Hickory Bar-B-Q reopens in Fort Myers

Hickory Bar-B-Q reopens in Fort Myers

There are 21 comments on the News Press story from Jan 18, 2010, titled Hickory Bar-B-Q reopens in Fort Myers. In it, News Press reports that:

A Fort Myers restaurant institution has been resurrected. Hickory Bar-B-Q, owned by the Davis family since 1956, quietly reopened Friday after being closed for more than six years.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at News Press.

First Prev
of 2
Next Last
Karol Sabo

Mooresville, NC

#1 Jan 19, 2010
There is a Bar-B-Que God! Thank you Bill for re-opening the "Pit"! We have missed you and your employee's,(and of course the best Bar-B-Q this side of Heaven!) Our family has been going to the Hickory since you first opened and we are blessed to have you back! Can't wait to visit Ft.Myers again! Thank you!
Mary Alex Sibbald

Cape Coral, FL

#2 Jan 19, 2010
We used to eat at the Hickory Bar-B-Q in the 1960s with our families. We always wanted a seat by the screen since there was no a/c. They had the best coconut cream pie ever! We slathered that barbeque sauce on everything from the bread to the corn on the cob. My wife screamed for joy when she heard they reopened. Plan to bring the kids and grandkids thanks for reopening.
Brian Burgess

Philadelphia, PA

#3 Feb 20, 2010
My brother, sister and I had our first taste of heavenly (Hickory) BBQ in the mid sixties with those paper bibs around our necks that were pulled from nails driven into the wooden posts. If we behaved ourselves, and used our manners, we were awarded a piece of coconut cream pie. Upon the birth of my children, we would mark their first excursion out of the house by going to the "Pit" and having their picture taken with the waitresses.

Hearing of the Hickory being opened again warrants a quick trip home. Praise God from whom all blessings flow!
BL G

Fort Myers, FL

#4 Mar 7, 2010
Mary Alex Sibbald wrote:
We used to eat at the Hickory Bar-B-Q in the 1960s with our families. We always wanted a seat by the screen since there was no a/c. They had the best coconut cream pie ever! We slathered that barbeque sauce on everything from the bread to the corn on the cob. My wife screamed for joy when she heard they reopened. Plan to bring the kids and grandkids thanks for reopening.
Please, where is it located.
BL G

Fort Myers, FL

#5 Mar 7, 2010
Where is the great Hickory Bar-B-Q located.
Elwin

Detroit, MI

#6 Mar 8, 2010
I got the squirts every time I ate there.
Suzanne Guthrie

Cape Coral, FL

#7 Jun 23, 2010
I LOVE this place!!! I can remember eating there when I was a small child, even the screened in windows!! When I lived on the beach, I ate there a couple times a week.Was sad when it closed. I read in the paper a while back, that it had reopened,but I forgot about it,as I live way out in N.ft.Myers. Well, I'm working down by the old place,have got to get there again!!! Hope the food is as great as I remember it!!!
Susan King

Fayetteville, NC

#8 Jul 12, 2010
Wow, I'm SO excited! What great memories we have of that restaurant! Is the food the same? Especially the coconut pie and slaw - same recipes? Has anybody from the good ol' days actually tasted the food to tell us if it's the same? A couple of years ago, my husband even tried to track down Bill Davis to see if he could get the recipe for the coconut pie to make for my birthday.
Guest

United States

#9 Jul 13, 2010
great memories cant wait to get there
guest

United States

#10 Jul 13, 2010
good good good
sad bbq fan

United States

#11 Aug 12, 2010
What happen to hickory bbq. It's closed.
Hickory Lover

Cape Coral, FL

#12 Nov 30, 2010
sad bbq fan wrote:
What happen to hickory bbq. It's closed.
It's NOT closed! It is open Monday - Thursday 10:45-2:30 and then on Friday and Saturday from 10:45-8:00. It is closed on Sundays for church. The food is exactly the same and as wonderful as it always was!!!!
Cottager1

Oshawa, Canada

#13 Feb 14, 2011
I just returned from a month's vacation at Fort Myers Beach and was thrilled to discover the Hickory Barbeque had reopened. I have been going there off and on since it first opened in 1056 and a visit to FMB was not complete without a visit there. So nice to see Bill there and the place and great food had not changed abit. In one month, I ate there 5 times. The very, very best coconut cream pie anywhere and still only $2.50!! Thank you Bill for opening!!

Whitby, Ontario, Canada
Rolando

Port Huron, MI

#14 Feb 14, 2011
where is it. i'll go there if they will promise that i won't get the hershey squirts. it sure is an old place if it opened in 1056...maybe they count differently in canada.
cjc

Rome, Italy

#16 May 8, 2011
The reopening of the Hickory BBQ is some of the best news I have ever received. I honestly mourned its closing. I thought I would never enjoy their sauce or coconut cream pie ever again. I was there in the summer of 2010. It is every bit as good as ever. I can't tell the joy it gave me to hear from the lady at Dunkin Donuts (across the street) that it was open again. I truly thank God for this. Help Hickory to stay open by eating there as often as possible. Unfortunately, that is only once per year for me.
Leann

Myrtle Beach, SC

#17 Jul 31, 2011
Susan King wrote:
Wow, I'm SO excited! What great memories we have of that restaurant! Is the food the same? Especially the coconut pie and slaw - same recipes? Has anybody from the good ol' days actually tasted the food to tell us if it's the same? A couple of years ago, my husband even tried to track down Bill Davis to see if he could get the recipe for the coconut pie to make for my birthday.
We recently went there 7/21/2011..........don't know about the pie but the bbq sauce was the same and I have been tryin to create it on my own as I live in SC.......food is just as yummy!!!!!!!!!!
Buckingham by God

Lehigh Acres, FL

#18 Jun 24, 2012
They have the best pulled pork sandwich in the tri-county area. The sauce and Cole slaw is second to none. Never seem to have room left for pie, but I'll work on that. By the time I'm through eating I'm happier than a fat tick a a lazy dog. Keep up the good work guys. Don't change a thing.

Since: Jun 12

Location hidden

#19 Jul 1, 2012
Sounds like a place I must visit! Love BBQ!

Since: Jun 12

Location hidden

#20 Jul 1, 2012
15400 Old McGregor Boulevard Fort Myers. Got this from google, hope it is right
guest

Clearwater, FL

#21 Oct 23, 2013
very disappointed in the food and service. Not at all the same rustic charm that we all loved. Strange short hours for lunch ONLY during the week. The place was almost empty except for the employees who didn't seem very happy to be there. To make matters worse, something I ate didn't seem to agree with my stomach. We wont be going back sadly.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 2
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Fort Myers Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
The REAL reason for all the mass shootouts in A... Thu Prince John 2
Eva Schaffer (Mar '11) Feb 20 Dahone 2
Single men forbidden by Federal law within less... Feb 20 stupid 5
Single/lone guys are sore losers and belong dea... (Apr '17) Feb 20 Carl 17
Non-business chatting with wait staff is a capi... Feb 20 Carl 2
Guys, taking pictures of/with a taken bartender... Feb 20 Carl 4
Guys, hugging a taken bartender is the surest w... Feb 20 Carl 21

Fort Myers Jobs

More from around the web

Personal Finance

Fort Myers Mortgages