Sal's New York Pizza on the beach road

Sal's New York Pizza on the beach road

Posted in the Kill Devil Hills Forum

First Prev
of 3
Next Last

Since: Apr 11

Location hidden

#1 Jun 4, 2012
OK, I'm pretty sure none of us were surprised when Nectar, formerly Krave, formerly pool hall blah-blah-whatever on the beach road near Baum St. closed down as quickly as it did. I mean...come on - vegan cuisine on The Redneck Riviera? Weak business plan. I think someone must've been smoking their inventory instead of just blending it with fruit, saw grass & pure rain water. Yet I'm sure we were equally surprised when a pizza joint took over within (seemingly) minutes of Nectar getting the boot - made of 100% ironically-stitched cowhide, I'm sure. I was hoping to find some competition in the "NY-style pizza" wars that seem to rage here, especially in the off-season as there's (apparently) not much else to do. I'm here to say that the local & established pizza places have absolutely nothing to lose sleep over.

Straight to the point - the pizza is almost indescribably bad. A plain cheese pizza, the barometer of any pizza joint worth its salt (sauce?) should, in all instances, taste better than a frozen platter of red & white garbage from the Food Lion pizza selection. Sal's has failed miserably and gives nothing but ammo to any competitor worried about this place thieving any long-term business. Yeah, they have an arcade. Yes, the place has great location. And a big plus - there's tons more sitting room for customers *cough-Sliceneedstoexpand-coug h*. But if your so-called signature food is an outright culinary failure (It's pizza fer chrissake!) then you deserve to pack up shop & make room for, oh I don't know, another thrift shop maybe?

Too bad for them. They need to improve immediately if they want to stick around here for more than a few months. I hope they do. They have plenty of room and a nice place for families to stretch out & play some games. But if you want a proper pizza you'll need to go somewhere else. I can only imagine how the rest of the menu pans out. And imagine I will. Grade D+
Slice Sucks

Kenly, NC

#2 Jun 4, 2012
If they continue to stay open late night, they will do just fine. Nobody cares what it tastes like at 2 in the morning.
IAMADRINKER

Kill Devil Hills, NC

#5 Jun 5, 2012
so glad they are open late,you know how it is when your hungary after drinking.
Joe

Kill Devil Hills, NC

#6 Jun 5, 2012
SoundToSand wrote:
OK, I'm pretty sure none of us were surprised when Nectar, formerly Krave, formerly pool hall blah-blah-whatever on the beach road near Baum St. closed down as quickly as it did. I mean...come on - vegan cuisine on The Redneck Riviera? Weak business plan. I think someone must've been smoking their inventory instead of just blending it with fruit, saw grass & pure rain water. Yet I'm sure we were equally surprised when a pizza joint took over within (seemingly) minutes of Nectar getting the boot - made of 100% ironically-stitched cowhide, I'm sure. I was hoping to find some competition in the "NY-style pizza" wars that seem to rage here, especially in the off-season as there's (apparently) not much else to do. I'm here to say that the local & established pizza places have absolutely nothing to lose sleep over.
Straight to the point - the pizza is almost indescribably bad. A plain cheese pizza, the barometer of any pizza joint worth its salt (sauce?) should, in all instances, taste better than a frozen platter of red & white garbage from the Food Lion pizza selection. Sal's has failed miserably and gives nothing but ammo to any competitor worried about this place thieving any long-term business. Yeah, they have an arcade. Yes, the place has great location. And a big plus - there's tons more sitting room for customers *cough-Sliceneedstoexpand-coug h*. But if your so-called signature food is an outright culinary failure (It's pizza fer chrissake!) then you deserve to pack up shop & make room for, oh I don't know, another thrift shop maybe?
Too bad for them. They need to improve immediately if they want to stick around here for more than a few months. I hope they do. They have plenty of room and a nice place for families to stretch out & play some games. But if you want a proper pizza you'll need to go somewhere else. I can only imagine how the rest of the menu pans out. And imagine I will. Grade D+
I've eaten the pizza and I think it's great.I've recommended it to others and they agree!It's not greasy like some of the others.You must be their competition(haha).I'll keep going back......
Google "Sal's NY Pizza".They have a few stores in SE Va and their ratings are very good.You lose!
Really

Linden, NC

#8 Jun 5, 2012
Had their pizza. This is not New York pizza. It is horrible. Tastes like pizza you get at the Ocean City boardwalk. If you want to try really good pizza, try Chicago pizza on Wisconsin Avenue in Georgetown, DC. Or alternatively, go to New York for NY pizza or try somewhere else. This place does not have good pizza. But I guess some have opinions as it being good because they do not know any better or have not gone anywhere else except on this Island.
PizzaPro

Moncure, NC

#9 Jun 7, 2012
Food Lion Frozen Pizza ROCKS!!!
wow

Kill Devil Hills, NC

#10 Jun 12, 2012
i had a pizza from Sal's it was really good, if it stays as good as the one i had i will surely go back
Amy Fisher

Pittsboro, NC

#11 Jun 13, 2012
I had the lazagna Friday and thhought it was great sause was just a little sweet but in NY it usually is.
Joey Buttafuoco

Kill Devil Hills, NC

#12 Jun 13, 2012
The stromboli was pretty good.
Southern Shores Res

Windsor, NC

#13 Jun 13, 2012
Red Barron frozen pizza and some hot sauce and you will think you are in NY, you just need to add the rats, the muggers and pollution.
john

United States

#14 Jun 29, 2012
Dear Sals pizza place on the beach. Yesterday you place a brochure on my vehicle will it was parked on private property that is well posted with signs stating no distribution of literature or solicitation or loitering. What part of those signs don't you understand,your brochures just end up being litter. I will collect all that I find and return to you as litter on your property.

Sincerely,

Stay off private property with your litter.
Local n proud of it

Manteo, NC

#15 Jun 29, 2012
I wont be going there any more. Went there Wednesday. Walked in though it looked like it might be a tad dark. After about 1 minute of having to listen to the background ebonics, smelling the stench of the brothers and having to witness them constantly pulling up their pants from around their knees, I left. I won't EVER go back to that...Ubangi hangout. Those sorry a$$ excuses for humans need to carry themselves and their skankie a$$ girlz back to Columbia, Elizabeth City or better yet, the dark continent. Before you haters even open your punk a$$ mouths, know this, things go on here in good ole OBX that law enforcement never knows about and frankly, they don't want to. It's called culling the herd.
Buzzard

Roanoke Rapids, NC

#16 Jun 29, 2012
Tried Sal's today. Pizza was good. Not great, but it will do. The service was horrible. It seemed that English is the second language of the entire staff. Very, very slow. There were just 4 booths with customers and three folks waiting for takeout.(Me being one) They forgot two out of three items for one guy. He left pissed after the long wait, but was refunded the money for the missing items. My order took close to an hour to complete, from calling in to walking out the door.(And I just had a pizza and a side salad)

Gotta pick up your game Sal's, the long wait sucks.
26th Gen Native

Manteo, NC

#17 Jun 29, 2012
Local n proud of it wrote:
I wont be going there any more. Went there Wednesday. Walked in though it looked like it might be a tad dark. After about 1 minute of having to listen to the background ebonics, smelling the stench of the brothers and having to witness them constantly pulling up their pants from around their knees, I left. I won't EVER go back to that...Ubangi hangout. Those sorry a$$ excuses for humans need to carry themselves and their skankie a$$ girlz back to Columbia, Elizabeth City or better yet, the dark continent. Before you haters even open your punk a$$ mouths, know this, things go on here in good ole OBX that law enforcement never knows about and frankly, they don't want to. It's called culling the herd.
Amen my brother. We need to rid our home of all Africans, Mexicans and all other foreigners including yankees and Jews. We haven't needed them in the passed and we don't need them now. They are stealin' our jobs and taintin' our women.
Sandy Semans

Manteo, NC

#18 Jun 29, 2012
26th Gen Native wrote:
<quoted text>
Amen my brother. We need to rid our home of all Africans, Mexicans and all other foreigners including yankees and Jews. We haven't needed them in the passed and we don't need them now. They are stealin' our jobs and taintin' our women.
Agreed. The OBX was much better when it was just the Midgetts, O'Neals, Austins, Ethereidges, Daniels, Tillets, Baums, etc. inbreeding with each other.
26th Gen Native

Manteo, NC

#19 Jun 29, 2012
Sandy Semans wrote:
<quoted text>
Agreed. The OBX was much better when it was just the Midgetts, O'Neals, Austins, Ethereidges, Daniels, Tillets, Baums, etc. inbreeding with each other.
I'm kin to all of them and yes it was much better.
27th Gen Native

Moncure, NC

#20 Jun 29, 2012
Your not a native, your just a local.
NutsCluelessSpam

Louisburg, NC

#21 Jun 30, 2012
I thought "real" NY pizza is SUPPOSED to be greasy?
Cheesy

Manteo, NC

#22 Jun 30, 2012
NutsCluelessSpam wrote:
I thought "real" NY pizza is SUPPOSED to be greasy?
Yep, greasy and thin. Fold in half to eat and it drips all over ya.
Sandy Semans

Manteo, NC

#23 Jun 30, 2012
NutsCluelessSpam wrote:
I thought "real" NY pizza is SUPPOSED to be greasy?
Yup, just like real New Yorkers.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 3
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Kill Devil Hills Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Search Ongoing For Missing Kayaker In Albemarle... (Apr '14) Oct 16 Bradley gunners pal 23
Drug dealers in Nags Head (Mar '12) Oct 12 wtf 27
Joseph Pledger (Dec '16) Sep 26 Shooby 10
okay so who served missy marvin last (Apr '09) Sep 19 iamali 46
Faking a service animal (Nov '16) Sep '17 Yankee 16
too many tourists Sep '17 Dicky 3
adult fun (Mar '14) Sep '17 Parent 13

Kill Devil Hills Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

Kill Devil Hills Mortgages