Woman files wrongful-death suit over bungled abortion at Hialea...

Belkis Gonzalez, 43, of Miramar, was arrested Tuesday and charged with practicing medicine without a license and tampering with evidence, both felonies, the Miami-Dade State Attorney's Office said.

[pro- life person]

I don't think this doctor should practice medicine however a wrongful death lawsuite???? Wasn't the patient killing the baby in the first place???

OK *that* makes sense, get rich off the death of a baby that was not wanted.

[Gods warrior]

Ghetto lottery.

[Redneck]

Sycloria Williams got precisely what she wanted.
Now she wants a big time bonus. What a slut!!

[newsie]

gettin an abortion does not mean, giving birth to a breathin baby and throwing it away, that to me is murder. shut this place down and arrest the staff

[RED BARON]

I hope this lady doesn't win her case. Otherwise, every woman seeking an abortion will try to sue for emotional trauma after their pregnancy is terminated. Yet one more reason why late term abortions should not be allowed except under extreme circumstancs.

[FARTY MARTY]

KEEP THESE SCUMBAGS AWAY FROM ME

[Seriously]

This is the height of irony. It's disgusting! They never should have done an abortion at 23 weeks. Anyone knows babies born at that stage can survive. But for this woman who did not want a baby to now claim "wrongful death" is pathetic. She's clearly just trying to get money because she thinks she can. Go get a job and pay your taxes and use birth control, for god's sake!

[Saddened]

I've tried to adopt an infant for two years. It's sad that all of these deaths (abortions) take place when there are people like me who would have LOVED to have adopted the baby.

[Marine Corp Pat]

Abortion is legal, and that will never change. President Obama said it best: we should always protect a womans choice while finding ways to lessen the number of abortions.
I agree with that.

For the pathetic people on here talking about the young woman being from the ghetto; cowards knock people in poverty and there are a lot of rich women that have abortions.

[MyPerspective]

Marine Corp Pat wrote:

Abortion is legal, and that will never change. President Obama said it best: we should always protect a womans choice while finding ways to lessen the number of abortions.
I agree with that.
For the pathetic people on here talking about the young woman being from the ghetto; cowards knock people in poverty and there are a lot of rich women that have abortions.

So you agree with this woman seeking a wrongful death claim?

[I say]

Marine Corp Pat wrote:

Abortion is legal, and that will never change. President Obama said it best: we should always protect a womans choice while finding ways to lessen the number of abortions.
I agree with that.
For the pathetic people on here talking about the young woman being from the ghetto; cowards knock people in poverty and there are a lot of rich women that have abortions.

Yeah, but they don't try to sue afterwards.

Keep drinkin' the kool-aid, you tard.

[Fed Up]

They should all ROT in PRISON! They ALL killed the baby!!! If any judge lets ALL of them get away this, this Country will become worse then it already is...Send ALL Brazilian people and any other non-american back where they came from and let them kill each other instead of Americans!

[AUFire]

Thet woman that was pregnant and the doc ought to be in jail for the rest of their lives....after that, hopefully there will be a guy in a red suit with a pitchfolk and horns waiting for them...

They are both evil.

[stinky]

Someone needs to throw her in the trash. Deport this POS now.

[Church Lady]

It's a no win situation for all involved. KEEP YOUR PANTIES ON!

[Max]

This case will hopefully put the abortion issue in the spotlight, resulting in much needed legal clarifications.

The basis of the lawsuit defies logic. The woman went to the clinic specifically to abort - have killed - her 6 month fetus. Indeed, that is what happened. Now she screaming murder.

This can only mean that if a doctor kills the fetus in the womb, it is a legal abortion and everyone is happy. No crimes, no malpractice. But if the fetus exits the womb alive, then not making every effort to keep it alive, even though that was not the mother's intent, is cold calculated murder.

It makes no sense in any context - legal, ethical or moral. None.

[Max]

newsie wrote:

gettin an abortion does not mean, giving birth to a breathin baby and throwing it away, that to me is murder. shut this place down and arrest the staff

Let make your point another way. You are saying that if the fetus is intentionally killed in the womb, it is a legal abortion. But if the fetus actually exits the womb not dead, then not making every effort to keep it alive is murder.

That makes no sense legally, ethically, or morally.

[So Serious]

I am not saying that the baby should have been killed that way, but are you serious? You go down to the abortion clinic to terminate a pregnancy, in other words kill the baby, and now you are filling a wrongful death suite. You were going to kill the baby anyways. Thats what you went there for.

[JTT]

How can they say that this was a "bungled abortion", when they accomplished their mission?

[Max]

Marine Corp Pat wrote:

Abortion is legal, and that will never change. President Obama said it best: we should always protect a womans choice while finding ways to lessen the number of abortions.
I agree with that.
For the pathetic people on here talking about the young woman being from the ghetto; cowards knock people in poverty and there are a lot of rich women that have abortions.

The issue here is not whether abortion is legal or not. The issue here is WHEN abortion is legal, that is at what point, and under what circumstances, does abortion become murder?

Much of the abortion debate has centered around the ethical controversy of when does a fetus become a human being. In later term abortions, which the pro choice fanatics insist is guaranteed by Roe v Wade, the ethical question becomes life in the womb versus life out of the womb since a 6 month fetus can, and has, become a living human being upon exiting the womb.

This case renders the issue in the most simplest of terms. The woman wanted the fetus killed, as long as the killing was done in the womb. But since it wasn't done in the womb, she is now claiming someone murdered her child. At best that should pose a serious ethical dilemma, but more importantly, it is a vexing legal one.