Why does Google Mapmaker operate like The Planet of the Apes?

Posted in the Los Altos Forum

UpperFalls

Danville, WV

#1 Nov 6, 2012
Why does Google base its maps on 12-year-old data?

Why did Google create Map Maker if corrections and updates to their obsolete maps were to be denied by Map Maker reviewers, knowing that each denied edit penalizes contributors?

Why are Google Map Maker reviewers and editors so steadfastly arrogant in defending their 12-year-old, obsolete data?

Why does Google continually roll out a fatally-flawed Map Maker to more and more global markets, even as they refuse to fix its long-standing and publically-acknowledged structural defects?

Why does Google Map Maker operate like The Planet of the Apes, where incompetent, arrogant apes lord over oppressed humans?

Judged:

121

103

85

Reply »
Report Abuse Judge it!
muahaha

Watsonville, CA

#2 Nov 12, 2012
well, it's OBVIOUSLY intentional

Judged:

57

50

40

Reply »
Report Abuse Judge it!
UpperFalls

Hewett, WV

#3 Nov 13, 2012
muahaha wrote:
well, it's OBVIOUSLY intentional
Actually, it has to be intentional. Nobody can be that inept. Either that, or Google staff intentionally lie to users. I received this email message from Google on 2012-01-25:

noreply-maps-issues@google.com

Jan 25

Hi,

Your Google Maps problem report has been reviewed, and you were right!

We'll update the map soon and email you when you can see the change.

Thanks for helping us to improve Google Maps!

It's now November 13 and the needed correction to the referenced feature again stands unapproved, despite Google staff acknowledging the error in January. Meanwhile, everyone else, from Mapquest to USA.com has displayed the feature correctly for many months!

That's to say nothing of Google displaying nonsensical magisterial districts in location hierarchies and capriciously making up feature categories like "Built Up Area." What works in India doesn't work in the United States!

Contributors have begged Google to "fix categories" for many, many months. Instead, Google redesigns their Map Maker interface, while ignoring the pleas of their contributors to shore up their infrastructure.

Cynically, Google doesn't even support its own services with its own browser!

I'm beginning to think this is just another in-your-face lie:

"Since the beginning, we’ve focused on providing the best user experience possible. Whether we’re designing a new Internet browser or a new tweak to the look of the homepage, we take great care to ensure that they will ultimately serve you, rather than our own internal goal or bottom line."

What else are those who freely give Google their intellectual property while being abused, to think?

Judged:

101

83

60

Reply »
Report Abuse Judge it!
UpperFalls

Madison, WV

#5 Nov 15, 2012
I added another post here detailing solutions to these issues, but Hearst spiked it. No one has the lost post cached, not Bing, nor Baidu, nor Yandex.

Google, if you want to fix these issues, you know where to find me.
question

Kelowna, Canada

#7 Nov 23, 2012
Why doesn't Google use Esri, the world's single finest GIS vendor, to source the geocoding data for its Google Maps?

Why does Google instead use the unspeakably horrid Microsoft partner, NAVTEQ, to source the geocoding data for its maps?

Judged:

71

53

37

Reply »
Report Abuse Judge it!
AnotherQuestion

Kelowna, Canada

#9 Nov 24, 2012
Isn't it the absolute epitome of irony that Google Map Maker suffers from a lack of adherence to even the most basic standards for localization?

Google should buy a copy of the published standard "Identifying Attributes for Named Physical and Cultural Geographic Features of the United States" and apply those standards to Map Maker. The publication only costs thirty dollars!

Judged:

57

41

26

Reply »
Report Abuse Judge it!
StillAnother

Kelowna, Canada

#10 Nov 25, 2012
Why does Google continually merge trash data from abhorrent junk mailers, overwriting good data in Map Maker? Why doesn't Google instead source quality business listings from directory publishers?

Judged:

44

29

17

Reply »
Report Abuse Judge it!
DoingItForYou

Kelowna, Canada

#11 Nov 26, 2012
It turns out that I can buy the polygon for Upper Falls CDP, West Virginia from Esri for just a few dollars. If I buy it and donate it to you, will you use it?

Judged:

36

23

11

Reply »
Report Abuse Judge it!
StillNotDone

Milton, WV

#12 Feb 10, 2013
Dear Google,

Please comply with your own "Best Practices" by deleting http://www.google.com/mapmaker... and selecting the corresponding City/Town/Village as the Built Up Area.

"It is always advisable to select a larger area like a City/Town/Village as a Built Up Area. This enables (sic) to render the entire City/Town/Village on maps evenly." From http://support.google.com/mapmaker/answer/280... ;

Judged:

13

10

8

Reply »
Report Abuse Judge it!

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Los Altos Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Moderators why have i been shadow banned? (Jun '14) 11 hr Fracking Doodooda 4
My Teen Verbally Abuses Me (Feb '09) Thu tera 112
Caltrain accident Wed Mary J 1
VTA seems to think El Camino Real bus riders ar... (May '12) Feb 25 Jack Offmoore 14
Ron Fleishman is the World's Most Underrated Ph... Feb 25 Etsy 63
I m housewife need home based job Feb 24 Rajveer9033383005 11
Local painter records wedding memories on canvas (Mar '09) Feb 23 calebhart54 3

Los Altos News Video

Los Altos Dating
Find my Match
More from around the web

Los Altos People Search

Addresses and phone numbers for FREE

Personal Finance

Mortgages [ See current mortgage rates ]

NFL Latest News

Updated 7:49 pm PST

ESPN 7:49PM
Raiders to release injury-plagued Branch
Bleacher Report 8:35 PM
Why CB Is San Francisco's Top Non-WR Draft Need
Bleacher Report 9:18 PM
San Francisco 49ers: Should They Sign Reggie Bush?
Bleacher Report11:48 PM
Oakland Raiders Must Cut MJD, Bring Back Darren McFadden
Bleacher Report 9:56 AM
Raiders Must Create Recreate DL by Adding Suh, Hardy