I was expecting better food from Flaherty's in Honeoye Falls!

Posted in the Honeoye Falls Forum


Rochester, NY

#1 Mar 16, 2011
Expected better food from them. The menu didn't impress. For a "Irish Pub" they had way too many pasta dishes. The Oscar dish was frenched. Since when do you French a Oscar dish? The béarnaise sauce was also watery and actually tasted like French(very lemony).The fries were served in a boat dish. Why? The portion was also way too small. The French dip was a little short on beef and would have been better with melted cheese and the roll grilled. The servers also should check on drinks more often.

Honeoye Falls, NY

#2 Mar 20, 2011
Yikes, my experience could not be more different. Iíve visited Flahertyís three times now. Iíve ordered the Shepardís Pie, a Corn beef and cabbage special, and a Chicken Caesar salad. In each case the dish was excellent, and beyond the norm. The servers were all pleasant and prompt, without being overbearing. Finally the beer selection is wonderful, with a good variety of local Micro-brews to compliment the big boy brands. Itís hard to believe we are discussing the same establishment. Overall, the food, ambiance, and service have definitely met my expectations each time.

Rochester, NY

#3 Mar 26, 2011
i agree with you. we weren't impressed at all. the waitress screwed up our drinks and the food was dry and bland. the buffolo bites were over fried and dry grease balls. the chicken parm had barely any sauce and i needed a lot of water to wash it down. they forgot the baked beans with the pulled pork. The pulled pork was smaller than my kid's portions. my son's grilled cheese was rock hard and the bread was too dark. we went saturday for lunch. it wasn't busy and they couldn't get it right. it was over priced, too. we didn't even get any bread with the entrees. we won't be back. on the plus side, the building is clean and new. that's about it.

Lima, NY

#4 May 20, 2011
Oscar dish was frenched. Since when do you French a Oscar dish? The béarnaise sauce was also watery and actually tasted like French(very lemony)
Same here. I ordered the veal Oscar. Oohh boy dripping in water! I thought the veal must have been frozen in a ton of ice then thawed but not drained. Could have been veal soup.
Will try again though. Not too many places to go in HF.

Rochester, NY

#5 May 31, 2012
F rating. Went to Flags five times now and still have been unable to get a good meal. Service is fairly good. Prices are a bit high and drinks are over priced. Good thing there is another bar and grill in the town which has "The Best" food around. I was so surprised when I ate at the Brewery, the food is delicious, drinks are reasonably priced, and a nice atmosphere. There is also another bar in town called Cosmos. Good priced drinks and decent lunch mostly for the working crowd, burgers, ect.

Flags: F
Brewery: A+
Cosmos:(cheap drinks) B

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Honeoye Falls Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Cult (Sep '07) Tue Agrant 23
Congratulations Hollie Rider and Josh Jimerson ... Dec 15 Bonnie 13
3 Teens Arrested In West Seneca Murder (Jul '07) Dec 15 Ezra 162
Governor Issues Tractor Trailer Ban Due To... Dec 11 F U FUBO 2
LA Fitness buys 2 Rochester Athletic Club sites (Dec '13) Dec 8 delwin11 7
Above the law Dec 2 Baboon 2
Dutch Hollow Foods inc. (May '09) Nov '14 Debbie 5

High Wind Warning for Monroe County was issued at December 25 at 12:19AM EST

Honeoye Falls Dating
Find my Match
More from around the web

Honeoye Falls People Search

Addresses and phone numbers for FREE

Honeoye Falls News, Events & Info

Click for news, events and info in Honeoye Falls

Personal Finance

Mortgages [ See current mortgage rates ]

NFL Latest News

Updated 9:31 pm PST