'American Idol' contestant Pia Toscan...

'American Idol' contestant Pia Toscano returns to New York City after surprise elimination

There are 17 comments on the NY Daily News story from Apr 11, 2011, titled 'American Idol' contestant Pia Toscano returns to New York City after surprise elimination. In it, NY Daily News reports that:

Ousted 'American Idol' favorite Pia Toscano packed her bags and headed back to NYC after her surprise elimination from the show on Thursday - still all smiles.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at NY Daily News.

Otis B Driftwood Jr

East Quogue, NY

#1 Apr 11, 2011
She's from Howard Beach? Wow, someones gonna' get kneecapped for this one, or end up with a horse's head in their bed!
Ozzie Guillen

Springfield, IL

#2 Apr 11, 2011
She's hot!! I wanna banger in homeplate of US Cell field.
Ken

Parrish, FL

#3 Apr 12, 2011
hopefully she will start doing porn films.

“Go Ahead Liberal, Make My Day”

Since: Dec 07

Florida...home of Trump

#4 Apr 12, 2011
who cares
liner

Bronx, NY

#5 Apr 12, 2011
Otis B Driftwood Jr wrote:
She's from Howard Beach? Wow, someones gonna' get kneecapped for this one, or end up with a horse's head in their bed!
Or better yet.......in a burlap bag on Fire Island.
Jessica

Laval, Canada

#6 Apr 12, 2011
She was the absolute winner of the show in my opinion !!Something just looks shady to me ? Could American Idol be behind the vote and not the public?Makes ya wander..........

“Go Ahead Liberal, Make My Day”

Since: Dec 07

Florida...home of Trump

#7 Apr 13, 2011
Jessica wrote:
She was the absolute winner of the show in my opinion !!Something just looks shady to me ? Could American Idol be behind the vote and not the public?Makes ya wander..........
read a book
Long Island BOATER

White Plains, NY

#8 Apr 13, 2011
liner wrote:
<quoted text>
Or better yet.......in a burlap bag on Fire Island.
The bodies are NOT on Fire Island. They are on a strip of land (barrier beach) between Long Island and the Fire Island INLET.
Jessica

Laval, Canada

#9 Apr 13, 2011
Guinness Drinker wrote:
<quoted text>
read a book
Do you read much GUINNESS "DRINKER" ??

“Go Ahead Liberal, Make My Day”

Since: Dec 07

Florida...home of Trump

#10 Apr 14, 2011
Jessica wrote:
<quoted text> Do you read much GUINNESS "DRINKER" ??
as much as I can; don't want to end up like most who think 'American Idol' is entertainment.
Billy B

Fort Collins, CO

#11 Apr 14, 2011
Its not a singing contest its a twitter facebook contest.
shameless-li

Denver, CO

#12 Apr 14, 2011
Guinness Drinker wrote:
<quoted text>
as much as I can; don't want to end up like most who think 'American Idol' is entertainment.
really, what are they thinking?
everyone knows that "dancing with the stars" is the only real entertainment on tv.
Jessica

Laval, Canada

#13 Apr 14, 2011
I enjoy the music ! What's wrong with that?? Who wouldn't want to be a singer??

Since: Mar 11

Merrick, NY

#14 Apr 14, 2011
The whole world is crumbling around us and people in record numbers are watching this thing called "American idol"? When is it on next?

“Go Ahead Liberal, Make My Day”

Since: Dec 07

Florida...home of Trump

#15 Apr 18, 2011
Jessica wrote:
I enjoy the music ! What's wrong with that?? Who wouldn't want to be a singer??
Nothing's wrong. The problem is watching a young talented person get berated by four, untalented ones. J-Blow has talent ? cripes, give us a break

“Go Ahead Liberal, Make My Day”

Since: Dec 07

Florida...home of Trump

#16 Apr 18, 2011
shameless-li wrote:
<quoted text>
really, what are they thinking?
everyone knows that "dancing with the stars" is the only real entertainment on tv.
close, but the show needs improvement. Add a pole and watch Kirstie Alley jump and pull the entire building down.
liner

Bronx, NY

#17 Apr 18, 2011
Long Island BOATER wrote:
<quoted text>
The bodies are NOT on Fire Island. They are on a strip of land (barrier beach) between Long Island and the Fire Island INLET.
Sorry, to us mainlanders everything over there is Fire Island.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Howard-Beach Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Jennifer Aniston and Justin Theroux split house... 3 hr now you know 1
News Rally backs student in Malcolm X sweater clash ... 5 hr Fulton Telese 3
lady Feb 19 power trip 1
News Jennifer Aniston and Justin Theroux's long dist... Feb 19 Jennifer OVERLOAD 1
The News Today, The way I see it. Feb 19 Bobo Brazil 4
News Gottis are Goin' Down Da Tubes (Jun '08) Jan 31 WATCHING LIVONIA 40
News Queens jogger murder suspect allegedly told pol... (Apr '17) Apr '17 china white 1

Howard-Beach Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

Howard-Beach Mortgages