Lisa Watson

Mattituck, NY

#143 Feb 15, 2014
Just saw that video pix.11, it's a very good story, Robert does not look happy and looked like something not good was going to happen after that but what? Ida mentioned she has no knowledge of him living a double life but no one will ever know until someone sees him someday and hope he is alive, just like that man that that was found 2 years later in Florida, his family and kids did not think he was alive.
I think what has thrown me off is that maybe these news people are putting the wrong information like the one on Commack Patch, they said Ida said he left his wallet on the dresser and now on the new pix11 it was in the garage.
It just seemed that 10 mins. Rob had at home had to be with someone maybe and put all his things in different places while Robert was getting ready to dress and disguise himself so no one will notice him.
He maybe in a lot of trouble or involved in something bad that he needed to do for money?
Not saying anything bad about Ida, she never sheds a tear, but she does look upset, but what do you do in her situation no knowing if she does not know!
Not sure who the person was, but I am using my name and not hiding anything...
Joan

Elmont, NY

#144 Feb 15, 2014
In my opinion he left on his own and she knows it! I think things spiraled out of control. Do we know there has been no contact for sure? Nobody but one person does all the talking so we can't know! Are police monitoring their phone,doubt it... They don't even think a crime was committed! Isn't her bro in law (the one she originally called) on the force? No professional courtesy there? No rush to get info on the car? A cops bro in law is missing and nobody can call in a favor! Doubt it!!! If that was my family ( which we have quite a few police officers in) you could bet they would be pulling every string! And again no comments ever from anyone ?
Lisa Watson

Mattituck, NY

#145 Feb 15, 2014
It seemed a little odd with the story about the neighbors camera only saw the little red car, considering how tall Robert is and how small the car is that all was seen on camera?
Observer

Los Angeles, CA

#146 Feb 15, 2014
Linda wrote:
<quoted text>
We all know who "Observer" is from CA It's obvious. One of the sycophants.
Oh really? Who am I? Like that makes a difference. And who are you? A tabloid chaser I would guess.
Sue

Commack, NY

#147 Feb 15, 2014
Observer, seems to take these comments personally! Everyone is entitled to their opinion based on the story that has been told. What do YOU expect? Should everyone be in agreement with you? If there are different opinions you say people are "clueless!! Well clue us in if you know so much....Until I hear anything that make sense, I'm going with he left her and she knows why!
Linda

Hopewell Junction, NY

#148 Feb 16, 2014
Lisa Watson wrote:
It seemed a little odd with the story about the neighbors camera only saw the little red car, considering how tall Robert is and how small the car is that all was seen on camera?
I agree, after seeing the latest I think he left on his own. She gets emotional about taking him for granted. That's her biggest regret, she never told him he was appreciated. Poor Rob.

He had enough and left. He cashed out and left.

MM full article: http://pix11.com/2014/02/13/surveillance-show...
Snoopy

Massapequa, NY

#149 Feb 16, 2014
Linda wrote:
<quoted text>
I agree, after seeing the latest I think he left on his own. She gets emotional about taking him for granted. That's her biggest regret, she never told him he was appreciated. Poor Rob.
He had enough and left. He cashed out and left.
MM full article: http://pix11.com/2014/02/13/surveillance-show...
Because every husband who isn't told he's appreciated "cashes out" and leaves.

::eyeroll::
Lisa Watson

Mattituck, NY

#150 Feb 16, 2014
When I watch her videos you know how when a judge says a person is lying they do a movement, when she says something in an answer of not know what happen to Rob she takes her hand to her neck or other things she does and than still when she goes on about nothing, and when she sounds like she is crying no tears, unless she has a problem. She must know something and just cannot say anything, where are all the phsychics in this case.....
Linda

Hopewell Junction, NY

#151 Feb 16, 2014
Joan wrote:
In my opinion he left on his own and she knows it! I think things spiraled out of control. Do we know there has been no contact for sure? Nobody but one person does all the talking so we can't know! Are police monitoring their phone,doubt it... They don't even think a crime was committed! Isn't her bro in law (the one she originally called) on the force? No professional courtesy there? No rush to get info on the car? A cops bro in law is missing and nobody can call in a favor! Doubt it!!! If that was my family ( which we have quite a few police officers in) you could bet they would be pulling every string! And again no comments ever from anyone ?
I agree. I misquoted above.
Joan

Elmont, NY

#152 Feb 16, 2014
@ lisa Watson, agreed! While I understand protecting her children and ultimately her own reputation , the bigger picture is her husband is gone! At what point do you not care about what "strangers" are saying and put all you can out there to find him! Enough with the act! Social media is sooo powerful, use it!
On a side note, did anyone else sense hesitancy when the reporter asked if he has any issues that would make him disappear? I sure did
Lisa Watson

Sag Harbor, NY

#153 Feb 17, 2014
On that video, when they asked Ida so the only thing that was shown on neighbors video was the top of his car as she rubs her chin.....Also notice he had sunglasses on his shirt, she never mentioned if he still maybe had those but talked about him leaving his reading glasses.

One other thing is that when he or someone pulled in the driveway that day, all his stuff was put in the garage but did he or someone go through front door,why did they not open the garage door that day, seems odd since all his stuff was put in the garage but the neighbors camera did not show anything but the TOP OF HIS CAR, still do not believe in that story..Just my opinion
Lisa

Elmont, NY

#154 Feb 17, 2014
Lisa Watson, soooo true ! What bothers me to this day is how much everyone ( including His wife) focused on Arrow , when she clearly knew he came home after ( since she found receipt and the money)

And what happened with the car? Does she have it or not? Any answers found in the car? She is counting on strangers to help her , yet she is withholding information. Why? Im having a hard time feeling compassion for her! I know it sounds terrible.
Dan

Huntington Station, NY

#155 Feb 18, 2014
Another shameful performance by Ida. And why now?
I don't think Rob left voluntarily but i believe Ida knows the whys and hows behind the mysterious events the day her husband vanished.
A bit of honesty and candor goes a long way.
Lisa Watson

Sag Harbor, NY

#156 Feb 19, 2014
Not picking on Ida, but watch a lot of judge shows and know the judges always say when someone is lying they have a movement, so I watched the interview again

Ida says "I want to believe he is alive" as she touches the side of her neck

Ida says "Top part of his car was only seen in the video" as she touches her chin

Also mentions in the garage a jacket she picked up a jacket, she said he would always wear to work in the morning, she never mentioned that before unless some else seen that, but no jacket on any interview, it was always about the work shirt he wore, but no jacket.

Saw the detective in the interview, there was no cameras he says, but he said his car, it was legally parked at the train station but Rob would never take the train, but obviously if his car was parked there and his bike is missing maybe there is a chance he got on the train, in disguise of course, since he did have 10 minutes to drop off his life, and I do believe he must have had a helper, maybe that was the person he may have left with at the scrap yard, maybe that was planned for a Friday and that's why he looked tired, kind of scared and freaked out because he was going to dissappear, at least I would be freaking out.
Just my opinion all and questions?
Sue

Commack, NY

#157 Feb 19, 2014
Lisa Watson wrote:
Not picking on Ida, but watch a lot of judge shows and know the judges always say when someone is lying they have a movement, so I watched the interview again
Ida says "I want to believe he is alive" as she touches the side of her neck
Ida says "Top part of his car was only seen in the video" as she touches her chin
Also mentions in the garage a jacket she picked up a jacket, she said he would always wear to work in the morning, she never mentioned that before unless some else seen that, but no jacket on any interview, it was always about the work shirt he wore, but no jacket.
Saw the detective in the interview, there was no cameras he says, but he said his car, it was legally parked at the train station but Rob would never take the train, but obviously if his car was parked there and his bike is missing maybe there is a chance he got on the train, in disguise of course, since he did have 10 minutes to drop off his life, and I do believe he must have had a helper, maybe that was the person he may have left with at the scrap yard, maybe that was planned for a Friday and that's why he looked tired, kind of scared and freaked out because he was going to dissappear, at least I would be freaking out.
Just my opinion all and questions?


It was June, so he wouldn't have been wearing a Jacket. As for the video of him, I did not get the impression that he looked scared.....I do think he looked tired but lets also remember that this was a security camera, which in my opinion the pictures are always awful.
Joan

Elmont, NY

#158 Feb 19, 2014
Why bring up the jacket now? Or was she simply being nostalgic? Sometimes I get the feeling watching her speak that she is speaking to him, like alway saying things like we will protect you, or on this last interview she took him for granted and she appreciates him. Either way you dice it, I hope he is safe... Hope it's as simple as midlife crisis or nervous breakdown. I mean he drove himself to train station (no other fingerprints) or anything in the car, so that means to me he skipped town! Nothing else makes sense!
Carter

Elmont, NY

#159 Feb 19, 2014
Wonder if arrow is one of those sketchy places that sells I.d.'s? Lots of crooked places do that sort of stuff. Not saying arrow is like that, I know nothing about them. Just curious !
Lisa Watson

Sag Harbor, NY

#160 Feb 20, 2014
She is so neat and tidy and perfect in the house except for the garage and why was the jacket just hanging out, surprised all that stuff is so messy down there? I hope he is okay also, after all those years together, looking at all family photos the perfect family he just got tired of all of it, at least living like that I would to...

Did not look like he had a break just for himself, the travelling time to and from work, the job he had looked like a lot and than go home and have the family projects and travelling how many times a year do they travel, I use to go away once a year and that was a lot, I saw the picture they had in Feb from there last vacation and they planned again in July? Notice the pictures also, Rob seemed to look different in all his pictures, his weight, hair and everything, well so did she...

If he did just leave that is so horrible for the kids sake and his mom and close family and friends but so many people go missing and just appear years later in another life.

Does anyone know of a pshyic
Joan

Elmont, NY

#161 Feb 20, 2014
So true Lisa Watson, love your attention to detail! Would be very interesting if all the people who were on websleuths voiced opinions on here!
Carolyn

Riverhead, NY

#162 Feb 20, 2014
Hi guys--- just a few random thoughts----

I think Arrow is such a point of focus b/c there is actual tape of him and also interaction with another human being who can discuss Rob's manner etc., also if he was alone or not. There is a receipt of his transaction with (presumably) a stamped time.

I am unable to watch the video (stupid computer of mine)--can anyone tell me if Ida is wearing her wedding ring??

Lisa W--- would love to know if a psychic has contaced Ida---There had been a question raised of "LI Medium" getting involved and helping. I believe Rob's father has passed-perhaps her can provide a message.

And waving to Joan-----Hi-am on Websleuth!!!!!!!

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Greenlawn Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Swift Named Principal at Our Lady of Lourdes (Aug '09) 3 hr Bruser 2,315
Review: Depalo & Sons Auto Body Inc (Nov '09) 6 hr Jack Oasis 17
Review: Sahdev Devinder (Dec '10) Wed John 15
Cops raid W. Islip bar, arrest owners, bartenders (Jan '08) Oct 20 tim21 239
Review: Demi's Coffee S Oct 20 Foodie 1
"Raunchy Joker But Harmless?" Oct 19 Jeff Kelly 1
commack resident janet koch is new exec. dir. o... Oct 18 DHF1147 1

Greenlawn News Video

Greenlawn Dating
Find my Match

Greenlawn Jobs

Greenlawn People Search

Addresses and phone numbers for FREE

Greenlawn News, Events & Info

Click for news, events and info in Greenlawn

Personal Finance

Mortgages [ See current mortgage rates ]