Verdict is in on Judge Ettore Simeone...

Verdict is in on Judge Ettore Simeone's behavior

There are 45 comments on the Newsday story from Jul 15, 2007, titled Verdict is in on Judge Ettore Simeone's behavior. In it, Newsday reports that:

You'd think Conservative Family Court Judge Ettore Simeone, already censured by the state, would be on his very best behavior in his bid for re-election. But the judge is already tripping over his own Web site ...

Join the discussion below, or Read more at Newsday.

First Prev
of 3
Next Last

Mastic, NY

#43 Feb 25, 2008
Governments Enemy wrote:
<quoted text>And you have been a particpant in his courtroom.He is one of the few good judges.
I have been a particpant in his court room and let me tell you, he is not about fathers rights. He gave custody to my ex-wife because she was a stay at home mother when the woman was committed to south oaks 2 times that I know. She even admitted to work from home and never paid taxes on what she made. You tell me if that is about father rights.
Laurie Iannucci

Palm Harbor, FL

#44 Jun 27, 2009
I've just recently become aware of Judge Simeone censure, as I moved from NY in 2003.
I was in his courtroom, concerning my son, several times starting in 1998, continuing through 2001. This Judge was compassionate, caring and took a real interest in these children.
As I had the opportunity to sit in his courtroom so frequently, I was able to see how he dealt with these troubled children. He had only their best interests at heart. His personal life is just that...personal. It's no one else's business.
Whatever he did while he was sitting on that bench was totally professional and dealt with each individual case on its own merit. From where I stood, I could see no influence from any other people in his courtroom. When he made a decision, it was his decision, always a very fair one.
At that time in my life, during those terrible days, I know he saved my son's life and I will always be grateful to him for that.

Long Beach, NY

#45 Apr 19, 2010
noticed those that bashed him gave random statements, as to their dislike/ disaproval of him while those in support provided work related criteria , its quite sad that a MAN of this CALIBER should be so horribly DEFAMED, quite honestly its SAD what the public media has become a forefront for airing peaples DIRTY LAUNDRY & everyone has dirty laundry I surely HOPE or you are not HUMAN, public HUMILIATION for private indiscretions that have NO PLACE in the public media , this world has MAJOR issues to be dealt with . he sounds like quite an upstanding COMPASSIONATE PROFFESSIONAL BEING.

Dover, NJ

#47 Oct 14, 2010
GovernmentsEnemy wrote:
<quoted text>Judge Hertha Trotta of 1st District holds on to cases she when she knows shes biased against the defendant.I see no difference here.Just remember,Innocent till proven guilty.
Spoken like someone who had a bad day in court. The woman is 110% fair AND 200% unbiased.

Separate fact from hype before you type
Dave Holbrook NY

Plainfield, NJ

#48 Jun 26, 2013
Have had several dealings with this man and have found him to be honest and professional in every way.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 3
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Holtsville Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Murder 1995 - 1996 (Mar '07) 9 hr Joe 29
News Charges Filed In LI Chimney Sweep Scam (Feb '06) Aug 29 Chimneyman39 331
News Petition drive underway to reopen Roberto Cleme... Aug 29 clean it up Angie 6
Heroin Overdosed Centereach High School (Jan '09) Aug 28 Relic 36
News After officer's wake, cops nab drug suspect (Mar '09) Aug 26 Go Blue Forever 212
As we can C Newark NJ Hells angels just cowar... (Apr '13) Aug 26 Ends in a vowel 13
News Islip ex-commish Joe Montuori Jr., aide plead g... Aug 25 make them pay 2

Holtsville Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

Holtsville Mortgages