Sheriff: Death was likely murder-atte...

Sheriff: Death was likely murder-attempted suicide

There are 73 comments on the Sunherald.com story from Oct 17, 2008, titled Sheriff: Death was likely murder-attempted suicide. In it, Sunherald.com reports that:

Monroe County Sheriff Andy Hood says the shooting death of a 20-year-old Smithville woman appears to have been a planned murder-suicide. However, Amanda Christine Suggs' assailant, 20-year-old Casey Young of ...

Join the discussion below, or Read more at Sunherald.com.

First Prev
of 4
Next Last
kelly hall

United States

#65 Oct 25, 2011
Mother wrote:
To Kelly Hall...Were u there that night? I don't think so..She was not in the bathtub then..She was at the front door..then watched as Casy got the gun out of the trunk of the car and then pointed the gun at Amanda as she turned that is when he shot her...
mother, WERE YOU THERE??? Or you also repeating hearsay????
kelly hall

Dallas, TX

#66 Oct 26, 2011
I am sure not going to skate around the truth with this situation....
THESE ARE FACTS, THAT WE ALL KNOW FOR SURE;

911 was called on october 15, 2008, requesting police action and the need for IMMEDIATE AID....

*** EVERYONE SHOULD KNOW OR CONCLUDE THAT TIME IS OF THE ESSENCE IN HANDLING GUNSHOT WOUNDS, AND OTHER LIFE THREATENING EMERGENCIES ******

When LAW ENFORCEMENT arrived HE ABSOLUTELY HAD A DUTY TO PROTECT OTHERS AND PRESERVE EVIDENCE... LAW ENFORCEMENT had a duty to SECURE THE SCENE AND GIVE AN "ALL CLEAR" FOR THE MEDICS TO RENDER FIRST AID TO VICTIMS!!!!!!!!!!

EXIGENT CIRCUMSTANCES:
1) TO PREVENT HARM TO OTHERS
2) TO PREVENT THE DESTRUCTION OF EVIDENCE.
3) TO RENDER AID TO A PERSON IN NEED OF IMMEDIATE ASSISTANCE!

Officers are trained not to hesitate to act reasonably to preserve life and protect others in potentially dangerous situations....(I KNOW THIS FOR A FACT)

there were plenty of reasons for immediate need to act!!

THERE IS WITHOUT A DOUBT IN MY MIND A CASE OF DEPRIVATION OF PEOPLE'S CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS AND PROTECTION THAT IS AFFORDED TO THE CITIZENS OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA...

It's as obvious and anything I have ever seen in my life that an officer, WITNESSING EXIGENT CIRCUMSTANCES, STOOD BY AND WAITED ON BACKUP BECAUSE HE WAS SCARED AND OBVIOUSLY NOT SO SURE OF HIS TRAINING WITH THE WEAPONS ON HIS DUTY BELT OR POSSIBLY EVEN A SHOT GUN IN HIS PATROL CAR.....

WELL, SINCE YOU DIDN'T YOUR JOB AND ONLY STOOD BY TO WITNESS APPROXIMATELY 45 MINUTES OF EVENTS THAT NIGHT, MAYBE WE CAN USE YOUR STATEMENTS IF YOU ALL WOULD EVER GIVE ONE INSTEAD OF TELLING PEOPLE THAT ASK YOU,
" THAT IT'S A TRAGEDY FOR ALL INVOLVED"....
WELL, WE ALL KNOW THAT ALREADY!!

NOW TELL US WHAT HAPPENED, AND WHAT YOU WITNESSED AS YOU WERE ALLOWING THE DESTRUCTION OF EVIDENCE AND INJURY TO PERSONS AND NOT PROVIDING IMMEDIATE AID TO YET ANOTHER PERSON......(WHILE YOU WERE WAITING ON BACK UP)????????

AND THERE IS NOT A PERSON STUPID ENOUGH AND ILLITERATE ENOUGH TO ATTACK THESE FACTS

BECAUSE IF THERE IS, I'LL BE YOUR HUCKLEBERRY!!

WAKE UP PEOPLE, STOP BEGGING FOR INFORMATION THAT IS AFFORDED US IN OUR RIGHTS!!
THE SHERIFF'S DEPT. IS AN ARM OF THE GOVERNMENT AND THE GOVERNMENT'S BUSINESS IS OUR BUSINESS....

DEMAND YOUR RIGHTS AS I AM DOING AND DO NOT STOP PURSUING EVERY AVENUE TO OBTAIN JUSTICE FOR YOUR LOVED ONE(S)..

EVERYONE THAT RESPONDED TO BRASFIELD LOOP ON OCT.15, 2008 HAD A DUTY.... IF YOU PERFORMED YOUR DUTY, I GIVE YOU A PAT ON THE BACK, FOR DOING WHAT YOU CHOSE, SOME SWORE TO DO AND SOME GET PAID TO DO....
IF YOU ARE SCARED AND NOT TRAINED, FIND ANOTHER JOB!!! THAT'S YOUR OPTIONS...... EACH WILL ANSWER TO THEIR ACTIONS AND LACK OF ACTIONS !!!!!

RESPONSE TIME OF THE SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENT IS NOT MY COMPLAINT.... TIED UP ON ANOTHER CALL IS LEGIT!! IF YALL WANT MORE OFFICERS TALK TO SOMEONE IN JACKSON!! BUT US HAVING CAPABLE OFFICERS SHOULD BE AN ABSOLUTE....
ilovedmydaughter

Kilmichael, MS

#72 Oct 27, 2011
Grow up Chasity. You didn't live in my house. I took good care of Amanda. She had everything she needed. The abused told lies to cover for their abuser. I talked to her everyday and saw her about every other day. Your brother was behind her going to get rid of her daughter. Happy to send you the letter too! You were not here when Amanda moved in with Casey and neither was I. I was at work at my hospice job thank you. If Amanda had killed Casey ya'll would be falling all over yourselves pissed. But no......he killed Amanda and ya'll are trying real hard to turn everything around and make him look innocent. Say what you want. I saw her hair pulled out and her bruises. I got stuff thrown at my house by him when he would come hunting her down. He let her lay sick with her diabetes at your mothers house when she called the ambulance. You need to do research on domestic violence. My daughter was murdered and ya'll try to lessen that with your oh pitiful me. AMANDA WAS MURDERED. Oh yeh, and you don't seem to be so worried about who brought him over there for some reason. Maybe they killed him. Maybe they beat him up? Why no concern? Do you know who did and afraid to turn one of his friends in? All I know is I was at work and got a call my daughter was shot and killed. I had nothing to do with this and everytime I turn around I'm being accussed of "knowing" things. I was as innocent as ya'll when this all happened. I came out my door the day ya'll brought some of Amanda's things to the house to hug your neck and you looked at me like you could run through me. I had no idea why. I had to keep asking for Amanda's things back and still didn't get her dvd's. I furnished most all of her stuff. From kitchen to bathroom to bedroom. I was constantly giving her money. I told him to quit taking her money and for her to quit giving it to him. Another sign of abuse? All he ever did was laugh when I would say something. He had no RESPECT for anyone. Her car had no insurance on it and I told him not to drive it because it wouldn't be covered.....do you think he cared? Hell no!!!! Do you know what it's like to be a daddy and hear crap that you killed your own daughter? HUH? Then it's changed to he killed them both! Then now he's beat up Casey after he shot himself! Make up yall's mind!! Ya'll want to say all of this stuff about her daddy and make accussations then go see him. No ya'll have attacked me with it. I'm having the same trouble with MCSO that everyone else has. It was a big ole mess! And they know it. I'm biding my time as God's instruction. He will win and no one else. My daughter is dead and He will avenge it! I have nothing further to say to you. I have done nothing wrong as I was not there. Oh and neither were you. Feel free to call her daddy with your accusations. I don't know what happened to him if anything. I went to his grave upset and gonna cuss him but as I said I didn't as it was then I forgave him. I did not cuss him as you say.Read before you repost little girl. Oh and anyone that gets on here and says they know about being abused obviously knows what Amanda went through and the lies she had to live.
Mother

Olive Branch, MS

#73 Oct 27, 2011
kelly hall wrote:
<quoted text>
mother, WERE YOU THERE??? Or you also repeating hearsay????
No I was not there..I'm the mother of the witness.If there is anything you need to say then say it to me.
ilovedmydaughter

Kilmichael, MS

#74 Oct 27, 2011
Chasity_Caseys sister wrote:
<quoted text>
**Jealousy?? IT WAS ANOTHER MAN'S BABY!! Amanda did not want to keep Jaiden the whole entire time she was pregnant..Everybody was saying she was leaving and this and that.. Where was she going?? Because ALL her things were still at the Youngs house!!! casey did not hurt Amanda. They loved each other and it was THEIR life! Noone could stop them, and who would have wanted to? You are supposed to be supportive of any family members decision NO MATTER what it may be. Why would you want to make someone you love unhappy. FAMILY=STICKING TOGETHER! You would have beat the shit out of him dead or alive.. REALLY? You just showed what kind of person you are, and you are going to talk bad about my family??! HIPOCRITE! Don't sit there and say "And HE will take care of Caseys family if they call upon Him!! But we will all meet our judgement in time.Day by Day ...." and then talk about beating the shit out of someone..
and Casey got another girl pregnant while he was with Amanda. And you talk about jealousy. It was okay for Casey to be jealous but not Amanda? And she was pregnant before Casey come along too. She didn't find out until after they got together dear.
Kelly hall

United States

#75 Oct 28, 2011
Mother wrote:
<quoted text>No I was not there..I'm the mother of the witness.If there is anything you need to say then say it to me.
I didn't think I had held back... I SAID WHAT I WANTED TO AND STAND BEHIND WHAT I DID SAY...
I would love to talk to Jessica though...
Kelly hall

United States

#76 Oct 28, 2011
I SURE WOULDN'T MIND SPEAKING TO BUDDY......
Elaney Danielle Young

Tupelo, MS

#77 Mar 30, 2012
This is Casey's younger sister, Elaney Danielle Young. I am not here to speak on the behalf of Kimberly Ann Gatliff Carter Young, as she does not DESERVE my loyalty, or any other human being's. I am done with her imature things.
Just found out the actual truth on what happened about Casey's murder. Thank you once more Kimberly Ann Gatliff Carter Young. You are truly an absurd liar. I would love to see you try and hurt ANYONE here again. These people (Young Family) Are my TRUE family. I am sick of finding out things that you lied about! Things that you told me you NEVER did, yeah, you were the perfect stepmother. Liar. You treated them like they were nothing! What's worse is you treated me the same way, your own blood! You will reap what you sew. One day. Kimberly treated me, her daughter, horribly as Chasity said my whole life. In and out of foster care, though, if you ask Kim she will tell you it's because I lied. That is the lie. She hates to think she is wrong. KIM plays the victim all the time. It's a living Hell with her, I have had friends and boy-friends say that I shouldn't have to endure what I did for nearly fifteen years with her. She does nothing but complain and act like she is more important than everyone else in life, she acts like she is a badass when in reality she is a big-mouthed liar. Always has been. I finally got the courage to tell her my true opinion of her earlier in March and when I did she told me to call my 'good for nothing father' to come get me. I did and I live with the Young family. They have treated me 100 times better than her in every way possible.
Richard

New Albany, MS

#78 Apr 26, 2012
After receiving a call from my dad figured I would find this sight where I am been accused of writing something, Well I can honestly say it's not me, but damn I didn't even know all this, this is very intricate knowledge inside information.

But I will say this been all my family is always speaking of "Jesus" which is truth? And in the word of God said one statement in the entirety of the bible spoke of something he hates, A "Liar" So who is lying?"
Richard

New Albany, MS

#79 Apr 26, 2012
There's too much anger in here, the dead have found peace, and according to the bible they know nothing.

The living are the ones who have to struggle to find it again.

We all have sins, some worse than others, but a sin that can be repaired, is the sinner's job according to the bible to repair it or make amends with to one it hurt. You can carry sins even when you ask forgiveness. A repetitive sin with a repetitive "oh forgive me" becomes an unheard prayer then we risk been turned over to the reprobate mind. Hmm makes you wonder what's wrong with the world.(When we see wrong as right and right as wrong) and justify it. God turns away.
Kimberly Young

Brandon, MS

#80 Sep 28, 2012
sick of these people wrote:
but oh yes.... you are right... the truth always comes out
GET READY!!!!! CAN YOU BEAR IT?????
IT WILL BE MY NEW DILIGENT GOAL TO HELP GET THE TRUTH OUT AT ALL COSTS, I AM TRUELY ASHAMED OF MYSELF FOR NOT DOING ALL I COULD TO TELL IT BEFORE TODAY!!!
THESE PEOPLE MUST BE HELD ACCOUNTABLE, FOR THE PAIN AND HORROR THEY CONTINUE TO CAUSE IN THE LIVES OF ANYONE WHO DOES NOT PROMOTE THEIR FRAUDULENT EXISTANCE
Now that's a good story if I don't say so myself. I'm good at making shit up and causing problems by sticking my nose where it should never be... That includes smelling cocain.... I never snort it. I just love the way it smells. You have to forgive me; I am still upset at the fact that I lost everything including my daughter not because of the Young family but because I am a damn cocain head and a hypocrit.
Makenzie Holcomb

United States

#81 Feb 3, 2013
I don't really know if it i true or not and if people aren't a witness they have no room to be talking and it matters how casey was killed but if there not a witness then the need to get out of casey's death
anon

Tupelo, MS

#82 Feb 4, 2013
" but if there not a witness then the need to get out of casey's death "
==========
Witnesses are unreliable the evidence is much more accurate.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 4
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Fulton Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
hope nelson cakes (Sep '13) Jun 18 WOW 4
Wanda Grimes Jun 17 Dana Grimes 2
Any one know these people? Jun 15 Whatever 3
News Fulton man in custody for suspected murder of h... Jun 14 neversaynever123 5
Matthew Gray Jun 14 magan 2
Kim Edwards Jun 14 jason 5
Iahs Jun 12 guccimane 10

Fulton Jobs

Personal Finance

Fulton Mortgages