A 'hell on Horton Road' for family of...

A 'hell on Horton Road' for family of murder victim

There are 1123 comments on the Newsday.com story from Feb 14, 2006, titled A 'hell on Horton Road' for family of murder victim. In it, Newsday.com reports that:

It hardly matters anymore to Richard and Victoria Tinyes that the Golubs will be leaving Horton Road in Valley Stream." /> Long Island A 'hell on Horton Road' Pending sale of the home of their daughter's killer ...

Join the discussion below, or Read more at Newsday.com.

Since: Feb 09

Valley Stream, NY

#22 Feb 19, 2009
I would be very interested in speaking with any of you privately about your posts!!! I have asked Chino above wih no answer. Long Island Chick, you seem to have a lot to discuss. Could you email me at [email protected] so we could talk more in depth than on a forum. I would be interested in hearing what else you have to say.

Plainview, NY

#23 Feb 20, 2009

Since: Mar 09

Valley Stream, NY

#24 Mar 1, 2009
On behalf of the Tinyes Family, Kelly's parents Richie & Vicki, & Kelly's brother Richie & his wife, we would all like to invite family, friends and supporters of Kelly Ann Tinyes to a balloon memorial on Kelly's birthday Thursday March 5th at 4:00 pm at Kelly's home 101 Horton Road in Valley Stream. This is a tradition we have been sharing with family, friends & neighbors throughout the last twenty years. This year we would like to open the invition to whomever would like to join us. Though Kelly had a short life, we would like to celebrate the love, life & memories we all share. Please open the invitation to anyone you'd like and forward this forum as well. 20 years later Kelly will never be forgotten and will always be in our hearts. Help us keep her memory alive!

March 5th 4:00 p.m. The Tinyes House 101 Horton Road Valley Stream Please bring your own balloons to let go in memory of Kelly Ann Tinyes.

Mahwah, NJ

#25 Mar 2, 2009
This case was just re-opened by the Nassau County DA. I read that new DNA techniques were being used. You'd think they wouldn't re-open the case unless they had something pretty specific.

I followed this case very closely and watched the trial on TV. I live a few towns away and have always wondered what really went on in the basement that afternoon and who (else) was involved.

Valley Stream, NY

#26 Mar 3, 2009
Loudmouth wrote:
https://www.bluffmagazine.com/ players/john-golub/36242/playe r-profile.asp
Johnny Gloves!!!!
Still looks like a real wise a**ed pecker head who needs a beating.
Kellys Cousins


#27 Mar 3, 2009
I would once again like to open the invitation to join us at Kelly's balloon ceremony March 5th at Kelly's home 101 Horton Road at 4:00 p.m. Now that it has been made public that the case has been reopened we need your support now more than ever. If anyone out there has any information at all about Kelly's death and the involvement of others, as little as you may think it is, please contact Kelly's tip line at 5 1 6 - 8 7 0 - 2 8 1 3. Once again as i said before although Kelly had a short life, we would like to celebrate the love, life & memories we all share. We are hoping after 20 long years Kelly & her family will finally have thier justice. We will continue to keep her memory alive and hope you can join us.
*Reminder: Thursday March 5th Kelly's Birthday at 101 Horton Road in Valley Stream. Please bring your own balloons to let go in Kelly's honor & memory!

Jamaica, NY

#28 Mar 3, 2009
I hope now that they have reopened this case, they will put this guy in jail. Something was obviously not right in the Golub family. The parents of these boys sound as if they have absolutely no sympathy for the victim their sons murdered. No wonder their children are so psycho.

Brooklyn, NY

#29 Mar 3, 2009
Its sad that it took 20 years for ths poor kids story to be heard. You have to wonder if John Golub is the focus of this new reopening or someone else? Either way I say Kathleen Rice is a champion and gives me hope that some law makers ane politians arent looking for the easy way out, and will go the extra mile.
All American Drive Inn

Brooklyn, NY

#30 Mar 6, 2009

Ths above website is a chat room/forum totally dedicated to Kelly Tinyes and her justice, please visit and share your opinions and thoughts on her story. There are people talking from all over the world about this girl, not just from Long Island

All American Drive Inn

Brooklyn, NY

#31 Mar 6, 2009
New forums have turned up, please view them all on this one link.


Oak Ridge, NJ

#32 Mar 7, 2009
Long Island Chick wrote:
It entrages me to know that John Golub was directly or indirectly involved in Kelly Ann Tinyes death and yet he was not prosecuted for his involvement. I know this case very well because my father was a Nassau County detective. In doing extensive research on this case, I understand that John was not prosecuted because the Nassau County police Department could not tie John to the crime. They had no physical or DNA evidence to prove he was directly involved in Kelly's murder. None of John Golub's hair, skin fragments, blood, sweat, semen, or finger prints were recovered from Kelly's body. As much as the investigators working on this case wanted to prosecute him, they simply couldn't because they had no substancial evidence against him. The only evidence they had was phone records showing that a call was made from the Golub home(made most likely by John) to the Tinyes home in an attempt to lure Kelly into the Golub home. It is now almost 20 years later and john continues to show a pattern of perverse sexually behavior. While john wasn't prosecuted for Kelly's death in 1989, there is a note on his criminal record that he was questioned in this murder. I don't think there is a stue fo limitations in 1st degree murders in the state of new York. If John's recent behavior teaches us anything, it teaches us that this person has engaged in perverse sexual behavior against woman in the past and he continues to do so. Therefore, it should provide a pathway for the nassau County DA's office to go back and pursue a conviction against him for his involvement in the Kelly Tinyes murder. He was an accomplice! His behavior in the years after the murder show that he is a sexual deviant. These actions set a precedence in a court of law and provide justification for prosecuting him for his involvement in Kelly's murder. intil there nassau DA's office gets off their lazy asses and decide to move ahead with pressing charges agaibnst john Golub, there will be no justice for Kelly Tinyes!!!
There is no statute of limitations on murder in the state of New York. Since it has been 20 years the only thing that they would be able to charge him with is murder and they have to make sure that they have enough evidence to get a conviction. His current and previous deviant sexual behavior is not relevant to Kelly's murder. It is important to understand that if they bring John Golub to trial and they do not have anything to link him to Kelly's murder he will not be convicted and they will not be able to try him again. I believe that in order for their to be justice for Kelly the people who know what happened that day need to come forward and tell their stories. Maybe after 20 years someone will be tired of keeping a secret.

To the Tinyes family: My heart goes out to you. I hope that Kelly gets the justice that she deserves and you get the closure that you need.
Long Island Chick

Brooklyn, NY

#33 Mar 7, 2009
Hi watcher and thanls for responding to my post. I realize that John's recent crimes have nothing to do with Kelly Ann's murder. However, I am sure that if the Da does bring John Jay to trial there will expert pyschologists testifying on behalf of the prosecution, and giving the jury some insight into John Jay Golub's psychological makeup and how he thinks and functions as a human. I am wondering if there is some loophole in the law or just someway to show that his behavior ovver recent years lends itself to showing just what type of a person John Jay Golub is. I know the law fairly well and I realize it is a stretch. I do realize that if the DA goes to trial this is it. They have but this one chance to get hom for murder. I agree that in order to convict him they need very strong evidence. I do believe that someone who knew what happened that day will 'make a deal' and talk.


Oak Ridge, NJ

#34 Mar 7, 2009
Long Island Chick - I have been fascinated by this case since 1989, cases like this are the reason i went to law school. I am glad to see that DA Rice reopened this case because I always felt that John Jay helped commit this murder. I was reading through the posts on this sight and i think I read one that said your father was a former Nassau County Detective? I wanted to ask you if you know why the detectives disregarded the statement of the six year old girl who said she looked through the basement window and saw John Jay and his two friends dancing around Kelly with Knives. From what I have read about this little girl it seems like she was able to tell them things that weren't published and she knew about wounds on Kelly's body that she would have know way of knowing about unless she had seen them. What this little girl not believable?

Since: Mar 09


#35 Mar 8, 2009
Hi Folks, firstly thank you to All american Drive inn for putting up that link, and thanks to Rocky for letting us know about this board.

The feelings expressed here are the same as on our board, perhaps this little girls evidence should be looked at again, depending how much she remembers accuratley.
Talk to you later,

Since: Mar 09


#36 Mar 8, 2009
Hello everyone. I also want to say a special thankyou to 'All American drive inn' and ovcourse to rocky & LongIsland chick for helping us with intense research and past history. We have been rehashing this tragic case for quite some time now, and it is great to hear from other people who have the compassion to take some time out of their own life and think about Kelly.

I agree with what is said about Jaquilyn De luca, not her real name, the little girl, something always told me, perhaps its a 'feeling' I should say, that just rings true to me.

I wonder what evidence they have on John Jay. I try to keep an update on this case every day.
I'll keep my post general and look forward to hearing your opinions.
Thake care

Gatineau, Canada

#37 Mar 8, 2009
Hi Folks
I also wanted to thank you also All American Drive Inn for putting up a link to our web site, and thanks to Rocky for giving us the info about this site. Long Island Chick she has been a huge help to us.
You all make some very good points here.
I have always thought from the beginning that Robert did not acted alone, and always felt that John Jay was involved in Kelly’s murder.
Also call it a gut feeling if you will, but I think that Robert & JJ parents were aware that Kelly’s body was in the basement and had every intention to help their sons dispose of her body that night. But their plan backfired with so many neighbours and friend looking for Kelly that night it would have been impossible to take her out of the house.
Don’t get me wrong here, Im not saying that I think that John & Victoria Golub were involve in the murder in any way nor do I think that they were home when it happen. They both had plenty of witnesses that proved they were not at home when the murder occurred. But I do think that they were told about it when they got home from work that day.
Just their reaction to when the police found Kelly’s body in their basement speaks volumes, if that would have been me I would have been freaking out. The lack of remorse and emotion from the entire Golub family member is right down creepy. The fact that they still harass the Tinyes family till this day shows their total lack of respect and care for what happen to Kelly.

Staten Island, NY

#38 Mar 8, 2009
if there is no DNA evidence linking the brother to the crime, then why are people insisting he was involved in the actual murder?

Staten Island, NY

#39 Mar 8, 2009
this reminds me of the OJ case, i remember there were people insisting OJ didnt commit the crimes alone, people would say he couldnt have killed 2 people, i say, why not? when a person is enraged they are perfectly capable of a murderous rampage..
Better late than never

Brooklyn, NY

#40 Mar 8, 2009
Long Island Chick, you're going to get your wish and well deserved at that.
If your dad was really in law enforcement in 89 you know that was a witness to the murder. New DNA technology is going to put that little s**t behind bars right next to his sicko brother!.
He won't be bothering any waitresses too much longer because his arrest for murdering Kelly Ann is inevitable.
Looking up at the sky .... Thank you Lord! Thank You
All American Drive Inn

Plainview, NY

#42 Mar 9, 2009

How does it feel to be bullied Johnny??

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Island Park Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Katie Flynn's family to appear on Oprah's show (May '07) Dec 3 kgcincy 205
News Cops: Latin King slain in Queens (Apr '07) Dec 1 KING LITE 328
US Hells angels war on American women and child... (Feb '10) Nov 30 GodofUSAHellsangels 305
Alpha Omega Theta Fraternity (Aug '09) Nov 30 Douglas Sprague 19
Harveys Lake Pa Nov 30 charly 1
Alpha Sigma Phi (Mar '09) Sep '16 Ol Satchmo 573
News Most Nassau beaches reopened after closures (Jun '08) Aug '16 Island Parker 10

Island Park Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

Island Park Mortgages