Best Pizza in Lexington
Fortune Teller

Lexington, KY

#42 May 23, 2009
I'm new here, but Sir Pizza's off of Nicholasville was pretty good

Louisville, KY

#43 May 26, 2009
if you havent tried Old Chicago, you should. They have a lunch buffet which is a great deal- it comes with a salad and cookies.
Other places I'd recommend are Sontino's on Southland Drive and Joe Bologna's.

Lexington, KY

#44 May 29, 2009
just me wrote:
i cant beleive nobody said ANYTHING about sir pizza. thats the best we drive from frankfort once a week to get that square of heaven. old chicago is great too. i havent been to the one around here. i ate at the one in chicago. but if you want some serious pizza the city chicago is where its at.
Are you serious about the Sir Pizza thing? I'm just asking because around here the overall crapiness of Sir Pizza is kind of a running joke...
Tired of BS

Cincinnati, OH

#45 May 29, 2009
Doc_ wrote:
So, where is the best pizza in Lexington?
You need to get on I75 head north 2 and a half hours to Dayton Go to Cassonoes...Mmmmm Best pizza in town

Franklin, OH

#46 May 29, 2009
sir pizza is pretty good. mellow is bomb, but it takes so long (made to order), you cant be starved when you go. sir pizza is different. never had anything like it EXCEPT in ky. now the problem with sir pizza is, the are kinda ghetto. do not let them deliver your order, becuase they will F*() it up EVERYTIME. so, you have to pick it up or eat there. there is a newer one on new circle road. its clean, nice people. give it a shot you can get an ex lg pep pizza for $16. great for breakfast!!
blue z

Franklin, OH

#47 May 30, 2009
Mellow mushroom... try the GOURMET WHITE pizza . :)

Since: May 09

Location hidden

#48 May 31, 2009
Doc_ wrote:
Thanks for the help! I tried Brooklyn Pizza. It was so so. Better than most places in town.
I love their calzone's...
Jo Smo

Shepherdsville, KY

#49 Jun 6, 2009
Old chicago and Slice of Chicago are the best!

Winchester, KY

#50 Jul 5, 2009
why is there a mad mushroom and a mellow mushroom?
RIP Giovannis

Jeffersonville, IN

#52 Jul 6, 2009
Giovanni's (small chain around KY) was awesome until it turned into Garro's a few months ago. Overpriced and not nearly as good.

Lexington, KY

#53 Jul 11, 2009
No one mentioned Pazzo's? Good pizza and atmosphere. Second choice would be Brooklyn Pizza. I will have to check out Mellow Mushroom.
Jo Smo

Henderson, KY

#54 Jul 11, 2009
Brooklyn pizza is horrible and expensive!

Since: Jul 09

Lexington, KY

#55 Jul 12, 2009
Jo Smo wrote:
Brooklyn pizza is horrible and expensive!
Brooklyn Pizza is not horrible! What's your favorite? Pizza Hut?
Jo Smo

Henderson, KY

#56 Jul 13, 2009
jtizzle wrote:
<quoted text>
Brooklyn Pizza is not horrible! What's your favorite? Pizza Hut?
Haha, not at all it has be Slice of Chicago, and a close second Old Chicago.

Winchester, KY

#57 Jul 14, 2009
cheetos wrote:
<quoted text>
Are you serious about the Sir Pizza thing? I'm just asking because around here the overall crapiness of Sir Pizza is kind of a running joke...
Sir Pizza is the bomb, usually the premises are rundown so the that's a running joke, but the pizza is amazing!

Cici's price can't be beat, it's even cheaper that fixing frozen at home,
Old Chicago has good pizza and if you go at lunch time the buffet is a deal too
pizza freak

Louisville, KY

#58 Jul 29, 2009
Does any like Gario's...I love it!!
pizza eater

United States

#59 Jul 30, 2009
I like Joe Bolognas' pizza myself, miss UNO's too.
Not in WVA

Lexington, KY

#60 Jul 30, 2009
LA Gourmet Pizza is the best. Try the Cheeseria.
pizza anyone

United States

#62 Aug 1, 2009
yeah I loved to get high and eat lots of pizza with my buddies in our underwear.

Fairborn, OH

#63 Aug 2, 2009
I've heard Goodfellas is REALLY good and Puccini's.

I live in Lexinton but drive to Frankfort because Buddy's have the BEST pizza, ever. Sometimes we drive there just for the pizza, LOL.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Lexington Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Bible study rules for public schools proposed (Feb '10) 22 min Wisdom of God 170,509
New Pain clinic in Lexington (Apr '11) 28 min Fed up with dumba... 125
Sarah Huckabee Sanders 33 min fun to watch 1
Can ANY Dem voter explain to us.....Why they vo... 1 hr Two cents 26
Trump sacrifices $$$ cause he loves America 1 hr spanky 12
Obama & Hillary gave port operations to the bro... 1 hr The Truth 1
Running against Kim Davis 1 hr Two cents 113

Lexington Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

Lexington Mortgages