'Moment' in schools banned for now --...

'Moment' in schools banned for now -- Crime, Law and Justice, J...

There are 11 comments on the Chicago Tribune story from May 29, 2008, titled 'Moment' in schools banned for now -- Crime, Law and Justice, J.... In it, Chicago Tribune reports that:

The morning routine at Stevenson High School in Lincolnshire will be 10 seconds shorter Friday after a federal judge banned the moment of silence mandated in public schools in Illinois.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at Chicago Tribune.

Terri

Chicago, IL

#2 May 30, 2008
Just when you thought all this silliness was based on the presidential race, in comes a slider ... Can't people just give these things a rest. Come on folks a moment of silence is not asking you to pray ... I remember in school when we had our "moment" I sort of reflected on whether or not I actually did bring all my homework back ... what ploys people like instituting. Believe me, school can be hectic and a moment of silence was beneficial. I just don't know ... I was always taught to pick my battles carefully and this one just seems so immaterial nonsense. If you don't want to be included -- then just be quiet a minute so everyone else can reflect. Geez ... what's the deal!!!!
Donald Ross

Lake Mary, FL

#3 May 30, 2008
Ban guns and knives. Everyone needs a moment of silence
Bob TG

United States

#4 May 30, 2008
Donald Ross wrote:
Ban guns and knives. Everyone needs a moment of silence
?? Sorry, what is your point. Let's also ban rope, candle sticks, pipe wrenches, and plumbing pipe. Lawmakers need a CLUE!
2bit

Berkeley, IL

#5 May 30, 2008
Donald Ross wrote:
Ban guns and knives. Everyone needs a moment of silence
Yeah but legalize pot right?
Bob TG

Louisville, KY

#6 May 30, 2008
2bit wrote:
<quoted text>
Yeah but legalize pot right?
What are you talking about?
Dana

Chicago, IL

#7 May 30, 2008
I wonder what the students who have to participate in the "moment" think... I know if this was instituted when I was in high school,(1) I'd be annoyed that some time -- any time -- was taken away from learning (yes, I was one of those kids...), and (2) I'd feel exactly like the the girl in the article feels -- the government shouldn't be telling us when and where to think. The whole ten seconds, I'd sit there in resentment. I'm sure, though, a lot of students just see it as less time to listen to the teacher.
Pierre JC

Portland, OR

#8 May 30, 2008
"That's a travesty, in my opinion, for a judge to make a statewide decision based on one student filing in his courtroom, when this would affect millions of students statewide," Lightford said.
No doubt Ms. Lightford is equally upset that bans on interracial marriage were declared illegal by the Supreme Court in 1967 based on on one interracial couple filing in that courtroom, affecting millions of Americans nationwide. She must instead believe that the Loving v. Virginia ruling was a travesty, and that states should have the right to ban interracial marriage.
Unless, of course, she's a hypocrite.
People, keep your idiotic fantasies about your magical, invisible friend out of the government's activities. Why is that so hard to understand?
Tom

Lemont, IL

#9 May 30, 2008
Haven't well-meaning believers sought to have their particular faith become a part everyone else's lives?

When prayer in school was revoked, then the moment of silence mandate was created, it seems, as a fall-back position to begin their struggle once again.

Perhaps we could create a promised land for the true believers of every sect.
2bit

Berkeley, IL

#10 May 30, 2008
Bob TG wrote:
<quoted text>
What are you talking about?
Sarcastic reply to Don R's post
Greg

Killeen, TX

#12 May 31, 2008
I am a Christian and I understand the 'moment of silence'. But making people be quiet for 10 seconds for, in their minds, no reason at all is absolutely ridiculous. They will not rebell because it is just 10 seconds.
Just a suggesstion... There is plenty of opportunities to pray or 'reflect'. I'm not sure about other religions, though. Do it at home, before you get on/off the bus, in the parking lot (risky). Though some students need prayer (LOL), most high school students will say to those who do pray 'Yo man, just do you, unless you clog up the hallway while I'm tryna get to class'.
Greg

Killeen, TX

#13 May 31, 2008
Dana wrote:
I wonder what the students who have to participate in the "moment" think... I know if this was instituted when I was in high school,(1) I'd be annoyed that some time -- any time -- was taken away from learning (yes, I was one of those kids...), and (2) I'd feel exactly like the the girl in the article feels -- the government shouldn't be telling us when and where to think. The whole ten seconds, I'd sit there in resentment. I'm sure, though, a lot of students just see it as less time to listen to the teacher.
I'm with you on that...

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Lake Villa Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Blood in Blood Out: Who was wrong Paco or Miklo? (Jul '07) 18 hr Skina 103
No Stoplight at Grim Road (Jun '17) Mon Antioch Res 9
Have you gotten a red light camera ticket in La... (Feb '13) Jan 15 Earthqueen 178
news update: charles trinchetilla Jan 12 getting back 1
beware of charles trinchetilla III -cat service... Jan 12 getting back 1
What happened to Dr. Dennis Thain? (Apr '17) Jan 6 None 37
The Haunted Gate in Libertyville, IL (Feb '11) Dec 28 Joko 10

Lake Villa Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

Lake Villa Mortgages