Whats your views on Garrett Dye

Whats your views on Garrett Dye

Posted in the Guthrie Forum

First Prev
of 7
Next Last
TCCHS17

White House, TN

#1 Sep 6, 2011
Did he really do this?
metalmamma

United States

#2 Sep 7, 2011
That's for a jury to decide.
shaynana brown

Utica, KY

#3 Sep 7, 2011
he sure nuff will be tender meat for the cons at prison
Sugarmomma2004

Utica, KY

#4 Sep 20, 2011
I think he did this, and needs to pay for the crime
Nothing like family

Central City, KY

#5 Sep 20, 2011
Michelle Oliver why wouldn't you help your nephew instead of trying to keep your nephew off dope,you need to leave him alone and thanks for putting your brother in jail for sticking up for his son. They'll find your dope house one day and you will rot in HELL you dirty lying whore is this where you want to be when jesus comes back. And to all the Elkton cops your all retarded for not searching the house when you were there y'all couldn't catch a fly if it weren't for narcs you pieces of shit.
dillion johnson

White House, TN

#7 Sep 22, 2011
he'll always be my buddy and like to thnk he dident do what they say he did
LISTEN HEAR

Bowling Green, KY

#8 Oct 18, 2011
All evidence seem's to say he did commit this horrible crime against this innocent child!!!!! I dont understand how anyone could stick up for him after such a heinous act was commited, perhaps you use to be friends but friends or not murdering that child and trying to hide it is unforgivable, and if you don't think so well maybe you have a small child in your family, would you honestly say that you would feel comfortable letting this monster be alone with that child????? I think not!!!!

Since: Nov 10

Location hidden

#11 Oct 19, 2011
If he didn't do it would he plead guilty? For all the Garrett Dye sympathizers.
Nunnnya

United States

#12 Oct 20, 2011
Kill him tha same way he did tha lil girl
Tcchs girl

Valdosta, GA

#13 Oct 20, 2011
Nunnnya wrote:
Kill him tha same way he did tha lil girl
I couldnt agree more!!
dye MUST dye

Hardinsburg, KY

#15 Oct 22, 2011
read the bible an eye for an eye
Toddcountygirl

Madisonville, KY

#16 Oct 22, 2011
Reading what was in the new era it sounds like he got some bad legal advice if he thinks pleading guilty and stating he beat her until she was dead for no reason and reserving the right to appeal is going to work out for him. At trial he could have gotten 20-50 years. If the appeal doesn't work out for him- and the judge told him it was a very long shot- he will be 67 when he is released. If word leaks out what he is in prison for they better keep him in protective custody or he's in bigger trouble than just the 50 years lockup!

Rest in peace Amy! God bless you sweet girl!
Tcchs girl

Valdosta, GA

#17 Oct 22, 2011
Did anyone watch the news yesterday at 6 I dont know why but when he sat there and admitted that and the way he said it really freaked me out. Thats so horrible I do hope he does get the maximum time.

Since: Nov 10

Location hidden

#18 Oct 22, 2011
Prison will not be kind to this punk. He will be old when and if he gets out of the pen.
southern man

Hardinsburg, KY

#19 Oct 24, 2011
50 years in prison i would ask GOD for forgivness then KILL myself
fuckyallhaters

Dunmor, KY

#20 Oct 24, 2011
i dnt thnk he did it even if he did confess and if he did i forgive em. thats my boy rite there that tlkin bout.

Since: Nov 10

Location hidden

#21 Oct 25, 2011
fuckyallhaters wrote:
i dnt thnk he did it even if he did confess and if he did i forgive em. thats my boy rite there that tlkin bout.
"Your boy" is not real smart is he? He admitted to doing what he didn't do? lol
I guess he just likes the thought of being a young bitch in the pen...someone will make him their "boy".lol
just saying

Clarksville, TN

#22 Oct 25, 2011
fuckyallhaters wrote:
i dnt thnk he did it even if he did confess and if he did i forgive em. thats my boy rite there that tlkin bout.
he might be your "boy" but do you really think he would confess if he didn't kill amy? if you were innocent, wouldn't you be fighting tooth and nail to prove just that? i know it's hard to believe your friend would be capable of something so horrible, but get used to it kid. he did it, he confessed, and now he's going to pay the price for taking that child's life.

you can still be his friend, you can still support him. visit him in prison, send him letters and care packages, do whatever you need to do...but he is guilty. there's no debate. it came from his own mouth.
Todd County Girl

Madisonville, KY

#23 Oct 28, 2011
There is info. in the Todd County Standard this week about the murder, his confession and also info. from the autopsy report. If you read the extent of the injuries that this poor girl suffered it will make you sick. I can't even begin to imagine what the last minutes of her life must have been like at the hands of this person who she loved so much. If you ever knew Amy, you knew she thought the world of Garrett.

When he pleaded guilty recently he calmly stated that he went to get the weapon and came back and hit her with it and kept hitting her until she was dead. Even if the earlier confession is thrown out somehow, this should be sufficient to convict him even if he does win an appeal. He showed no remorse, no emotion, just stated the facts. Scary.

There has been much speculation about the home life that Amy had. She always seemed so happy and carefree. She was always dressed really cute and had a sparkle in her eye. She loved her friends and her family. After she is gone you find out that she would come to school with a moldy lunch box with a piece of bread for lunch or a few crackers. Pictures were on FB of the parents and brothers on vacation in Hawaii and other places- Amy was never included in the trips it would appear from all the pictures that were posted. If she their adopted sister and lived with them it seems odd that she was excluded from family trips. There has been lots of speculation about reports with child protective services. If there is nothing to hide why would the family have been so protective of the information? Granted, you don't want to air your business, but if you are trying to clear your child of murdering a family member you would think you would want all the supporting evidence of a loving family that you could show.

She was shoveling rocks in the driveway in very cold temperatures in the rain as punishment for stealing food at school that day. I don't believe a 9 year old would steal food if they were being fed properly. It also seems strange punishment to put a child outside in freezing cold rain to shovel rocks. The truth about what happened that lead up to that moment when Garrett snapped and went to get the weapon may never be known. You can't help but wonder if he took the deal to save family details coming out or exactly what the situation was.

It's a heartbreaking situation and two young lives were lost that night. Amy is in a better place and regardless of what her home life here may or may not have been, she is at peace now.

It is sad that when telling what happened there was no emotion, no regret, no tears, no apologies, no wishing he could go back to that night and change things. No, I snapped and am sorry it happened. Nothing showing he would do anything differently, just stating the facts. He went to get the weapon, came back and killed her. He had the time walking there and back to think about what he was doing and kept going. After he has done this he goes and cleans up and plays video games then pretends to help look for her?

Prison isn't good enough for someone this callous and cold.

Since: Nov 10

Location hidden

#24 Oct 30, 2011
Where did all the Garrett Dye defender/lovers go that have been present in all the other threads concerning this animal?

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 7
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Guthrie Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Private swingers club 7 hr Rumor 3
Dollar General on Greenville Road is disgusting 7 hr Rumor 23
Addison brown 11 hr Skeptical 1
Red head 19 hr Hair 7
Vincent Judd-Rapp (Mar '12) Mon Bout Time 31
Board of education vacancy Sun Friend 18
jailer election Dec 7 TODD DUKES 12

Guthrie Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

Guthrie Mortgages