Who has the best pizza in Herkimer?

Who has the best pizza in Herkimer?

Posted in the Herkimer Forum

First Prev
of 9
Next Last
herkimer resident

Fishers, NY

#1 Apr 20, 2008
Tonys, That's Amore, Salvatore Sorrentos , Pizza boys, Vinny, or Yettys?

Vernon, NY

#2 Apr 20, 2008
herkimer resident wrote:
Tonys, That's Amore, Salvatore Sorrentos , Pizza boys, Vinny, or Yettys?
No close second


#3 Apr 20, 2008
Nothing Better to Do

Frankfort, NY

#4 Apr 21, 2008
Everybody has there own taste and opinion!
Mohawk Valley Mama

Nedrow, NY

#5 Apr 21, 2008
Used to think Brian's had the best but seems like they have gone downhill. Just tried That's Amore over the weekend, not impressed; nothing to write home about. Tony's blows; never cared for theirs. Looking forward to Vinny's re-opening. Sorrento's is probably the best right now.
Nothing Better to Do

Frankfort, NY

#6 Apr 21, 2008
Vinny's reopening :) That's a good thing!

Syracuse, NY

#7 Apr 21, 2008
I wonder if pizza places like sorrentos are going to go down now with Vinnys coming back.

Palmetto, FL

#8 Apr 21, 2008
Well it DEFINATELY isnt Carney's! That pizza is hideous!!! Nothing delicious about it. The place is a grease-pit anyway!!!
Valley taxpayer

Fishers, NY

#9 Apr 21, 2008
Nothing Better to Do

Frankfort, NY

#10 Apr 22, 2008
Carney's is disgusting. Yetty's is good! Even Brian's is getting real dirty inside they need to renovate.
Ed Holtz

Carleton, MI

#11 Apr 22, 2008
The "old" Yetty's pizza around the corner from where it is now was the best. I still remember the old worn out sign who's only letter's that lit up were Y's PIZ. The new Yetty's was a letdown. Brian's is now the best.
Nothing Better to Do

Frankfort, NY

#13 Apr 22, 2008
Ceiling tiles and walls are black and I mean black. Very Gross. It wouldn't take alot to replace some tiles and paint the walls would probably make a world of a difference. You are right the food is good. But lately when I pick up the food the atmosphere is horrible and brings down the way I feel about the food that is being made in that dirty kitchen.

Cicero, NY

#14 Apr 22, 2008
I would say the cleaniest place I have eatin has been at Salvatores Sorrentos. There food is really good too.

Tremont, PA

#15 Apr 23, 2008
Herkimer also

Frankfort, NY

#17 May 1, 2008
Vinny's by far. Can't wait till the reopen.
Pizza Fan

Syracuse, NY

#18 May 1, 2008
I think Carney's is great. The thick crust is excellent and the service has always been good. I haven't tried Vinny's but I will when they open. Pizza Hut is also great.
Single parent

Herkimer, NY

#20 May 2, 2008
Joe B wrote:
I eat pizza from anywhere no matter how dirty,i love food,specially twinkies,ho hos and pizza with mayo! Im a fat slob,so what Mr, i saw your dog poop on main street!

Let the record show the above comment was not made by me...
Mean people


#22 May 3, 2008
I have never seen anything so ridiculous in all my life. People being able to write these types of things and not put a real name of who they are. Anyone could write anything bad or negative even if it is not true. Especially if they have something against the business, like being fired for stealing..etc or if they owned a similar business and wanted to make the other business look bad. Most kitchens are behind a swinging door and you don't know what is behind that swinging door..don't be too quick to judge. Also NYS has health inspectors that visit all restaurants several times a year...unexpectedly. There are many stipulations in the food business that have to be passed. So for just anyone to say such nasty things about any business without using their real identity is very wrong...what a shame.
pizza expert

Fishers, NY

#25 May 3, 2008
Dunkin Donuts gets my vote
Mean people


#26 May 3, 2008
Yes, I have been in Brian's many times...It has been in the same location and has had the same owner for over 30 years. Everytime I go there the owner is alwyas there working...just trying to survive and doing what he loves to do. It is certianly nothing fancy by all means..but has good food at a reasonable price. If you don't like the atmosphere then you don't have to go there...no one is pulling your arm. He must be doing something right..for being in business for so many years. Other than Morettis barber shop..and collis hardware, Brians is the only original place that has ever lasted on main st.
All other pizza and sub shops have either closed or have relocated and built brand new. The buildings are all attached together...so it is impossilble to tear down and rebuild. He would have to relocate and at his age it wouldn't be worth it. WOW...Leave the guy alone...he is a nice guy...who is a hard worker.. just doing what he loves...and don't be so negative and mean..no one is making you go there to eat. There are a ton of other places to go.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 9
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Herkimer Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Kriket And Clyde.. 46 min Itsme 13
8 people selling drugs 2 hr Just me 12
Kayla Symonds? (Apr '15) 2 hr Scumbag 6
Codie johnston fuckable or no? 3 hr Uakbitch 12
who is amanda pohleven? 5 hr Bib Frapples 15
Village loses again 5 hr Tony 7
Ben anthony 16 hr LostBoi 9

Herkimer Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

Herkimer Mortgages