Haley Reinhart Eliminated from 'Ameri...

Haley Reinhart Eliminated from 'American Idol'

There are 25 comments on the ABC News story from May 20, 2011, titled Haley Reinhart Eliminated from 'American Idol'. In it, ABC News reports that:

Lauren Alaina and Scotty McCreery will face off next week in the final round of "American Idol" after Haley Reinhart was eliminated Thursday night.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at ABC News.

First Prev
of 2
Next Last
George

United States

#1 May 20, 2011
It's about time,, she should have gone a long time ago, Scotty will win this, Lauren is good, just not near as good as Scotty, and those that say he can't sing absolutly have to be tone deaf, and have a major cob up thier backsides when it comes to wholesome, true country, he most certainly is what America stands for, and way to many out there are threatened by that, why?? don't know, must be they see the total good in Scotty and it makes thier own failures stand out that much more, only reason I can think that people feel threatened by him and hate him so much.
Oh and by the way, fyi,, I am not a teenybopper having a major crush on cutie Scotty, I am a happily married 50 year old mother of 3 that happens to love country music and this country. and Love Scotty for being such a good influence on the younger kids out there,, not afraid to proclaim his faith, clean cut, wholesome all American kid, and those of you that feel threatened by this? please, go bury your heads in the sand and shake and shiver, because Scotty is most certainly going to win this.
Either that or change who you are and feel proud of yourselves, that was Scotty is, confident, smooth, very comforatble on stage, and around others, he has a confidence that shows in all his work, and his voice is amazing, anyone that says it isn't has no clue what real talent is. and obviously the majority of the votes across the country agree with me!:) just go to dialidol.com and see the results of the voting, Scotty won 2 to 1 over both lauren and Haley,, not surprising.
Mona

Saint Louis, MO

#2 May 20, 2011
I am so glad she is gone. Did you see the look of disbeleif on her face when Lauren name was announced. It was priceless. She thought she had it all wrapped up. Did not like her voice at all. Did the happy dance when Scotty and Lauren were named.
Checkers

Colo, IA

#3 May 20, 2011
I think Lauren should win, Haley had no range and ANYONE can growl!!! Scott is good too but I would rather have Lauren...not a country music buff.
He he he

Bradenton, FL

#4 May 20, 2011
Checkers wrote:
I think Lauren should win, Haley had no range and ANYONE can growl!!! Scott is good too but I would rather have Lauren...not a country music buff.
lauren should be on weight watchers Idol....

she'll weight 200 pounds within 6 months.....

not exactly Idol material for young girls.....
screen

Walnut Grove, CA

#5 May 21, 2011
Hahah!.. you do have a point there, I mean.. Lauren is a "big girl" for her age. If she does not do something about her weight NOW... she will definately have a problem with it in the future. If she's fine with her bigness.. then that's kool too.
Honey Bear

Colo, IA

#6 May 21, 2011
He he he wrote:
<quoted text>
lauren should be on weight watchers Idol....
she'll weight 200 pounds within 6 months.....
not exactly Idol material for young girls.....
And you know this because?????
Checkers

Colo, IA

#7 May 21, 2011
screen wrote:
Hahah!.. you do have a point there, I mean.. Lauren is a "big girl" for her age. If she does not do something about her weight NOW... she will definately have a problem with it in the future. If she's fine with her bigness.. then that's kool too.
Now I've heard it all.... Are you aware that you are at least 20 lbs. heavier when on television??
Reader

Bradenton, FL

#8 May 21, 2011
Checkers wrote:
<quoted text>
Now I've heard it all.... Are you aware that you are at least 20 lbs. heavier when on television??
thats what all the fat people on tv say.....

Tv or no TV...that girl has spent way too much time in the junk food isle.

Since: Apr 11

Location hidden

#9 May 22, 2011
James Durbin should have that title! He was the best performer out of all of them! America always goes country. I like country but how many more country artists do we need from Idol?
screen

Walnut Grove, CA

#10 May 22, 2011
Checkers wrote:
<quoted text>
Are you aware that you are at least 20 lbs. heavier when on television??
Of course I am, anyone would be about 20 lbs. heavier when on a tv while weighing themselves. When standing side-by-side.. Lauren makes Ryan Seacrest look like her stepchild.
NO LOVE

Moline, IL

#11 May 22, 2011
kooky girl wrote:
James Durbin should have that title! He was the best performer out of all of them! America always goes country. I like country but how many more country artists do we need from Idol?
Did you mean "BLINKY"? Maybe he should of tongue kissed his bass player like adam lambert did, or preformed oral sex on randy jackson,thats the only way that screeching tard would of got more votes.

Since: May 11

Location hidden

#12 May 22, 2011
Reader wrote:
<quoted text>
thats what all the fat people on tv say.....
Tv or no TV...that girl has spent way too much time in the junk food isle.
When Lauren and Haley were standing beside of each other Lauren made Haley look like a 12 year old girl before puberty. Lauren has the body of a WOMAN. She is beautiful and has the perfect figure for a woman. Out of the picture I am linking, she looks way better than Haley!

http://i53.tinypic.com/8wczud.jpg
LOL

Bradenton, FL

#13 May 22, 2011
JeannieRanee wrote:
<quoted text>
When Lauren and Haley were standing beside of each other Lauren made Haley look like a 12 year old girl before puberty. Lauren has the body of a WOMAN. She is beautiful and has the perfect figure for a woman. Out of the picture I am linking, she looks way better than Haley!
http://i53.tinypic.com/8wczud.jpg
He he he....the body of a woman ??????

you been looking at way to many obese american women....

lauren is a porker....

not big boned.....she got her big azz from the bakery shop....

Since: May 11

Location hidden

#14 May 22, 2011
LOL wrote:
<quoted text>
He he he....the body of a woman ??????
you been looking at way to many obese american women....
lauren is a porker....
not big boned.....she got her big azz from the bakery shop....
It is people like you that make the world a shitty and judgmental place. You and your shallowness won't make it far in life, bet.

You are a sad, sad human being. And I am not going to make this a big conversation because you have already won in your small mind. Good luck in life... and love.

Goodbye.
LOL

Bradenton, FL

#15 May 22, 2011
JeannieRanee wrote:
<quoted text>
It is people like you that make the world a shitty and judgmental place. You and your shallowness won't make it far in life, bet.
You are a sad, sad human being. And I am not going to make this a big conversation because you have already won in your small mind. Good luck in life... and love.
Goodbye.
hey...don't go chubby....

i'm sure somebody will be posting some weight loss tips for you later....
Checkers

Colo, IA

#16 May 23, 2011
screen wrote:
<quoted text>
Of course I am, anyone would be about 20 lbs. heavier when on a tv while weighing themselves. When standing side-by-side.. Lauren makes Ryan Seacrest look like her stepchild.
You aren't mean spirited, are you???? People..
screen

Walnut Grove, CA

#17 May 24, 2011
I should ask the same of you Checkers. But in answering your question, no I am not mean spirited.. and I believe the majority of my posts reflect this. My goal is to tell it like it is (with no intent to offend), while still being able to joke around a bit when the opportunity arises.

My tv shows people in accurate proportions to their actual size, therefore; your post stating that an individual is 20 lbs. heavier when viewed on a television set, is nothing more than an excuse to justify someone who is actually "twenty pounds heavier" than they should be for their age.

Lauren's big frame allows her to handle her weight for now. But as with all of us, her metabolism will slow down with age; causing her difficulties in maintaining that nice figure she enjoys today.

No meanness meant here.
LILMISY

Tacoma, WA

#18 May 24, 2011
screen wrote:
Hahah!.. you do have a point there, I mean.. Lauren is a "big girl" for her age. If she does not do something about her weight NOW... she will definately have a problem with it in the future. If she's fine with her bigness.. then that's kool too.
TV always makes you look bigger...She looks great!
glen hall

Oneida, NY

#19 May 24, 2011
Haley should of got it. She had the voice.
just saying

Bradenton, FL

#20 May 24, 2011
LILMISY wrote:
<quoted text>
TV always makes you look bigger...She looks great!
if TV makes a person look bigger.....then it makes everyone look bigger.
soooooo, lauren is still huge compared to everyone else.....especially being only 16 years old.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 2
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Garner Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Trump, Clinton and Katy Perry make case to vote... Thu Oh No You Di-nt 2
Do you like to expose your wife? (Sep '11) Thu Leo1963 70
News Judge dismisses challenge to N. Carolina gay-ma... Sep 23 DaveinMass 27
Buh Bye all you IBM Employees (Feb '11) Sep 22 Ronald McDonald 110
Garner Music Thread (Jun '14) Feb '16 Musikologist 4
News Editorial: What does McCrory have against solar... (Feb '16) Feb '16 Solarman 1
"RINO" Burr (Dec '15) Dec '15 JB Buttsavage 2

Garner Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

Garner Mortgages