Who has the best pizza in Herkimer?
pizza eater

Nedrow, NY

#154 Dec 15, 2009
The best pizza in the area is flatiron pizza in Ilion. My family and i have been eating their since they opened a year ago and have never had a bad one.
Uhhhhh

West Monroe, NY

#155 Dec 15, 2009
pizza eater wrote:
The best pizza in the area is flatiron pizza in Ilion. My family and i have been eating their since they opened a year ago and have never had a bad one.
Title of topix is best pizza in Herkimer, not Ilion. And just so everyone knows, Flat Iron Pizza is same as Yetty's - not good. Yetty's used to have the best pizza in town (about 40+ years ago), but after we moved back to the area 25 years ago, ordered a Yetty's pizza and ended up throwing it away. One of the worst pizzas I have ever had. My kids thought I was crazy when I told them Yetty's used to be the best!
I Heard

New York, NY

#156 Dec 16, 2009
Ringo wrote:
Brian's is the best. Great Food, GREAT VARIETY, and very reasonable prices. Brian Carney is a hard worker as well as the rest of the people that work there. I have always been treated like a king there and never got a bad meal. It hasn't been remodeled since the 80's but then again compare the quality and quantity with any other place in town. I will take Brian's.
I heard Brian is currently remodeling. I drove past the other night and the outside is painted with Christmas lights up--the only on Main Street. Is it true that he is remodeling the entire place?
Jen

Cicero, NY

#158 Dec 24, 2009
herkimer resident wrote:
Tonys, That's Amore, Salvatore Sorrentos , Pizza boys, Vinny, or Yettys?
Tonys in Herkimer is THE BEST all over...
Traveler

Lewiston, ME

#159 Nov 6, 2010
I know this is an old topic, but I figured I would add my two cents...

I haven't tried Vinny's at all and it's been a long time since I ordered a pricey pizza from Yetty's, but my favorites are Brian's and Tony's...but only when Tony's uses the better-tasting sausage.(They used a lousy sausage on one of my pizzas.) I don't care for Pizza Boys or Pizza Hut at all. That's Amore's pizza was a rip-off since I paid for four toppings and I had to look hard to see everything except the skimpy amount of pepperoni, but I liked their crust and sauce.(Their greens and Gold Rush wings were VERY good.)

Lombardo's in Ilion is also very good.
Losurdos

Canastota, NY

#160 Nov 6, 2010
I miss Losurdo's.
bart the hero

Herkimer, NY

#162 Nov 6, 2010
sorrento's in Ilion
Kortland koward

United States

#163 Nov 6, 2010
first amendment wrote:
between my moms legs
must be you just getting home from your third shift job wiping elderly ass.
Kortland koward

United States

#165 Nov 6, 2010
first amendment wrote:
whats ur saying all the time stay on topic whats that have to do with best pizza u troll? u spit or swallow boy?
blah blah blah blah...
Kortland koward

United States

#166 Nov 6, 2010
any time you think you got the balls to spit in my face, you got the email address. take a chance. you might get lucky to stay out of the hospital
Kortland koward

United States

#167 Nov 6, 2010
any time you want to get together and pack each others fudge just let me know. I find all this back and forth garbage very hot and I love manjuice
Kortland koward

United States

#168 Nov 6, 2010
first amendment wrote:
u spit or swallow boy?
I swallow of course
Really

AOL

#170 Nov 6, 2010
Kortland koward wrote:
<quoted text>
I swallow of course
Why dont you start a porn site? Why do you turn every thread into trash? You are one sick person.
Kortland Koward

Herkimer, NY

#171 Nov 6, 2010
first amendment wrote:
phagg u talk a good game ive sent to that email 2x and no response ur ful of shit like ur rants.. get a life dikles
You have sent ZERO emails to that address because the inbox is still empty. coward
Kortland Koward

United States

#172 Nov 6, 2010
first amendment wrote:
phagg u talk a good game ive sent to that email 2x and no response ur ful of shit like ur rants.. get a life dikles
ahh, so instead of actually sending me an email, you decide to use the email address to enroll in all kinds of crap like the GAO with the government and parenting magazines.

I see, really sad cowardly thing to do.
bitch move

Herkimer, NY

#174 Nov 6, 2010
Kortland Koward wrote:
<quoted text>
ahh, so instead of actually sending me an email, you decide to use the email address to enroll in all kinds of crap like the GAO with the government and parenting magazines.
I see, really sad cowardly thing to do.
yeah a straight up bitch move. obvious they have no balls and are nothing to worry about

Since: Oct 10

Rome NY

#175 Nov 6, 2010
Vinnys
joe

United States

#176 Nov 10, 2010
i like salvatores
chazzyG

Dolgeville, NY

#177 Jul 12, 2011
Tony's pizza is indeed excellent, but you gotta sell your "damn" car to enjoy it!
chazzyG

Dolgeville, NY

#178 Jul 12, 2011
He treats his help like servants,He belly-aches and complains why he has to pay them(as if they were put on earth to serve him),and he posts stupid excuses @ THE "CASH-COUNTER"(which makes him look desperate) to the costomer explaining why he's SOoo...OUTRAGEOUS ~~
ps: on the contrast the pizza rules!

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Herkimer Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Empire Diner 2 hr Thatotherguy 16
That Place, Utica's pathetic excuse for a gay bar (Feb '12) 6 hr Ben Dover 7
Romas Pizza Sucks 7 hr Just me 18
get rid of jimmy franco 8 hr poster4177 13
Albany st. gay bar coccaine bar (Jun '09) 8 hr olddiebutgoodie 9
Poll Herkimer Needs a Gay Bar Because (Nov '08) 9 hr olddiebutgoodie 13
Men Who Masterbate Often (Feb '10) 9 hr olddiebutgoodie 38

Herkimer Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

Herkimer Mortgages