Caledonia man facing 25 years for teen's rape

GENESEO - An ex-Caledonia police officer is facing a maximum of 25 years in prison after a Livingston County Court jury convicted him of first-degree rape and other crimes involving an 18-year-old woman. Full Story
froggy_33_14428

Macedon, NY

#1 Jun 8, 2006
PUT HIM AWAY ,THROW AWAY THE KEY
john

Rochester, NY

#2 Jun 8, 2006
men like him need to be put away for good im glad the law did the right thing.
annie

Rochester, NY

#3 Jun 8, 2006
Oh my god! you mean the cops do things wrong? It's about time! It's about time they get what they deserve. They get away with drinking and driving, drugs, abusing people and rape! This man is suppose to protect us,I'm glad he got caught. That girl did't deserve what he did to her.ROT IN HELL COP!I hope he gets a real nice BUBBA!
Michele

Mclean, VA

#4 Jun 12, 2006
annie wrote:
Oh my god! you mean the cops do things wrong? It's about time! It's about time they get what they deserve. They get away with drinking and driving, drugs, abusing people and rape! This man is suppose to protect us,I'm glad he got caught. That girl did't deserve what he did to her.ROT IN HELL COP!I hope he gets a real nice BUBBA!
She was a whore. She dated older men all the time. she just went after dave. It was all around school she was messing around with him. She never had a problem with it. Dave is a good man. He is caring. what happen should not of happen to him. I know I have knowen him since I was 5 years old.
Joe

Buffalo, NY

#5 Jun 13, 2006
I heard that she was telling people in school weeks after it happened that now she can retire thanks to the caledonia PD
Carl

Pittsford, NY

#6 Jun 16, 2006
I have known Dave for many years. He was always very respectful and would go above and beyond to help people. He risked his life entering a burning house attempting to save a middle aged women.
Dave has a lovely wife and two fine sons. I find it extremely hard to believe Dave wasn't setup on these charges. People naturally want to think the worst and kick a person when he's down. I am truely saddened by this entire event.
shelly

Mclean, VA

#7 Jul 11, 2006
Dave is a kind man. Everyone knows dave as such. You never here bad about him. When someone was in trouble and needed help Dave would be there for anyone.Thats why I don't believe what she is saying. She slept with many older men.
Mel

Avon, NY

#8 Jul 14, 2006
Well; Dave may have had a wonderful family..all the more reason not to screw with a young "whore"...He is not an innocent victim....NOT in the least!!! I am sure the Livingston County Grand Jury considered the evidence and acted correctly in convicting the little RAT.
Crooked cops who think and act like the law applies to every one...except them; should get DOUBLE the sentence...and a BIG BUBBA!!!!
babyeys

Batavia, NY

#9 Nov 14, 2006
If he how was the law a "police officer",rape SOMEONE;wath about the other like juges,deais...etc???!!!
THAS STIL NOT GOIN TO STOP THE CRIME.
candace

Rochester, NY

#10 Jul 13, 2007
Maybe everyone who talks bad about Dave and thinks bad should get to know the girl involved. Take a look at her past, look in to details of that night, then thinks twice about whos really in the wrong.
Rich

Avon, NY

#11 Aug 1, 2007
No matter what profession, doesn't the law still state "innocent until proven guilty"? I have seen this matter before consider the facts, yes it was wrong for him to "allegedly" have sex with her. Was it one time? Did she say no? Did she report the matter to the authorities? I don't know Dave but even Arthur Shawcross was innocent until proven guilty come on people this is 2007. Consider all the arrests you hear about yet never hear the innocent released yet still carry that burden of guilt from the media and peers. This can be you.
Nancy

Rochester, NY

#13 Jan 10, 2008
Regardless of the girls reputation, he is a MARRIED w/children adult and supposed to be protecting our community. It's not the first time the Caledonia Police have had trouble....who's going to police our police?
Allen

Syracuse, NY

#14 Jan 27, 2008
The only way a persons past has anything to do with being raped is if that person has claimed falsely being raped before. But then, remember if it happened to you, you also would have to go through the rectal exam of your pasts, then wonder why you are being accused when you are the victim!
mei

Rochester, NY

#15 Jan 31, 2008
nancy it not an uncommon thing to hear of police officers with girlfriends as well as wives. I do agree with you though that who is going to police our police. Its not just in Caledonia either. Its all over, and its not just the town cops. I dont know either of the parties involved in this particular case, but sometimes the outcome can suprise you.
bbc24

Machias, NY

#16 Mar 29, 2008
What exactly happend here?Sounds like this was consential?
25 years? for what?
sbl

Rochester, NY

#17 Apr 7, 2008
I had known Dave for years also. I also how he acted when he didn't think adults were watching. He could be very cruel to the kids in town. When he was confronted, he was a huge coward. There were two sides to him. And the one was very nasty.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Livonia Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Family court (Dec '11) Dec 3 Heart Broke Mother 38
Dutch Hollow Foods inc. (May '09) Nov '14 Debbie 5
Who do you support for State Senator in New Yor... (Oct '10) Nov '14 I voted Zornow 3
Avon man sues police over excessive force with ... (Jan '08) Oct '14 talon1104 14
Former Caledonia Police Sergeant found guilty o... (Jun '06) Oct '14 Div for youth 10
Theft Oct '14 Concered 1
Man Found Dead on Road in Marion (Dec '06) Oct '14 Cathie 12
Livonia Dating
Find my Match
More from around the web

Livonia People Search

Addresses and phone numbers for FREE

Livonia News, Events & Info

Click for news, events and info in Livonia

Personal Finance

Mortgages [ See current mortgage rates ]

NFL Latest News

Updated 9:16 am PST