Hoosier singer booted from 'Idol'

Hoosier singer booted from 'Idol'

There are 25 comments on the The Indianapolis Star story from Feb 22, 2008, titled Hoosier singer booted from 'Idol'. In it, The Indianapolis Star reports that:

Tom Wood Subaru Visit Tom Wood Subaru at 96th Street and Keystone Avenue for Online Specials on New and Pre-Owned Subaru vehicles.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at The Indianapolis Star.

First Prev
of 2
Next Last
Crazyoldman

Edison, NJ

#1 Feb 22, 2008
Amy is beautiful but she is tone deaf. Kind of important for a singer, she would do better on a modeling show, just don't try and sing
Amerie

Duncan, OK

#4 Feb 22, 2008
She ishorrible and Im glad she is gone
Oldie

Bloomington, IN

#5 Feb 22, 2008
Davis doesnt have the look, she looks a lot older than her age.
Cena

Indianapolis, IN

#6 Feb 22, 2008
Was Randy, Paula, and Simon under the influence when they picked the finalist for Hollywood? All of the singers suck this year. They have a few that are OK, but not star material or anyone that I would want to listen to.I watched it this week and it was torture to hear them. Hopefully this will be the last year because it is getting old.
Marquette

AOL

#7 Feb 22, 2008
While I felt bad for Joanne, I wasn't at all worried that Amy would be the one booted off.
Idol Watcher

Indianapolis, IN

#8 Feb 22, 2008
Go Luke & Amanda!

Since: Feb 08

Woodburn, IN

#9 Feb 22, 2008
Unfortunatley she was not good. She was one of my picks to go home.
Larry Legend

United States

#12 Feb 22, 2008
Amanda should win.
Lighten Up

Houston, TX

#14 Feb 22, 2008
Sparrow wrote:
American Idol, Survivor, Weakest Link, America's Funniest (usually not funny) Home Videos...there is a pattern here.
I am ashamed of amny of my fellow Americans who have become the modern-day equivalent of the Romans cheering on the lions in the Colliseum.
Next, maybe we will have something like Slaughterhouse Scenes or maybe Live! It's Execution Time!
Did many of you get left off the kickball team at recess or something? Is it really enjoyable to watch people suffer or get hurt? Does seeing someelse get ridiculed and embarassed somehow fill a need?
Good Lord - it's a TV show. Lighten up - they knew what they were getting in to.
Hmmmm

Fishers, IN

#15 Feb 22, 2008
PHOENIX wrote:
I'd bang her.
Strangely enough, I don't seem to remember her asking you.
B Monkey Power

New York, NY

#16 Feb 22, 2008
I can't believe you waste your time watching this crap.
Jane

Carmel, IN

#17 Feb 22, 2008
This is the worse group of singers they've ever had on this silly show.
Jane

Carmel, IN

#18 Feb 22, 2008
Cena wrote:
Was Randy, Paula, and Simon under the influence when they picked the finalist for Hollywood? All of the singers suck this year. They have a few that are OK, but not star material or anyone that I would want to listen to.I watched it this week and it was torture to hear them. Hopefully this will be the last year because it is getting old.
Maybe Simon is trying to drive the show into the ground so it gets canceled. He's made his money.
Thomas

Carmel, IN

#19 Feb 22, 2008
Sparrow wrote:
Is it really enjoyable to watch people suffer or get hurt? Does seeing someelse get ridiculed and embarassed somehow fill a need?
Yes, but it would be more enjoyable if the contestants actually got "booted". Seeing Simon with a big boot on kick someone off the stage would be a hoot. I'd laugh and I'd laugh.
trania

Los Angeles, CA

#20 Feb 22, 2008
I loved her!
Marquette

AOL

#21 Feb 22, 2008
Jane wrote:
This is the worse group of singers they've ever had on this silly show.
If you think the show is so silly, then how do you know that this is the "worse" group of singers yet? You must be watching too!
Looks Good

Brownsburg, IN

#22 Feb 22, 2008
Sings Badly. The end.
Idle hands

Vincennes, IN

#23 Feb 22, 2008
Thomas wrote:
<quoted text>
Yes, but it would be more enjoyable if the contestants actually got "booted". Seeing Simon with a big boot on kick someone off the stage would be a hoot. I'd laugh and I'd laugh.
It's been done. It was called the "Gong Show"!
Denise

Hickory Hills, IL

#24 Feb 23, 2008
Wow, everyone is a critic but how many of those of you with your hateful comments would have the guts it took this young woman to stand before millions and pretty much bare her soul? Personally, I couldn't even do karaoke...

God Bless you Amy.

Since: Jan 07

Marion, IN

#25 Feb 23, 2008
Marquette wrote:
<quoted text>
If you think the show is so silly, then how do you know that this is the "worse" group of singers yet? You must be watching too!
HEHEHEHEHEHEHEHEHEHE Booooyaaaaa! Dipstick!

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 2
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Lafayette Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
I'm Thinking of Moving To Lafayette (Jan '13) Sep 16 Droopy 10
News Facebook post announces McCoy's run for prosecutor Sep 7 Yo daddy 1
News Indiana cougar sightings to become common (May '08) Aug 31 hoosier native 131
Metronet Aug '17 new here 1
News After 75 years teens still find second home ata Jul '17 gin0731 1
News Police enforce fireworks laws (Jul '08) Jul '17 Carol 9
Anyone good at making brochures/pamplets? Jun '17 The Guy 1

Lafayette Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

Lafayette Mortgages