each time because his bum is stretch farther and farther. I heard he is giving away cartons of smokes to get a day of rest now and then.
WHy

Blanchester, OH

#128 Jan 11, 2014
disagreeing wrote:
<quoted text>
Even though I believe Doan to probably be guilty....A LOT of your statements ARE, IN FACT, HEARSAY. If this case were to be tried in the Supreme Court, Doan would be set free. I'm not saying that he's innocent....All I'm saying is that there REALLY wasn't enough evidence to convict him beyond a reasonable doubt. The only reason that he was convicted was because he was tried in Clinton County with Clinton County jurors. I WISH LIKE HELL they could find Carrie. Breaks my heart to think about her Momma. I wonder if she would agree to an early release for Doan if he would tell the true story, if in fact he knows it..I only say this because there have been other cases where battered women were killed by other men. Just coincidental that a stranger or a crazy aquaintance got to them first.
Cases are NOT TRIED IN SUPREME COURT they are APPEALED and to set your mind at ease he has used up ALL his appeals and his conviction stands. The only way he walks out of prison now is if Carrie WALKS IN and says here I am and you know that is never going to happen. Vinny is at home now and settled in to his new homosexual life until that becomes old and used up then he will be disposed of properly like maybe thrown off a third tier.
WHy

Blanchester, OH

#129 Jan 11, 2014
caveman wrote:
<quoted text>sounds to me like you have a personal problem with vincent. Im just stating facts. oh and its real mature saying that im ignorant because i have my own views. A wise man once told me, "believe none of what you hear and only half of what you see" nobody has proven his guilt beyond a doubt... and
remember karma is a bitch so ya may want to stop wishing harm on other people. It will come back to haunt you...
Idiot if it wasn't PROVED BEYOND A REASONABLE DOUBT HE WOULD HAVE NEVER BEEN CONVICTED. SO your statement is FACTUALLY WRONG. HE WAS CONVICTED AND SENTENCED TO LIFE IN PRISON NO CHANCE OF PAROLE. SO OBVIOUSLY THE JURY SAW EVIDENCE THAT HE IS THE ONE THAT KILLED HER AND HIS DADDY GOT 8 YEARS FOR HELPING DISPOSE OF THE BODY.
hesayusayeesayhe say

Cincinnati, OH

#130 Jan 13, 2014
Sheila wrote:
<quoted text> Shows you what you know, dumb***. Vincent is no one's playmate.
Lemme guess u used to run around with those n people back in your day. By the way whats ur last name
Edith Owens

Cincinnati, OH

#131 Jun 8, 2014
Does the father, Lawrence, still operate the junkyard?
vick doe

Washington Court House, OH

#132 Aug 4, 2014
I was working at a fast food restaurant in Wilmington at the time of this and grew up there, one day during my shift a bad snow storm hit. I seen the lead detective in the drive thu window , like i have many times before, this time he had a lady with him i didn't think a thing of it, until Vince was convicted and i seen the jury. The lady in the car was on that jury. I have never told anybody, because I wasn't a great teenager and had a name in that town, and who would have believes me. I think about it a lot. I believe she is dead, but he should still get a fair trial.&#65279;st deserves a new trial.
Free4

United States

#133 Aug 5, 2014
[Vinny deserves a new trial. Please come forward and help him. "] I was working at a fast food restaurant in Wilmington at the time of this and grew up there, one day during my shift a bad snow storm hit. I seen the lead detective in the drive thu window , like i have many times before, this time he had a lady with him i didn't think a thing of it, until Vince was convicted and i seen the jury. The lady in the car was on that jury. I have never told anybody, because I wasn't a great teenager and had a name in that town, and who would have believes me. I think about it a lot. I believe she is dead, but he should still get a fair trial.&#65279;st deserves a new trial. Vinny needs you to come forward he deserves a fair trial.
kpayne

Tulsa, OK

#134 Feb 24, 2015
Free4 wrote:
[Vinny deserves a new trial. Please come forward and help him. "] I was working at a fast food restaurant in Wilmington at the time of this and grew up there, one day during my shift a bad snow storm hit. I seen the lead detective in the drive thu window , like i have many times before, this time he had a lady with him i didn't think a thing of it, until Vince was convicted and i seen the jury. The lady in the car was on that jury. I have never told anybody, because I wasn't a great teenager and had a name in that town, and who would have believes me. I think about it a lot. I believe she is dead, but he should still get a fair trial.&#65279;st deserves a new trial. Vinny needs you to come forward he deserves a fair trial.
You are a liar! Just like the rest of that white trash family. He killed her no one else had a reason to but him. He is an insecure lil punk. And I am sure daddy and the rest of the trashy family helped cover it up! And the f&*ckin cops. Give her remains back to her family. If he had of treated her right in the first place he wouldn't had to be so jealous and insecure. Guess he learned that from his pos dad.
The Truth

Wilmington, OH

#135 Feb 26, 2015
Carrie was white trash. She was a thief, a drug addict, and a liar. Those who really knew that family can tell you. Her mother was doing prostitution, her sister knocked up in high school. I know of a time when Carrie stole $400 from the cash register where she worked during high school. All these stories of anyone defending her by saying she was such a good person is showing how biased you are. She was trash and who knows where she's at today? Could be alive or dead. The fact that they throw a man away for life without hard evidence is crazy. It doesn't matter what Doan had done in the past, it only matters for this specific case and they should not of given him life. But don't be fooled be "dirty" Debbie, Christina, or Carrie, they are all three disgusting people.
yup

Blanchester, OH

#136 Feb 27, 2015
The Truth wrote:
Carrie was white trash. She was a thief, a drug addict, and a liar. Those who really knew that family can tell you. Her mother was doing prostitution, her sister knocked up in high school. I know of a time when Carrie stole $400 from the cash register where she worked during high school. All these stories of anyone defending her by saying she was such a good person is showing how biased you are. She was trash and who knows where she's at today? Could be alive or dead. The fact that they throw a man away for life without hard evidence is crazy. It doesn't matter what Doan had done in the past, it only matters for this specific case and they should not of given him life. But don't be fooled be "dirty" Debbie, Christina, or Carrie, they are all three disgusting people.
Exactly right.
small-town

Circleville, OH

#137 Apr 24, 2015
Bubba
The ones who can give the info never will. He didn't kill her the man who killed her had already admitted to and was being charged with other murders.
Roberto

Saint Augustine, FL

#138 May 25, 2015
Injured wrote:
Alot of really stupid people in these posts, the school system in that county must be a joke.
I agree that most of these postings are filled with uneducated, ilinformed people but after reading your post, you aren't much better. Just because you live in a large city burrow doesn't mean you automatically have an education.
Roberto

Saint Augustine, FL

#139 May 25, 2015
The Truth wrote:
Carrie was white trash. She was a thief, a drug addict, and a liar. Those who really knew that family can tell you. Her mother was doing prostitution, her sister knocked up in high school. I know of a time when Carrie stole $400 from the cash register where she worked during high school. All these stories of anyone defending her by saying she was such a good person is showing how biased you are. She was trash and who knows where she's at today? Could be alive or dead. The fact that they throw a man away for life without hard evidence is crazy. It doesn't matter what Doan had done in the past, it only matters for this specific case and they should not of given him life. But don't be fooled be "dirty" Debbie, Christina, or Carrie, they are all three disgusting people.
A Vince Down family member
Roberto

Saint Augustine, FL

#140 May 25, 2015
The Truth wrote:
Carrie was white trash. She was a thief, a drug addict, and a liar. Those who really knew that family can tell you. Her mother was doing prostitution, her sister knocked up in high school. I know of a time when Carrie stole $400 from the cash register where she worked during high school. All these stories of anyone defending her by saying she was such a good person is showing how biased you are. She was trash and who knows where she's at today? Could be alive or dead. The fact that they throw a man away for life without hard evidence is crazy. It doesn't matter what Doan had done in the past, it only matters for this specific case and they should not of given him life. But don't be fooled be "dirty" Debbie, Christina, or Carrie, they are all three disgusting people.
A Vince Down family member?
Roberto

Saint Augustine, FL

#141 May 25, 2015
Roberto wrote:
<quoted text>
A Vince Down family member


Vince Doan (my tablet kept changing the spelling of last name when I hit reply)
Spider-Man

Wilmington, OH

#142 Oct 23, 2015
alice kelly wrote:
I don't know if Vincent killed Carrie or not, all I know is that I don't believe this young man had a fair trial. This is the first case that I've known about where testimony was all "hearsay". Why in the world would anyone try a case with nothing but hearsay evidence. If Vincent is guilty then he is where he belongs, but if innocent, he doesn't belong in prison for life. If I were a juror on this case I would have never found him guilty on such flimsy evidence. No body, no forensic evidence, nothing. We're talking about a young man's life here people. He at least deserves a new trial. JMO
You aren't gonna get the hillbillies and crybaby bitc*he$ of blanchester to agree to this. I was younger when this happened, but I remember my dad watching the whole trial and even he said it was ridiculous. No body, no murder weapon, the witnesses that saw her after she was "murdered" were completely ignored. Supposedly there is a video of some of the jury members saying " I knew he was guilty after the first five minutes" well that's a biased jury right there, new trial. They have offered him freedom several times for the location of the body, and he won't take the plea deal. In my opinion, he may have done it, BUT PROVE IT and give the man a fair trial. All the people acting like he's some super killer that can hide a body, no DNA, no murder weapon, those people are crazy.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Lynchburg Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Joe Deters /////// Marvin Lewis Swap ? 6 hr Kisses 2
lovita williams sibcy cline 7 hr Kisses 2
Mollie channel 5 7 hr Kisses 3
News The 25 Most Dangerous Cities in the U.S. Are Mo... (Nov '10) 7 hr Strong Black Man 21,305
Timmy Vogel Fri fuckoffwhore 4
News Lady Gaga at Super Bowl LI (Feb '17) Thu Runner 15
what happened to monica estle? (Feb '17) Thu JusticeDawg 2

Lynchburg Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

Lynchburg Mortgages